9 ms·
What's Wrong with Students?
- danieltillett 9y agoI was going to post the great Socrates quote on this topic - The children now love luxury. They have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise.[0], but like all quotes that follow Tillett’s Law [1] Socrates didn’t say it. 0. https://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehaving-children-in-ancient-times/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/01/misbehaving-childre... 1. The more famous the authority quoted the less likely it is accurate.
- edflsafoiewq 9y agoThis attitude (let's not call it a quote) seems to often be offered up as evidence that there isn't much merit to such inter-generational kvetching. But if this attitude was contemporaneous with Socrates and Plato, then the Hellenic world was indeed in decline (Rome would conquer Greece in only a few hundred years and in Spengler's regime the whole Apollonian world had already entered its autumn period) and why should the recurrence not be because our own world has reached a homologous point in its development?
- lmm 9y agoSocrates is far from being the pinnacle; the pre-Socratic philosophers are seen as having accomplished little, whereas Plato and Aristotle are immensely influential, and presumably part of the generation referred to.
- Viliam1234 9y agoThe quote is made up. And the important question is why do we have the strong desire to make up quotes like this. What exactly are we trying to deny?
- tomtimtall 9y agoDid you read the link? The paragraph wasn’t made up. It is a summation of attitudes towards children at the time. My bet would be that it was falsely wrapped up into a quote because it simplifies origin and time frame to better underline the point.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoOne of my coworkers who is in his early/mid 20s didn't know what Leap Year was until his Junior year. He went to elite private schools in the Bay Area, probably among the most elite, and then went to a very good college. The idea that he could escape knowing what Leap Year was made me question whether I should home school my children.
- yakz 9y agoParents (i.e. the customers) have influence, the product that they are buying isn't necessarily an academic education for their children.
- milankovic 9y agoYes, I agree. The real cause of this issue.
- bittercynic 9y agoI don't think it's necessarily a huge failing to not know about this/not teach your kid about it. Different kids have different curiosities, and as long as he is intellectually curious, and just didn't happen upon that particular calendrical oddity, then no biggie. However, I've seen some evidence that it is possible to do well at elite bay area schools without having much intellectual curiosity, and most teachers will give you high marks just for hard work and obedience. I'd say you are likely to come out ahead if you ignore elite status, and instead focus on whether teachers at your kids' schools nourish their intellectual curiosity.
- rhino369 9y agoEveryone has weird gaps in their knowledge. Especially things that are common knowledge. I wouldn’t want a school covering leap year.
- JamisonM 9y agoI agree with the "weird gaps in knowledge" part, but I would want a school covering leap years. Leap years are an excellent introduction to astronomy and our solar system.
- tptacek 9y agoI went to Catholic college prep high school in the 1990s. My kids, public high school (albeit: a suburban public high school) over the last 6 years. I had to write a shitload of papers. My kids have to write a shitload of papers. If anything: their education is more rigorous than was mine. If my kids get(/got) "cats" vs. "cats'" incorrect, they'll get dinged for it. I kind of want to call bullshit on this analysis.
- analog31 9y agoJust want to chime in: Likewise with my kids. They've been writing paper after paper since middle school. Both have been taught a lot about good writing and critical thought. Other subjects are similarly rigorous. My kids study more in high school than I studied in college. With that said, there's certainly a disparity in education quality depending on where you live, and how affluent you are. In addition, for kids who attend college, there's a disparity across departments and majors based on the high school background of the students. It is possible that for whatever reason, the author of that article ended up assigned to teaching a "fluff" course at their college.
- mintplant 9y agoYep. Relatively recent product of the American public high school system here [0], and soon-to-be product of the public university system. If anything I had to write many more papers in my high school classes than in my college ones. I don't know what planet these guys are living on. > Well, the night before, I studied probably pretty close to an hour." And with that the scales fell from my eyes. > "An hour? Do you realize that when I was in college it was common to start studying for big exams a week or more before?" I suspect the professor has forgotten just how much college students have on their plates at any given time. An Intro to Philosophy class may not be everyone's top priority. [0] Starting in Louisiana and finishing in California.
- x0x0 9y agoCollege students also frequently work. Four decades ago, you really could pay for college with a minimum wage summer job. Now, it would require far more than a year's full time work. https://newrepublic.com/article/122814/how-many-hours-would-it-take-you-work-todays-college-tuition https://newrepublic.com/article/122814/how-many-hours-would-...
