6 ms·
Cash Might Be King, but They Don’t Care
- Finnucane 9y agoA clean, legal way to refuse service to anyone without a credit card.
- walterbell 9y agoThe named stores are also "healthy" options, so we have decided as a society that bankers decide who eats healthy food, even if the buyer has US legal tender?
- ataturk 9y agoUndermining legal tender laws is a bad idea. Convenience isn't a good reason--convenience can justify all kinds of horrible behavior. People who don't like "whites only" signs on restaurants and buses should be upset about anyone discriminating against cash.
- hkmurakami 9y agofwiw they take debit cards, and there are services like bluebird [1] that provide a bank account + debit card (iirc) without a credit check. but I agree with the spirit of your post. [1] https://www.bluebird.com/ https://www.bluebird.com/
- cesarb 9y agoEven these services have restrictions. For instance, the service you linked to says in its FAQ that it's only available to non-minor US residents with a valid SSN and a working email account. Cash has none of these restrictions, and it's not hard to imagine scenarios where they are relevant.
- geofft 9y agoThey seem to require an address. How do I give money to a homeless person to use at one of these stores? Can I buy a handful of Blue Dot cards at the drugstore, load them up with about $5 or $10, and hand them out?
- JoshMnem 9y agoSome people don't make enough money to open bank accounts, because their money is gone before the next paycheck.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoYou can buy prepaid Visa and MasterCard gift cards, that function exactly the same as credit cards at point-of-sale terminals, in places like CVS and gas stations.
- Finnucane 9y agoThose cards typically have high fees. So another way to leech off the poor.
- koolba 9y agoWhen the service provider goes down, do the POS systems have a way of batching transactions locally and sending them later? Or are you effectively shut down in the meantime? And are they wired or wireless? If they're running on Wi-Fi or even cellular it'd be relatively easy[1] to jam. Doesn't even have to be for too long either. Hitting a rival during the lunch rush is more then enough. > Not surprisingly, the credit card companies, who make a commission on every credit card purchase, applaud the trend. Visa recently offered select merchants a $10,000 reward for depriving customers of their right to pay by the method of their choice. A Visa executive described this practice to CNN as offering shoppers “freedom from carrying cash.” Yeesh. This reminds me of the PR messages from cable companies trying to prevent the deployment of municipal broadband. [1]: And highly illegal...
- skywhopper 9y agoNo way to batch the transactions, because they need to be online to validate the card. While you could potentially batch card-stripe data for later use, (1) you shouldn't even build that capability into your POS system because it would be a major hacking vector, and (2) you can't do so with chip data since the chip needs to be there to perform a calculation with its embedded key. You're right that disrupting wifi is easy enough, if such an attack actually became common, it's also easy to detect what/who is causing the disruption if you have reason to look for such. Or even easier to just hard-wire your POS terminal.
- gst 9y agoOffline chip and pin transactions are possible and are also used (at least in Europe). Due to security reasons they are usually only used for lower amounts and IIRC there's a maximum total amount that the chip is willing to sign without an online transaction in between. See https://www.aciworldwide.com/-/media/files/collateral/trends/emv_online_versus_offline_pin_validation_and_transaction_authorization_tl_us_1112_5058.pdf https://www.aciworldwide.com/-/media/files/collateral/trends... for some additional information.
- cesarb 9y ago> you can't do so with chip data since the chip needs to be there to perform a calculation with its embedded key. EMV has optional offline modes, where the calculations performed by the chip are saved by the terminal to be sent later.
- mieseratte 9y agoAs someone not in $BIG_TECH_CITY is this something folks are seeing elsewhere or this just another one of those problems only "coastal elites" have? Since I not only use cash for all purchases, but actively refuse to use a card this is a concerning trend.
- evgen 9y agoI have only seen it in major cities for now, but the trend will accelerate for all of the reasons given in the article. With chains like McDonalds replacing a large portion of the cashiers with automated ordering kiosks the next big push will be in marginalizing cash purchases and increasing the inconvenience (e.g. ten kiosks available or you can wait in a line five deep to order and pay with cash), but within a decade I can see the option for cash purchases being the exception and not the rule. It will happen much like the ongoing transition to the expectation that you will be carrying some sort of mobile device.
- geggam 9y agoOnce it hits the economic repressed areas, where the majority of folks don't have debit cards or bank accounts this will run into an issue. There is a very large and growing set of folks in this nation who use cash and barter only.
