3 ms·
I'm a New Yorker who's sad to see a lot of shops close, but at the same time can't help but think: efficient markets always correct themselves. Assuming market
by crazygringo 9y ago
I'm a New Yorker who's sad to see a lot of shops close, but at the same time can't help but think: efficient markets always correct themselves.
Assuming markets are relatively efficient, it's a good thing that landlords leave lots vacant -- they're waiting for a future higher-paying tenant who can afford to pay the higher rent because they'll provide more value to their customers -- and these landlords are paying through the nose in lost rent while making that bet.
This ensures there's space ready-to-go for the expensive wine bar customers would prefer over the cheap cafe that would otherwise already be occupying it, or the luxury bakery over the dollar store -- and just like anywhere in a capitalistic system, we assume that the store that produces the most profit (and therefore can afford the highest rent) deserves the storefront, because this is the best use/value for those potential customers.
At the same time, I'm ready to rip my hair out over another favorite shop being replaced by yet another Duane Reade pharmacy or Bank of America branch. But you know who I blame? The customers, not the landlords. As depressing as it is, it's clear people in that neighborhood will now pay more for the convenience of banking and aisles of toilet paper than the old stores, and so be it.
Which is why, for the first time, I'm moving from Manhattan to Brooklyn. Which is fine -- in my eyes, parts of Manhattan may be getting worse, but parts of Brooklyn are only getting better. Neighborhoods aren't supposed to stay the same. I'm not going to lament a lost New York, when a new one is always forming!
- leephillips 9y agoBut the article points out that a major input into this system is the valuation of properties by banks, which prefer to see corporate renters. It seems possible, at least, that a corporate landlord may, because of this, prefer to push out an individually-owned renter in the hopes of securing a corporate renter, because the property valuation by the banks will then increase. This would be immune to the popularity of the individually owned shop, so immune to an actual demand signal. In other words, it's not the customers, it's the banks and the corporations who own the buildings.
- nojvek 9y agoAlso banks are big and take the losses. Small businesses can’t. You can never blame the customer. They can’t find it at the price they can afford, they’ll move elsewhere.
- robbyt 9y agoMarkets do correct themselves, usually at the expense of the poorest or least powerful. A hypothetical scenario where this market could self-regulate is 1980s NYC happens again in 2020. Blight and crime everywhere, but wow! Look at how that commerical real estate became more affordable. The point of government regulation on these sorts of things is to reduce how far the pendulum of capitalism swings. When it moves too far in either direction, it only benefits a few people.