- thebeardedone 9y agoAmusingly I had a similar experience while holding a tutorial for math 2 at my university. After an hour a student asked me what the integral symbol is, as if she has never seen it before. Now I do not find this very tragic as I would gladly recap anything and working throughout my studies I know one might not be able to get through all of the content, but good luck studying when you are missing the basics to even understand the problem at hand.
- WalterBright 9y agoIn freshman physics at Caltech I cancelled out the d's in dx/dt. But I knew something was terribly wrong, and I sought out the professor after lecture. He asked me if I knew what a derivative was, and I said no. He suggested I come to his office later. He gave me a half hour lecture illustrating the basics of integration and differentiation. It was the most useful half hour of my life, and it got me through the semester. Prof. Gomez pretty much saved my @ss. No, my public high school had not offered calculus in any way, shape or form. My fellow freshmen couldn't believe I had come to Caltech utterly ignorant of calculus.
- WalterBright 9y agoI had other problems too - did not know how to study, did not know how to take notes, did not know how to organize my time, I'd never had to work at school before, thought I could skip lecture and wing the exams, etc. It took until my sophomore year to get my act together. Fortunately, freshman year at Caltech was pass/fail, and I barely scraped by that year.
- ggtyh 9y agoWhat were some of the methods you developed and used?
- WalterBright 9y agoIt was straightforward: 1. attend all lectures 2. do all of the homework on time 3. make sure I understood how to do 100% of the homework problems 4. get help with anything I didn't understand 5. write down everything that the prof wrote on the blackboard 6. clean up my handwriting so it was legible 7. lectures/homework/studying always came first
- guuz 9y agoI suppose I've got just a normal third world education, but even with my poor background I considered the cats example somewhat extreme. Is this kind of thing really common?
- trymas 9y agoI guess there is quite a paradox, that non-native English speakers know some grammar concepts better than the native ones. I also think that it's an extreme example and somewhat I refuse to believe that college students do not know the difference. I also was told that non-native speakers can better distinguish between 'well' and 'good', and the usual suspects 'you', 'your', 'you're'. The latter is so basic that I am bewildered when native speakers cannot understand the difference.
- guuz 9y agoI did not know this, quite interesting. I will try to find an explanation of the phenomena
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gattr 9y agoEnglish is my second language. I'd say it's due to the fact that when you learn a language in school, by listening AND writing, it'll stick in your head visually. I never mistake its/it's, they're/their etc., something I can frequently see native speakers do on the Web in their comments.
- Jemmeh 9y agoHaving done 2nd grade in the Philippines and the rest of my education in the USA, I would say that their schooling is much more difficult and they are pushed harder. In addition the school days were longer and the culture there really promoted the importance of academic success. Here in the USA it's almost frowned upon to some degree-- if you're smart, you're a nerd. And yes, at least in my area (Southeast USA) people do not know punctuation rules. Most of them write okay, but comma splices, apostrophes, semicolons, etc. would trip them up.
- lunchladydoris 9y agoMake sure you read Bryan Caplan's article in The Atlantic too [0]. [0]: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/01/whats-college-good-for/546590 https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/01/whats-c...
- SubiculumCode 9y agoMy writing was appalling out of high school, but it is passable today. That was only achieved after writing chapter after paper after chapter in my Ph.D. work. Writing takes practice, and is hard work and time consuming. I worked with my high school son on a report recently. His writing and organization was also appalling, yet this is a very bright kid; I've administered a number of cognitive and IQ batteries on him. Only after showing him how to arrange his arguments cohesively and logically, did he start to see the flaws in his writing. It takes practice and instruction, and I don't think that the school system makes it a priority. I could excuse my high school, coming from an impoverished district, but I see it also in the children of my son's school in an affluent school district.
- quasse 9y agoIt depends strongly on the school. I received almost a whole year of instruction on analyzing other people's arguments, spotting the use of logical fallacies, and constructing your own coherent arguments. We spent a lot of time reading both "news" and opinion articles from current events and analyzing how the author was trying to influence you / the quality of their arguments. I still count it as one of the most influential classes I have ever taken, and it was 11th grade English at a public school.