- skywhopper 9y agoI suspect at least some businesses everywhere in the US will move to this model in the next few years. Handling cash is a big logistical risk, and the only question is how many cash-only customers can you afford to turn away? And from my own non-coastal non-big-city observations, cash-only customers are fewer and fewer, and largely of demographics that some businesses (but not all) would be perfectly happy to have a reason to refuse service. But cash won't go away anytime soon. You just might have to skip dining at the latest fast-casual chain or indie coffeeshop to come to your town.
- geofft 9y agoAs a coastal elite (NYC), this is primarily a problem you'd see in famcy new gentrifying places. (Off the top of my head I can think of a salad place near Wall Street and a craft espresso place in the overpriced food court of a brand new mall in Brooklyn.) Your average bodega still has a $5 or $10 credit card minimum, and street food vendors, the bagel place I went to yesterday, etc. continue to be cash-only.
- sametmax 9y agoThat is such a dangerous trend. I perfectly understand the appeal though. Automatic book keeping, no more cash to move around that can temp thieves, less mistakes and cons. But for the society ? This just get rid of another grey area, a safety valve, a space so you have margin to maneuver. Indeed, no systems are perfect, but they will try to enforce their own rules, and have a big inertia and cost to be changed. Having those greys area allows for people not to be crunched by the unperfect system, or to experiment with alternatives that the system would not let exist. Without cash, kids can't mess around as much without adults knowing. But doing so is very important to their development. Without cash, you can't pay for a service that is illegal, even if it's not immoral. Do you know that we have freaking tomatoes that are legal to grow, but illegal to sell in France ? Yes, delicious, healthy tomatoes. Without cash, you can't finance an activity deemed immoral, even if it's legal. Because people will learn about it and make your life a leaving hell. Without cash, you can't disappear. But what if you need to ? Do you really trust the system to protect you if your life goes south ? We are not in the movies, the cops won't post guards in front of your house because you dated a drug dealer. Without cash, you don't have the right to make mistakes. How many of us are perfect ? I'm certainly not, and I paid for plenty of my sins. I have many purchases I'm not proud of, but I would like them to be forgotten. Without cash, there is no black market. Which mean if I'm looking for something that is not allowed in my country (say, boric acid to kill cock roaches), I can't. Without cash, society is less resilient. Power outage, network trouble or your card being unusable make you unable to pay for anything. Without cash, we give way too much power to entities managing the payment systems. Card companies don't like you ? You can't pay or take money anymore. That happened with wikileak, remember ? It was not illegal in my country, but VISA and paypal sure prevented me to make a donation to them. They stopped me to use my money in a legal way because they didn't like it. This is such a slippery slope. So yeah, cash can be misused in plenty of ways. So can be a knife. But I certainly not want my life to be limited to a spoon-only consumption. Also, saying it will fight cash laundering is telling only half of the story. The super-rich will still be able to do so.
- ksec 9y agoI love cash, but I really dislike coins. What we need isn't a cash or E-payment only, but a Hybrid. You should be able to pay with cash, and the changes should automatically be refunded to a payment system, since the retailer are highly unlikely to change their 98 or $99.99 pricing, those pennies will continue to exist. This system and tech is already in multiple places in South East Asia. The problem is companies like to hype themselves as a replacement of cash, and most people aren't aware of the privacy concern and implication with a cashless society.
- Thriptic 9y agoThe annoying thing about cash isn't the cash, it's change. Coins are awful. They're heavy, they take too long to count, and they have no buying power. I will frequently abandon change because I would rather lose money than deal with it / not purchase things at places that have minimums or are cash only. I understand why users are concerned about this trend, but if you're going to be working with cash you need to round your prices to the nearest dollar and take tax into consideration when doing it.
- StavrosK 9y agoSeriously? You'd rather round items up to the nearest dollar, so you spend a maximum of $5 more when buying ten items, than to just leave the extra change to the cashier? Of all the suboptimal solutions...
- Thriptic 9y agoEdge case. How many times have you done business at a place that is cash only where you bought more than a few items? The majority of the time rounding up is a great solution because it means the cashier doesn't waste time counting change and doesn't have to account for revenue not matching sales. Having a count thar does not come out cleanly at the end of the day is a major inconvenience depending on the business.
