3 ms·
Now good luck with students who were homeschooled, that's yet another huge can of worms waiting to explode (and it's bigger than "just" not being able to spell
by mschuster91 9y ago
Now good luck with students who were homeschooled, that's yet another huge can of worms waiting to explode (and it's bigger than "just" not being able to spell correctly). Next to no quality control, plus parents are free to "teach" their kids by religious rules.
Poor kids.
- analog31 9y agoThis has been going on for quite some time now, maybe a couple of decades. Homeschool kids have diverged into at least a couple of camps. I live in a relatively affluent, liberal town, that hosts a major public university. My kids are in an activity that's also quite popular among homeschool families, so I've met a few of those kids. They're great kids, and tend to be ahead of their public school peers academically, while being on a par socially. Then I was just talking to a relative who lives in another state, and his observation was quite different: The homeschool kids in his locale are practically uncivilized.
- sheepmullet 9y agoHomeschooled kids as a cohort do very well compared to kids in the public system. And what do you mean teach by religious rules? While it does depend on your state most states have a set curriculum for homeschooled kids.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Homeschooled kids as a cohort do very well compared to kids in the public system. The problem are those that fail miserably because their parents are rednecks with a deep trust towards the state combined with a fanaticism towards the Bible. They get overlooked when one only looks at the cohort/average. > And what do you mean teach by religious rules? Kids homeschooled (or, even worse, religiously schooled) by religious sects of any color: Jehovahs Witnesses, Twelve Tribes (these caused a major child abuse scandal in Germany a couple years ago), Amish, ultraorthodox Jews, salafist Muslims, Scientology or whatever. Basically, anything ranging from "you must not see kids of other faiths/gender", "you must not interact with kids being homosexual/non-cisheterosexual" to "you decide to leave our sect, you're dead to your family". Or, in Amish (or similar) communities: the kids actually never interact with normal kids and experience freedom. With state mandated schools, the parents cannot withhold that experience from the kids.
- sheepmullet 9y ago> They get overlooked when one only looks at the cohort/average. Ok, so can we compare the bottom 25th percentiles? A few of my family members went to public school and are functionally illiterate. Are these homeschooled kids worse off than that? > Kids homeschooled (or, even worse, religiously schooled) by religious sects of any color Oh so you weren't talking about education at all then. You were talking about the benefits of the state pushing its moral values onto kids. I'd rather err on the side of the parents than on the side of the state. I went to public school and was violently assaulted at school at least a half a dozen times and verbally harassed dozens more. I wouldn't give the state any moral authority.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Are these homeschooled kids worse off than that? They were both f..d up by the system and I'm sorry to hear that. No kid deserves having his life destroyed by a screwed up education. > Oh so you weren't talking about education at all then. Creationism, for example, is not education (and yes, I know, some public schools have been forced to teach that crap too, but that's actually the perfect example why religion should not touch education in ANY way). > I went to public school and was violently assaulted at school at least a half a dozen times and verbally harassed dozens more. Violent assaults are nothing exclusive to public schools, they happen at private schools too. And when I look at scandals of sexual abuse and violence (from teachers!) here in Germany, most of these have happened in private schools. > I wouldn't give the state any moral authority. At least I would give the state more authority than the churches or religious nutjobs.
- sheepmullet 9y ago> No kid deserves having his life destroyed by a screwed up education. And yet it is not uncommon. Where I live if you look at overall education homeschooling provides the best results, followed by private schools, and then public schools bring up the rear. > Creationism, for example, is not education That's neither here nor there. Millions of people who went through the public system here believe in creationism and it certainly wasn't taught in schools. Like I said in my original post the curriculum is still determined by the state for homeschool and private schools. > Violent assaults are nothing exclusive to public schools, they happen at private schools too. Of course they do. I guess my point is the media will focus on teacher related scandals etc. However, the overwhelming majority of physical and sexual abuse is student on student. As such the likelihood of physical or sexual abuse while homeschooled is likely an order of magnitude lower than at public school. > At least I would give the state more authority than the churches or religious nutjobs. The authority belongs with the parents. If your parents are horrible and abusive then you are in for a rough life. It is horrible and true regardless of whether you go to public school or not.