- StanislavPetrov 9y agoI recently went back to school (a nearby state university) after a 15 year absence from academia to get another degree. In one course, a number of my fellow students were pursing their ME. None of them were there out of a zeal for knowledge. Rather, New York State requires teachers to obtain a master's degree in teaching (or a related discipline) within five years of the completion of their initial degree. Without exception, the literacy and critical thinking skills of these students (several of which were already teachers), was absolutely atrocious. I was astounded at the total inability of these teachers (and teaching candidates) to read and write coherently. Granted, this was a state school and not a respected Ivy League university, but the lack of even basic literacy among these graduate students was shocking. Most struggled mightily to get through the class. Several dropped out to take courses with less demanding professors. To my knowledge, they all got their degrees, and are today teaching in our schools. How can we expect our children to become literate if those who teach them are not? The most important facet of education is teaching a child how to think. It is far more important to teach a child how to absorb the thoughts of others (reading) and express their own thoughts coherently (writing) than saturate them with information that they cannot retain or process properly. We are depriving our children of the tools they need to be thoughtful, and our society is suffering as a result.
- jseliger 9y agoI'd add that both teaching well and learning well are difficult skills: https://jakeseliger.com/2011/01/24/why-dont-students-like-school-daniel-t-willingham https://jakeseliger.com/2011/01/24/why-dont-students-like-sc... Many teachers and professor also develop unfortunate carapaces; if a student wants real coaching and mentoring, it helps to think about those carapaces: https://jakeseliger.com/2010/10/02/how-to-get-your-professors%E2%80%99-attention-or-how-to-get-the-coaching-and-mentorship-you-need https://jakeseliger.com/2010/10/02/how-to-get-your-professor...
- gumby 9y agoA TL;DR for the apparently irony impaired: The letter writer is a self-described humorist and appears to be doing an elaborate “kids these days” joke. Giveaways ate things like the 10-second pause for “cats, cat’s...” and the lovely ‘“What did you do in English class?" I asked. Answers: Listened to records, watched videos, talked about movies and current events.’
- draw_down 9y agoMmm, don’t think so.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eximius 9y agoSomething I don't think people here are taking into account is the bias inherent in this forum and the variance in education. I had to write a ton of papers in high school (less in college, but that happens when you study math). Some childhood friends of mine who went to a different school got stressed because they had to color a map (with colored pencils). The difference in rigor levels was astounding.
- gizmo686 9y agoI wrote more in some of my high school math classes then I did in all but one of my college classes. My college English classes felt like going back to middle school.
- lewilewilewi 9y agoIt's ironic that the author misuses the word 'comprises' in his rant about the quality of English education. Things never comprise of - a group comprises the parts, or it is composed of the parts. The parts compose the whole.
- pvg 9y agoThat ship sailed so long ago, fussing over it seems like futile pedantry. Webster seems to have the right idea calling it an idiom. Take a look these - there's 'comprised of' in the New York Times in the 1860s: https://query.nytimes.com/search/sitesearch/?action=click&contentCollection®ion=TopBar&WT.nav=searchWidget&module=SearchSubmit&pgtype=Homepage#/%2522comprised%2520of%2522/ https://query.nytimes.com/search/sitesearch/?action=click&co... Edit: Something a bit more recent - a 4600 word profile of Charlie Brooker in the New Yorker in which a sentence begins with 'Comprised of': https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/11/28/the-speculative-dread-of-black-mirror https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/11/28/the-speculativ...
- msla 9y agoThe things people get pedantic about are never the things which are the actual rules of English. In simple terms, if something were an actual rule, nobody would need to be pedantic about it, because everyone would follow it unconsciously, like they follow the rule that adjectives precede nouns in the simplest possible case, not the opposite, or in any other order: "The big red ball", not "The ball red, big", or "The red ball big". The things which pedants go on about are best seen as a failed attempt to "improve" the language, an exercise in conlang construction using an extant language as the base. This is how it was with the prohibition on splitting infinitives: A split infinitive is perfectly good English, but it is impossible in Latin, where the infinitive form is one word. So, operating on the dogma that Latin was more fashionable... more correct than English, the pedants attempted to modify English to be more Latinate by insisting that splitting infinitives was ungrammatical in English. It was only ungrammatical in their little conlang, which never quite caught on. The pedants did have one victory: The Latin word for "debt" is spelled with a 'b', "debitum", whereas the former English spelling was fairly phonetic: "dette", or similar, with no 'b'. The pedants got most English speakers to accept the conlang spelling, "debt", as "more correct", as part of their larger, largely unsuccessful, program to Latin-ify English.
- learc83 9y agoI think the most likely explanation for this story is that the students thought the professor was asking a trick question, so no one wanted to raise their hand. I went to high school and university in Georgia (our high school graduation rate and quality scores consistently rank in the bottom half of states). I have never heard of an English class where the students "Listened to records, watched videos, talked about movies and current events" and never had to write an essay.