- StavrosK 9y ago> How many times have you done business at a place that is cash only where you bought more than a few items? Literally every time, but I don't live in the US. > Having a count thar does not come out cleanly at the end of the day is a major inconvenience depending on the business. Then round up at the end of the sum.
- ghaff 9y ago>They're heavy, they take too long to count, and they have no buying power. Depends on the currency. In Europe--both pounds and Euros--coins are pretty significant. Of the currencies I use, it's mostly the US where change is often a small denomination annoyance because, for whatever reason, we collectively decided some time around 1950 that we were never again going to change either the paper money or coin denominations in wide use.
- briandear 9y agoIn France, it’s technically illegal to pay more than €1000 cash for anything. Because terrorism. Though I suspect it’s really because of extremely high rates of tax evasion. Anytime a worker does anything at my house, there is always the quiet option of “sans facture” which means taxes are avoided for the purchase, but also it allows the worker to pretend he never received that income for income tax purposes. There is seemingly a dual economy — an unintended consequence (though completely foreseeable) of confiscacatory tax policy. If the tax rate were 10%, fewer people would bother evading and tax revenues would logically increase (per the Laffer Curve.)
- sundaeofshock 9y ago> If the tax rate were 10%, fewer people would bother evading and tax revenues would logically increase (per the Laffer Curve.) No, they don’t logically increase. We just tried that experiment in Kansas, and it failed badly. They ended up reversing tax cuts since revenue took a beating.
- ploden 9y agoAfter living in Germany, I can't go anywhere without cash. It's like walking out the door without my keys.
- pimeys 9y agoAnd when you're in Berlin, whenever you see your bank's ATM, you know you must get some cash. Soon you'll need it and the nearest ATM is broken, so you must spend a considerable time to find another one.
- mamon 9y agoIs that legal in US? Poland for example has a law saying that cash must be accepted, refusing cash payments results in immediate fine of about $135
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y agoLand of the free. Home of the brave. It’s a “free” country.
- notl4wy3r 9y agoIn the US, cash must be accepted as payment for (edit: public) debt. However, there is no requirement that all transactions must accept all legal tender. A business owner can refuse to enter into a commercial relationship with you on the basis of your method of payment. https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/faqs/Currency/Pages/legal-tender.aspx https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/faqs/Currency/Pages...
- tombrossman 9y agoIt's legal but I believe it requires collecting payment upfront to make enforcement practical. The bus company example is pretty good - you get on the bus and pay how they prefer or you don't ride. If you ate at a restaurant which had a 'no cash' policy, I'm not sure how you would resolve a situation with a client who was willing to pay in cash only. Would the restaurant be able to refuse your cash and say you ate without paying?
- friedButter 9y ago>If you ate at a restaurant which had a 'no cash' policy, I'm not sure how you would resolve a situation with a client who was willing to pay in cash only. Would the restaurant be able to refuse your cash and say you ate without paying? I doubt it would be too difficult to find another customer who would swipe their own card in exchange for cash from the cash paying customer... free reward points after all. (Infact many people do something similar in India, we receive a fixed allowance which is tax exempt but can only be spent on food, this is given via a special debit card or vouchers. You pay for someone else's food using the voucher and take cash from them)
- qaq 9y agohorrible trend it is pretty realistic to imagine an attack that cripples major payment processing networks
- omgtehlion 9y agoQui prodest? It is quite apparent why CC companies offer $10k in rewards: they will keep commissions on all transactions. Anecdote: recently I bought a used car. Initially we agreed on bank transaction, tried several banks, some have low limits so low it would take months to move money. Others wanted transaction fee as high as $200 on 20k transaction. Gov wants to get rid of cash because of surveillance. Banks and CC companies want to be gatekeepers and tell you what you can and can not do with your money. And to pocket as much fees as possible...
- briffle 9y agoNot only do they get commissions, but for the merchants, people historically pay more with Cards than with cash https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-science-behind-behavior/201607/does-it-matter-whether-you-pay-cash-or-credit-card https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-science-behind-beha...
