4 ms·
> Religious figures, hopefully, will lose their relevance. People have been saying that for thousands of years. Hasn't happened yet, and isn't going to later.
by ars 9y ago
> Religious figures, hopefully, will lose their relevance.
People have been saying that for thousands of years. Hasn't happened yet, and isn't going to later.
That's essentially what the story of Hanukkah is all about. The Assyrian Greeks wanted the Jewish culture, but not the religion. Instead they got a religion that persisted despite pretty much the worst humanity has to offer - and has flourished despite it all.
If they couldn't do it, no one in the future can either (and science was just as important to them as it is to us, so don't try to use that as a "this time it's different").
It's also really not a nice sentiment. Virtually every single thing you consider a positive can be traced to ideas that came from religion. (Charity, helping your neighbor, community, law, proportional punishment (i.e. [the value of an] eye for an eye, instead of life for an eye), praising being a good person instead of a powerful person, the desire to give life meaning instead of hedonism - the list is almost endless.)
- soperj 9y ago>traced to ideas that came from religion None of those ideas necessarily came from religion.
- sp527 9y agoIt's shockingly ignorant and quite offensive to assert that fundamental tenets of morality and ethics originated in or necessarily had to be promulgated by religious doctrine.
- lamarpye 9y agoWhy? I don't find it offensive. I don't you can maintain morality long-term without religion.
- 8note 9y agoReligions don't impose morality on societies; they're a marketplace competing to communicate the society's morals. when society decided human sacrifices weren't moral, they ditched those religions in favour of ones without human sacrifice. it doesn't have to be a relgion that communicates what the morals are; some other structure can do that. morality itself seems to be good for societies ability to reproduce, so it'll probably stick around regardless.
- vadimberman 9y ago>> Religious figures, hopefully, will lose their relevance. > People have been saying that for thousands of years. Hasn't happened yet, and isn't going to later. I see. How many people worship Jupiter or Ba'al today? As the number of atheists and agnostics is growing in the West: https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/04/160422-atheism-agnostic-secular-nones-rising-religion/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/04/160422-atheism-a... and the Western trends are followed elsewhere, who is going to remember the mythical deities? > It's also really not a nice sentiment. Virtually every single thing you consider a positive can be traced to ideas that came from religion They didn't come from religion. They came from the social practices which worked for the society and got enshrined in some religions.
- jack9 9y ago> Virtually every single thing you consider a positive can be traced to ideas that came from religion. (e.g.) Charity, helping your neighbor, community, law, proportional punishment... You mean judeo-christian morality. The prevailing theory, as I understand it, is that this morality evolved from the play circuit that exists in mammals - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JI9n2yC14fU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JI9n2yC14fU A quote of his, which I cant find, sounds something like "For all the flaws in Catholicism, it's probably the closest that humanity has gotten [to an optimal moral framework]". I think that's overstated. The enduring religious orders that have survived thousands of years, do have a some sort of claim to such a thing. Generation after generation responding to archetypes (repeated in non-religious culture) is compelling, to me.