- jschwartzi 9y agoOr nobody wanted to respond to the professor contemptuously ridiculing their grammar skills. Students can smell it on you.
- gizmo686 9y agoIn my experience, "English" classes is a broad catagory that refers more to literature (broadly defined) then the language. Granted, in my highschool practically every class involved essays, but my movies "English" class didn't involve any more than my math classes did. (Admittedly, I do not know how to compare the length of a math paper with the length of an English paper). >I think the most likely explanation for this story is that the students thought the professor was asking a trick question, so no one wanted to raise their hand. This example reminds me of my syntax (linguistics) proffesor, who would frequently ask "are people not answering because they don't know, or because it is obvious". It also froze me for several minutes as I tried to figure out what is going on with cats/cat's/cats'. (I gave up because I cannot figure out how I pronounce cats'. There is either nothing weird going on, or some weird morphology).
- nmstoker 9y agoThe article has some grains of truth but seems to overlook many areas, but the three I'd highlight are that numbers have dramatically increased, facilities / organisation is much improved and students for the large part work very hard now (in higher tier institutions at least). It's such a diverse field I'm sure people could debate over examples for ages but it probably does benefit to try to simplify it this way. Where I'd suggest society might want to look is how we ensure that the overall higher education offering can be optimised to obtain the best outcome for the greatest number of people. Clearly it isn't for all and not treating alternatives (eg apprenticeships and other channels) as interior is a start. Something also needs to be done about the spiralling costs from the arms race between institutions and the increasing portion taken by senior staff at the expense of average staff.
- yodsanklai 9y ago> I often said that, in my experience, out of a class of thirty students only about five would normally possess the minimum requirements for a college student The question is what to do with these students... What should a teacher do when half of his students don't have the prerequisites to follow his class?
- danieltillett 9y agoWhen I as an academic I used to run extra classes at lunch time for the keen students covering topics that I thought the students needed to learn about, but for which we didn't have time in class. Theses topics were not covered in the exam so only those students interested in learning came. As for those students that don't have the prerequistes or the motivation to do the work to catch up, you fail as many as the university will allow and then scale up the class mark so the rest pass. At my university I couldn't fail more than 3% or 4%, but in some classes more than half really failed.
- downrightmike 9y agoThe professor should write a meaningful intro text book and deliver it as a pdf, rather than use some $400 Wiley textbook they get a kickback from and the chapter and questions get resorted each year so that used books are useless. This is all a racket. Does anyone think that the 25/30 remedial students are going to pay for a $400 or more textbook when they've got more immediate needs (shelter, food, clothing) to pay for?
- mschuster91 9y agoNow good luck with students who were homeschooled, that's yet another huge can of worms waiting to explode (and it's bigger than "just" not being able to spell correctly). Next to no quality control, plus parents are free to "teach" their kids by religious rules. Poor kids.
- analog31 9y agoThis has been going on for quite some time now, maybe a couple of decades. Homeschool kids have diverged into at least a couple of camps. I live in a relatively affluent, liberal town, that hosts a major public university. My kids are in an activity that's also quite popular among homeschool families, so I've met a few of those kids. They're great kids, and tend to be ahead of their public school peers academically, while being on a par socially. Then I was just talking to a relative who lives in another state, and his observation was quite different: The homeschool kids in his locale are practically uncivilized.
- sheepmullet 9y agoHomeschooled kids as a cohort do very well compared to kids in the public system. And what do you mean teach by religious rules? While it does depend on your state most states have a set curriculum for homeschooled kids.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Homeschooled kids as a cohort do very well compared to kids in the public system. The problem are those that fail miserably because their parents are rednecks with a deep trust towards the state combined with a fanaticism towards the Bible. They get overlooked when one only looks at the cohort/average. > And what do you mean teach by religious rules? Kids homeschooled (or, even worse, religiously schooled) by religious sects of any color: Jehovahs Witnesses, Twelve Tribes (these caused a major child abuse scandal in Germany a couple years ago), Amish, ultraorthodox Jews, salafist Muslims, Scientology or whatever. Basically, anything ranging from "you must not see kids of other faiths/gender", "you must not interact with kids being homosexual/non-cisheterosexual" to "you decide to leave our sect, you're dead to your family". Or, in Amish (or similar) communities: the kids actually never interact with normal kids and experience freedom. With state mandated schools, the parents cannot withhold that experience from the kids.
