4 ms·
sigh A patent isn't an idea. It's the specific method for implementing an idea. If there is a way to get the same end result using a completely different metho
by gaius 16y ago
sigh
A patent isn't an idea. It's the specific method for implementing an idea. If there is a way to get the same end result using a completely different method, the patent doesn't apply.
- btilly 16y agoHow does that relate to my comment that the patent in question sounds like it could have come out of Sun's work on optimizing Smalltalk instead of their later Java implementation? (Note that even if Sun could have worked around their own patents, they would have had no reason to bother.)
- koenigdavidmj 16y agoYes! And the first few claims generally paint way over the lines. It's in the later claims that you talk about the unique stuff that you did.
- kj12345 16y agoA "method" which is not being acted out physically, but instead is in someone's head or written down on paper is a type of idea. So some ideas are patentable, others aren't. The mantra that ideas aren't patentable presumes some other category of thought completely apart from ideas. Besides, what could be more purely and precisely methodical than machine-readable source code, in this case Smalltalk source code?