5 ms·
> I pulled this chapter together from dozens of sources that were at times somewhat contradictory. Facts on the ground change over time and depend who is tellin
by jedberg 9y ago
> I pulled this chapter together from dozens of sources that were at times somewhat contradictory. Facts on the ground change over time and depend who is telling the story and what audience they're addressing.
You know old time journalists had a solution to this. Interviewing subjects with first hand knowledge.
I know I rag on highscalability a lot, but I feel like they deserve it. They've written multiple articles about topics in which I would be a first person resource (Reddit and Netflix), and not once have they ever contacted me or anyone I worked with for an interview. They've quoted me from presentations, but the quotes were out of context and wrong they way they quoted it.
All of this could have been cleared up with a single interview of anyone who is a primary source expert.
- radicalbyte 9y agoA really good way for you to get your point across would be to write a reactionary blog post detailing the actual information. Netflix seem to be pretty cool & open about things so it should be possible?
- frik 9y agoI am all for video-on-demand, as long it's free. So YouTube, Twitch, etc are great value. In case I need to spend money, I prefer to own the thing I pay for. So Blu-ray/DVD/CDs discs for me. The gathered video/music can be played on all my devices from car to phone, even in flight-mode offline. I trade a bit of less convince upfront to really own it, but then I can play it as often and exactly when and where I want. Anyway every few years one could get a higher resolution version, unfortunately the films aren't sold in source versions, but downscaled, but the video-on-demand at always lagging behind and stream worse bit rates.
- tybit 9y agoWhich just goes to show how much of a market there is for easily digestible information in this space. Netflix in particular seems to have some really interesting ideas hidden behind unclear blogs(at least for me personally) and long presentations I rarely have time to sit through, even though I often appreciate them when I do.
- frozenport 9y agoWhats wrong with the information?
- marcoperaza 9y agoModern journalism in a nutshell. Now realize that most journalism is this sloppy, not just the pieces about things you happen to know about.
- oculusthrift 9y agonot true. many print news sources call their sources and sometimes verify each quote twice. i’ve heard stories from people who were simply quoted in a new yorker article about movies and they were called twice to verify their quote when it was just a small part of the article
- sandworm101 9y agoTry writing tech articles for money. You have to produce them quickly and to point. Interviewing people takes time. By the time the subject recieves the request and gets permission to talk to the reporter, the dealine has passed. An interview might also overturn the theme of the article, a theme dictated by a manager/purchaser based on thier brief reading of a few other articles/blogs. If the reporter wants to be paid they better generate the story as requested and on time. It isnt good jounalism but it is how you make rent.
- katastic 9y agoI've actually heard a lot of people say this. At least a couple Ph.Ds, though I can't recall the links. How many failures in journalism are attributed to "lazy journalism" where nobody will even leave the building these days to even ask someone involved in the story or topic. How the internet made it "easier" but they've become so over-reliant on it that many journalists fail to include information that isn't already online. Then again, Netflix is probably a phone call away, so that may be a whole 'nother level of lack-of-followup.
- ufmace 9y agoI get your point, but how many of these tech companies will actually authorize their employees who know what they're talking about to speak freely with tech reporters about how their system works? I would figure most would redirect you to a PR flunky to feed meaningless corporate-speak to any reporters, and then it's all "Netflix uses the latest internet technology to ensure the best possible viewing experience for all viewers around the world. Unfortunately, the specifics of our system are proprietary and we are unable to discuss that."
- gtaylor 9y agoReddit is constantly out presenting, talking, and even writing about architecture, culture, and our unique challenges. Netflix seems to be similar. Their open source record speaks for itself, and their technical blog and presence at conferences and meetups is outstanding. Source: though these opinions are my own, I work on Infrastructure at Reddit.
- drdrey 9y agoNetflix is particularly open about how it works. There are some confidential bits, but most of the infrastructure projects are not considered proprietary. (I work at Netflix)
- toddh 9y agoHi Jeremy, I'm very sorry if I've misquoted you or quoted you out of context. I'd certainly correct them instantly if contacted. I've searched my email and I don't see any corrections, so I'm not sure how I can make amends. I pull a lot of quotes from a lot of sources. Many thousands a year. My goal is always to highlight ideas that I think might help readers do their job better. Highlight is they key word here. That you say those sort of things often is not surprising. My hope is always readers will be made curious enough to follow the link and learn more on their own. And unfortunately there is no "they" at HighScalability.com. There's only me and there's only ever been me. So all mistakes are mine and only mine. There's never been much money or time to be as comprehensive as I'd like. I do the best I can, but I often fall short, no doubt. I'm not a journalist. I never said I was. I'm a programmer. Have been all my life. I started this blog a long time ago. It was just stuff I found interesting. For whatever reason it got popular for awhile so I tried to make something out of it. That, like most of the industry is petering out now, so we'll see what the future holds. The point about interviews is a good one and one I've wrestled with. Over the years I've conducted a lot of interviews. Much less so lately, and that's for a reason. I've learned that presentations at major conferences are usually the best resources. Presenters put a huge amount of effort into making those talks. And everything they say is open and approved for public consumption by definition. Interviews with someone like me are often a bother, a time sync, so I don't usually get as much out of them. Interviews have a high overhead, taking a lot of time to setup and there's often a lot of red tape and legal wrangling that must go on to get access and content approval. Which is again, why, presentations are such awesome resources. This article was derived mostly from people working on a project making a major presentation or from primary sources writing an article. I couldn't do better than that. And regardless, I would still make mistakes. Believe me. It's surprisingly hard to make sense of an interview and turn something from thread mode into document mode. That process is an error prone one because I have to fill in the gaps and there are always gaps. It's rare that I've ever just published an interview. I don't think they are that useful in general. I want people to read a highly condensed document they can get something concrete out of with minimal effort or just ignore easily if it's not relevant to them. The strange style I've developed reflects that goal. This article was of course different because it has a different audience. So again, I apologize. But I guarantee my mistakes are never intentional, never for money, and never for lack of caring or effort.