- jancsika 9y ago> Answers: Listened to records, watched videos, talked about movies and current events. Amazing-- a class of (apparently) 30 students mysteriously synchronized on three answers to a wide open question. And alarm bells didn't go off in the professor's head that maybe there's some confirmation bias going on in this non-scientific survey. Also amazing-- once the professor figured out that his students didn't have the prerequisites to understand the material, his next question was not how much debt the students had taken on in order to pay for this and presumably other classes they have no chance of understanding. This is especially irresponsible given that a) if they can't read on a third grade level it is certain they can't calculate compound interest and b) freshmen were enrolled who the professor could have at least convinced to drop out before accumulating so much debt they'd never be able to pay it back. But instead of a courageous act of dissuading them from continuing down what is clearly the wrong patch-- an act which no doubt would have brought the dean's wrath-- he shames them for not having had a quality education-- something that is safe to belly-ache about to colleagues. And he left teaching anyway! Question: did he give the money back to those students who had no chance of learning anything from the class he was paid to teach?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anonred 9y ago> his next question was not how much debt the students had taken on ... But instead of a courageous act of dissuading them Can you explain how you arrived at this conclusion from the letter? The author literally transitions from "... watched videos, talked about movies and current events" to describing another event. There's nothing about what he said or did after realizing his students' academic inadequacies.
- emmelaich 9y agoI have children in a good public school, in Australia. It is dismaying how much time they spend watching movies. I find the quality of the texts tends to contemporary issues and is of uneven literary quality to put it mildly. Only the advanced English classes spend time on classic texts. (apart from some Shakespeare - of whom everyone gets some exposure)
- chatmasta 9y agoPerhaps the question should be rephrased to, "What's Wrong with [secondary school] Teachers?" In the US, we only compensate our teachers $20-40k a year. For a skilled practitioner in a field, teaching presents an untenable opportunity cost. Most fields pay their experts at least four times the salary of teaching. Therefore the only reason for an expert to apply his skills to teaching becomes passion or a sense of duty. On the other hand, a non-expert may become a teacher because it is his only option. So we either get teachers who are both expert and passionate, or teachers who are non-expert and possibly even non-passionate. How can we expose students to more passionate, expert teachers? The clear solution is to reduce the opportunity cost of teaching for the expert. He should be able to engage his passion or satisfy his sense of duty without also sacrificing the benefits of a career in industry. The obvious way to reduce this opportunity cost is to pay teachers more. However, blindly raising salaries is an expensive and lazy solution. It risks attracting the group of passionless semi-experts who can barely get a job in industry. A more targeted approach would be to make it easier for experts to engage their passion, or satisfy their sense of duty, by participating in short-term, low-commitment teaching. Why should working and teaching be mutually exclusive? I propose that schools allocate a small budget for a new class of "temporary teachers," who keep full-time jobs in industry, but also attend class on a weekly basis to augment the permanent teacher. For example, a programmer could come to class once a week to teach or interact with the students. This would benefit the students by exposing them to a skilled practitioner in the field, help the practitioner by satisfying his passions or sense of duty, and utilize the permanent teacher for his specialty. It seems like an effective and cheap solution.
- late2part 9y agoYour salary range estimates for teachers are low. Average starting salary is $36k with population average of $56k. https://www.google.com/amp/s/articles.niche.com/teacher-salaries-in-america/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/articles.niche.com/teacher-sala...
- HarryHirsch 9y agoschools allocate a small budget for a new class of "temporary teachers," who keep full-time jobs in industry, but also attend class on a weekly basis to augment the permanent teacher Adjuncts, in other words.
- mikerathbun 9y agoMy son is graduating this year from the #5 ranked public High School in a top 10 population sized city in the US. In his four years he has never had to write a research paper or read a class assigned book. When he fails a test he is allowed to correct the errors and receive a 70% for the final test grade. His AP Computer Science class was mostly playing games and learning to create websites in HTML. I went through the same school district in the early 1990s and had a vastly different experience and did well in college. He is absolutely not prepared for college but the kid is a master at taking state standardized tests. I wish I had taken a more active role with his education instead of just assuming his school was getting him ready. My advice to moms and dads who have kids getting ready for High School is to participate and monitor what they are learning and find a way to fill in any gaps.
- nerdponx 9y agoDon't assume it gets better in college. It's very possible for a smart kid to go to a good school and not get a good education. If your son does in fact plan on attending college, make sure he has an advisor who is willing and able to take an active role in his education. Not every kid knows what they want, and not every kid figures it out on their own. Source: I was that kid.