3 ms·
Simply removing regulation is not enough to fix everything. Downtown Los Angeles is a prime example of that. It has been seeing a construction boom in recent
by slg 9y ago
Simply removing regulation is not enough to fix everything. Downtown Los Angeles is a prime example of that. It has been seeing a construction boom in recent year and loosened regulation is probably responsible for part of that boom. However since there is little regulation on the type of housing that is being built, the new construction is all coming in at the top of the market. This is because buying land and building a mid-market apartment building is not much cheaper than buying the land and building a luxury apartment building. The end result is that Downtown Los Angeles is full of luxury apartments with some of the areas highest vacancy rates as landlords are making more money charging high rents at 80-90% occupancy than they would with lower rents at 100% occupancy. Meanwhile these new buildings are replacing much more affordable housing which is pushing lower income renters out of their homes. Eventually those luxury apartments will trickle down to cheaper rent at the bottom of the market, but often times that means forcing a low income family out of their home in a gentrifying neighborhood into a less desirable area that is often farther from amenities the city offers like public transit which objectively make their lives worse.
- greggman 9y agoknowing how bad downtown LA is/was in terms of poverty and crime it's hard for me not to be happy at the gentrification and cleaning up of DTLA. It still has a ways to go but I'd love a safe and clean DTLA. I don't know what the implications are for the poor that get displaced but old DTLA was (and still is) a blight on the city. Of course a solution that some how helps the poor down there would be great but keeping the place a cheap ghetto doesn't seem like the right thing either
- slg 9y agoYou are taking the perspective of someone who is at least middle class. If you were a lower income family and you are pushed from DTLA to Whittier because of gentrification it could have a huge negative impact on your life. A "safe and clean DTLA" would do you no good in that instance. Also it has now been a few years since DTLA was a "blight" or a "cheap ghetto". Is there a bigger sign of gentrification than Whole Foods[1]? [1] - https://www.wholefoodsmarket.com/stores/downtownlosangeles https://www.wholefoodsmarket.com/stores/downtownlosangeles
- santaclaus 9y agoMost of the construction in DTLA was previously parking lots... I find it hard to believe that mostly vacant parking lots adjacent to a mostly vacant sports stadium is somehow a superior proposition to a sustainable urban fabric than much needed housing.
- slg 9y agoWhen was the last time you were in DTLA? There are many new buildings that weren't built in former parking lots and the gentrified area isn't purely centered around LA Live. You can walk 10 minutes south or west of the Staples Center and be in non-gentrified areas but if you walked 30 minutes north it is heavily gentrified.
- Decade 9y agoAbout 10% vacancy seems to be a healthy amount. If that were over the entire city, and not only in new developments, then people would have much more freedom to move. And then prices would go down. 100% occupancy is bad, because it means the city is not flexible to changing demands. Fill up that new development 100%, and then the next person who needs to come in would need to double up, or bid higher and displace somebody. That is my big problem with the Planning process, trying to manage growth. It’s slow and brittle to unanticipated changes.
- slg 9y agoIt isn't over the entire city, it is over a small neighborhood within the city. The vacancy rate in that neighborhood was at 12% while the entire city rate was at 4%. That plus the rate being at a 17 year high would seem to indicate a problem. [1] [1] - https://la.curbed.com/2017/9/15/16316040/downtown-la-high-vacancy-rate-rent https://la.curbed.com/2017/9/15/16316040/downtown-la-high-va...
- mjevans 9y agoYes it does. The problem is lack of supply in the overall market to drive the price to a reasonable point.
- closeparen 9y agoThe whole point of a market is that capital is most incentivized to come alleviate a shortage when prices are highest. There might be a cogent argument for fully centrally planned housing, but instituting price controls on new market supply when a shortage is at its worst is a staggeringly clueless demand. And let’s be clear, affordable vs luxury housing is about price controls, not the units themselves. There is nothing physically embedded in the average “luxury” 700sqft unit that makes it worth more than a McMansion in Iowa. Only the supply and demand situation where it’s located. Countertops and dishwashers don’t add +$2000/mo.