5 ms·
Walking and mass transit suck for people who are: traveling with kids, obese, disabled, short on time, carrying groceries, elderly, and/or in a place with bad w
by smt88 9y ago
Walking and mass transit suck for people who are: traveling with kids, obese, disabled, short on time, carrying groceries, elderly, and/or in a place with bad weather. That's not even mentioning people who can't afford to live in dense, central urban environments.
Self-driving, solar cars solve all problems of mass transit and are far cheaper, since they use existing roads.
- sandworm101 9y agoAnd anyone with more than a handbag to carry. Many workers travel with tools. Im going to training next month and have to bring about 80lbs of various stuff with me. Hauling that in and out of busses, not to mention finding places to secure it while i sleep/eat, wouldnt be much fun. But it all fits in my car nicely. And no, i cannot send it by courier.
- lostdog 9y agoMaybe you really do need a vehicle, but improving public transit and walkability would get a lot of other people out of your way.
- losteric 9y agoWhat kind of tools? Is there a functional reason for lugging your tools back and forth, or is that just how it's done? Could you leave those tools at work/training if they had secure storage? Alternatively, could the training facility offer a set of training tools while you keep your personal set at home for training?
- bdamm 9y agoYou clearly don’t do much work involving hand tools. The reasons to carry a portable tool locker on wheels are too numerous to mention. One, your locker, your key; theft is a major problem among contractor sites.
- sandworm101 9y agoIm in the military. Its a pile of cloathing, tent and other junk for survival training. A few days at a base in the woods learning to start fires. But it is 0430 now. My alarm just woke me up. I need to be at my office in an hour, where ill take over responsabilities from someone who started thier day before midnight. It's before dawn on december 26th. It's cold. The busses arent running. The uber drivers are all asleep. Some of us still have to get to work.
- kelnos 9y agoNo one is suggesting that there aren't special cases where using a car is the right move. But the vast majority of cases where people take cars, replacing that experience with better public transit is entirely reasonable. Hell, improving public transit would improve your use-case as well; you'd have less traffic to compete with while driving.
- sandworm101 9y agoUnless the goal is to pay for public transit by making car travel more expensive/painful. Then it is unfair to force all the carpenters to cover the costs for the office workers.
- losteric 9y agoThat's an incomplete view of the problem. Public transportation is used by people from all walks of life. Not just office workers - cooks, nurses, artists, school teachers, police officers, even employees of trade companies... and every citizen benefits from reduced traffic, lower infrastructure costs, and better health. Using car taxes to fund public transportation would not materially impact the carpenter. They'd just charge a little more. An absurdly high $1000/year tax spread across 50 clients is merely $20 per job - a more realistic $200/y tax would add $4 per job. Considering that public transportation increase average disposable income, the market can easily absorb that cost.
- sandworm101 9y ago>> They'd just charge a little more. And so too can the office workers. To charge one group for the benefit of another, based solely on the manner of their employ, is the definition of unfair. This is what progressive taxation is for, not use taxes.
- losteric 9y agoWhat? You either selectively read my response, or you're being deliberately obtuse with your focus on office workers. Car taxes ensure the market accurately captures negative externalities. There is no discrimination - if a doctor, CEO, and a plumber use cars equally, they are taxed equally. In contrast, low/absent car taxes are discriminatory subsidies. For businesses that require car usage, the tax is merely an operating cost. There is no impact on profit as operating costs are passed on to the consumer. Of course, allocating that revenue is still subject to local voters' wishes.
- AlphaSite 9y agoSure, but office workers for example would not have your issue.
- hanbura 9y ago>Self-driving, solar cars solve all problems of mass transit and are far cheaper, since they use existing roads. They don't solve the arguably most important issue: road capacity. A bus that takes the same space on the road as 2-3 cars seats 30 people (and holds another 30 standing). Self-driving cars enable somewhat more efficient traffic patterns, but they will have a hard time overcoming the order-of-magnitude lead that buses have. And that's not even mentioning subways, those don't impact roads at all and move staggering amounts of people
- fatbob 9y agoBuses are not always full. Their average capacity does not have an order of magnitude advantage.
- notatoad 9y agoneither are roads. it doesn't matter how full the bus is when the road is empty, but the number of cars that a bus is taking off the road at peak road usage time is pretty close to the full capacity of the bus, in any bus system i've ever ridden.
- michaelmior 9y agoThis is assuming that everyone who is on the bus would be driving/riding in a car instead, which I'm not sure is true.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fatbob 9y agoGood point - maybe buses will stay around just for peak usage, but will be replaced by rented, right-sized self-driving cars for the rest of the time.
- so33 9y agoThe NYC subway accounts for 5 million trips each day, taking millions of cars off the road because they don’t need to exist in the first place. Traveling with kids? Something people do with public transit and walking every day. Promoting walking encourages healthy lifestyles; promoting driving (or just sitting in a car and not doing anything) encourages the opposite. Elderly or disabled people take public transit all the time. Short on time or carrying a bunch of groceries? Live out in the far suburbs? Then public transit isn’t for you. But it takes passengers who aren’t short on time off the roads, making your trip faster. Edit: Cities with bad weather have adapted the cities to support public transit and walking (think covered, elevated walkways in Asia). It’s not a zero sum game. Self driving cars will be great. Public transit is great (and can be great in more places 0if cities made more investment). Both can and should exist.
- visarga 9y agoWe have had self driving vehicles for a long time - they're called busses, taxis and trains, and can take many people at once who don't need to drive or own the transport. We're just automating that last one human who needs to hold the wheel of the bus/taxi/train and extending the reach of the network. I'm a little bit worried about self driving cars being used for auto-detaining people and delivering them to police/terrorists. When you get into a sdc, you lose your ability to get off anywhere you want, it might lock up the doors and deliver you to the mafia or police for all you know. Remember "auto-detention" I invented it here and now. :-)
- heyalexej 9y agoThe only way to travel in a SDC is with a set of diagonal pliers and screwdriver in you pocket.
- smt88 9y agoI agree both can exist. The original article argues against SDC investment in favor of mass transit. I agree public transit is unequivocally great and important. I don't agree that most of our investment dollars should go to mass public transit over SDC public fleets. NYC is an exception and can't be replicated in most places, and the lack of transit options are still a burden on the groups I mentioned.
- petre 9y agoThese are all examples of European mass transit users. We even have places designated fir disabled, injured and elderly people on every bus, tram and metro.
- kelnos 9y agoHell, we even have that on SF buses and trains, and our transit is terrible. I regularly see people on Muni buses in wheelchairs, alone and unassisted.
- smt88 9y agoI never said these trips don't happen or aren't possible. I said individual, point-to-point options are better for a variety of riders.