6 ms·
Ignoring false positives for a second, isn't this easily fooled by putting on a prosthetic nose or something? Or plastic surgery? Hollywood makeup is pretty goo
by astura 9y ago
Ignoring false positives for a second, isn't this easily fooled by putting on a prosthetic nose or something? Or plastic surgery? Hollywood makeup is pretty good at drastically altering someone's appearance in a few hours at the most. I don't know why a motivated terrorist can't just change their appearance before bombing a plane.
Who is this really going to stop?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIt's not even that hard. Grow a long beard and get punched in the face the day before your flight.
- EpicEng 9y agoThe goal isn't to have a 100% success rate, it's to work most of the time in order to speed up processing.
- bobwaycott 9y agoI believe you are confusing the rationale provided for the goal.
- Rebelgecko 9y agoThis isn't speeding up an existing process, it's adding a new one. My understanding is that you still need a TSA person to look at your ID when you go through security
- QAPereo 9y agoI feel like even a mediocre TSA agent is going to be suspicious about the heavily bearded man with a serious bruise on their face. I mean, unless that matches your passport!
- mynameisvlad 9y agoWhat, exactly, are they going to be suspicious about in this hypothetical of yours? Humans are pretty good at matching up facial features naturally, a black eye and beard aren't going to trip up anybody looking at you.
- QAPereo 9y agoAgain, this assumes your passport matches, and humans are trained to spot the unusual. Guy with a massive beard he did’t have on his passport, plus a bruise sufficient to fool he camera is suspicious don’t you think? Once again, this also assumes that being recognized is a problem, which is why you’re evading the scanner. I don’t see how this works. Edit: Remember, it can’t be a valid passport that actually looks like you in this case or it defeats the point of the disguise. Remember, this only makes sense if you’re trying to evade detection, and it makes no sense to evade the camera by standing out like a sore thumb to the humans.
- newfoundglory 9y agoYou know passports are valid for ten years, right? Facial hair completely not matching the image is very common.
- realusername 9y agoUnlike what border control thinks, you are allowed to look different after 10 years, the picture on the passport is only there for reference and should not be used to identify people reliably.
- monksy 9y ago> punched in the face the day before your flight. Not a hard thing to have that happen to you these days considering the "pre-flight interview" they're now doing.
- drpgq 9y agoIt’s for verification based on your passport. If you don’t match you get more scrutiny. It cuts down on the cost of checking everyone.
- eesmith 9y agoRight now there's no in-person scrutiny upon exit, so I don't see how this would cut down the costs. DHS needs to justify the benefits and costs of creating such a system. That is, is visa overstay travel fraud enough to justify spending $1 billion on a system, and what failure rate is acceptable? If there are 1,000 cases of such fraud a year, then I don't think it's worthwhile. While many people overstay their visa, the vast majority are not going to get someone else to depart the country on their passport, which is what this system is supposed to prevent. Remember, even 10 seconds per passenger adds up. There were 243,195,022 international passengers in the year ending March. Figure 1/2 of them were departures. That's 121 million people. At 10 seconds per passenger that's 38 years of additional waiting. If we figure everyone's time is worth $7.25/hour then that's about $2.5 million of additional wasted time. How much fraud do we need to stop to make this time and money worthwhile? I'd rather spend that money on reducing a much bigger sort of fraud - the tens of billions in wage theft each year.
- kabdib 9y ago> If there are 1,000 cases of such fraud a year, then I don't think it's worthwhile. Well, it's probably not really for safety or security, and they clearly don't give a hoot if you're inconvenienced or not. Consider instead: - Government contracts routed to political constituents (follow the money -- we know the millimeter scanners were corruptly funded) - Tons of ground-truth data for further development and deployment. It'd be interesting to find out if they correlate against images captured by vanilla airport security cameras, as well as the cameras on the roadways or public transportation to the airport, and in rental car lots. This helps answer the question of "do we have to upgrade all the crappy domestic cameras to get ubiquitous surveillance, or can we get away with what's out there now?" A billion or two spent to catch one or two terrorists isn't the point; actual bad guys are utterly optional, and maybe even a distraction.
- QAPereo 9y agoThe problem with the disguise is that people are pretty good at seeing through, and the more prosthetics and make up you have on more obvious it is. It works in the movies with an editor and the lighting director and cameraman, but not so much in real life. Worse you’ve now given people a very good reason to stop you and question you further, because after all you’re wearing a disguise! You also have to consider that the disguise to fool a person, and the disguise to fool a computer might be very different, especially if the computer isn’t just using the visual spectrum to analyze you.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThat depends on the makeup artist, the face one starts with, and the degree of work involved. Source: working in film for a decade. The closer someone is to an average, the easier it is to make them look like someone else. This is one reason (among others) some actors 'disappear' into a role and others always look like themselves.
- QAPereo 9y agoI have faith in the power of makeup, but now let’s take this actor off the set. They can’t touch it up, they’re going to sweat, and they’ll be in real life and not on film. On the screen makeup is basically magic, I’ll totally grant that point, but life has limitations when you can’t yell “cut!” Still, this is very much IMO and I lack your experience in film.
- anigbrowl 9y agoYou'd be surprised at the changes that are possible with interior prosthetics alone. Alos, consider that about half the adult population can wear makeup without being considered remarkable for doing so. You might figure out a dude with a fake beard easily, but have less success at assessing the wrinkly old lady behind him.
- QAPereo 9y agoIt’s true, but by the same token it is subtle makeup that wouldn’t even begin to fool facial recognition, even if they don’t use Near-IR/UV. Do you think you could toe that line of fooling the camera and the human? If so, I’ll buy it, as I said you’re experienced in this field and I’m not.