- cripblip 9y agoI had the same situation in the UK a few years ago, the bank would not accept 25k in Euro or sterling; then when it came to electronic transfer, bank to bank, the bank would not guarantee the validity of the transaction for 8 weeks. Made the sale of the vehicle a little scary
- ohstopitu 9y agoI've experienced something similar at resturants in TO recently! Not only didn't they straight up refuse cash, they asked me download their app to pay for food. Obviously I walked out and got lunch elsewhere, but later when I was told that they sell their own currency in the app for CAD in denominations of 5. But their food + tax, is never sold at that amount - meaning, if your lunch is $10, tax makes it $11.3, you have to pay $15 in the app. If you have no intention of coming back, you loose the rest. This is such a scam. Also what's the problem with accepting cash? It's trackless and it's anonymous - I love it. Why should everything I buy be tracked by Banks, Corps and everyone in-between? Furthermore, unlike credit, there's are no fees associated with it so it's slightly better for the seller too. Btw if this does not give you a worry, think about this: all your expenses always end up at companies like Equifax. If them already selling it does not scare you, a leak should. Imagine if your transaction history can be used to refuse employment, housing etc. (without letting you know that's the case). Cash does not have any of those issues. The biggest 2 main issues with cash is - what if I get pickpocketed? and the solution is to never really walk around with more than $50-100. I've been using cash since I was a kid, and I've never gotten pickpocketed. The 2nd one is tracking your expenses - but I personally feel like using cash has made me spend a lot less than when I used my credit card.
- nchlswu 9y agowhich restaurant? I've seen a few food court spots go cashless, but nothing about downloading an app.
- ohstopitu 9y agoI can't remember the name - it's near union station - Bremner / York. It's a very hipsterish place.
- rodorgas 9y agoAlso, you can lose your phone the same way someone can pickpocket your wallet. If we’re stopping to use cash because of this, we should stop using expensive smartphones.
- qaq 9y ago
- djhworld 9y agoI rarely use cash these days, mainly due to laziness, and I like the fact that I can use some software to track all of my transactions across accounts so can rationalise my spending habits and commitments. Cash has that feature too but much more cumbersome to track, and comes with the additional burden of coins. Reading the comments in this post, I can understand the reasons why people would find this trend concerning, but I'm not really sure what you can do to stem the tide. For example in the UK the use of contactless credit/debit cards used for transactions went up by 147% between April 2016 to 17 [1] I suspect the trend will keep rising, contactless will probably soon overtake the smaller transactions (< £30) paid in cash. [1] http://www.theukcardsassociation.org.uk/contactless_contactless_statistics/ http://www.theukcardsassociation.org.uk/contactless_contactl...
- mrisoli 9y agoGrowing up in Brazil I got used to preferring card payments over cash, I never carried more than the equivalent of 30 USD(usually around 10-15 USD) on me because of the constant danger of being robbed. Most places accept credit cards and most of the time I carried cash for cab fare only. When Uber got started I could finally carry close to no cash on me, after a few months Uber ordered its drivers in Brazil to accept cash and was welcomed with a lot of protest from their drivers because doing so would threaten their safety.
- al_chemist 9y ago> Visa recently offered select merchants a $10,000 reward for depriving customers of their right to pay by the method of their choice. A Visa executive described this practice to CNN as offering shoppers “freedom from carrying cash.” This is and should be treated as an attack on US currency. It's not treated as such, because Visa sells its product to US gov as trackable and easy to control alternative to cash. Visa gets duopoly for payments. Government gets citizen spending profile. Citizen gets "freedom from carrying cash".
- misingnoglic 9y agoI was floored by the doublespeak in their statement. Freedom from cash?? I already have that. This is freedom to collect fees for visa.
- thisisit 9y agoOne of the problems I have noticed while using cash is the dearth of "change". In case of a digital transaction, restaurants can simply swipe and charge the exact amount. But, when it comes to cash they ask for "exact" change. Which makes me wonder, are we running out of coins or something? Or is it some marketing tick that pricing has to be non-zero, odd numbers to increase sales and that makes tendering change difficult?
- joncrane 9y agoI think it's a throughput thing. Lines are long at places in midtown Manhattan. Counting out change takes longer than waiting for the transaction to clear and offering a receipt.
- ricardobeat 9y agoIt is worrying that the US would move to a cashless society with credit cards. This is already a reality in the Netherlands and other countries in the EU, but with debit payments being the vast majority, which also have much, much lower fees. Handing off 2-3% of all transactions to Visa/MasterCard is just insane.
- hrasyid 9y agoDon't credit card companies charge a fee, which you can avoid by accepting cash? Is that charge usually worth avoiding the hassle of handling cash?