4 ms·
Geh, in reality the Mac didn't get an operating system in the true sense of the word (proper process separation, memory protection etc.) until like... System 7.
by cmrdporcupine 9y ago
Geh, in reality the Mac didn't get an operating system in the true sense of the word (proper process separation, memory protection etc.) until like... System 7.6 or maybe even later in OS X. Classic Mac OS was more like an overgrown API than a proper OS environment. A real step backwards from the Lisa...
It's baffling to me that instead of cost reducing the Lisa, Apple ran two parallel product lines (Mac and Lisa), similar to each other and competing with each other.. and from reading histories it sounds like it came down to territorial turf wars and Job's ego that made this the case. Lisa wasn't Jobs baby... so it was killed.
- glhaynes 9y agoLisa wasn't Jobs baby True in one sense... false in another!
- eesmith 9y agoIf I accept your "True sense of the word", then many early operating systems, like the "SHARE Operating System" from 1959, are not, actually, operating systems. I prefer to believe that you are using a stricter definition of the word/phrase, rather one which encompasses how that word/phrase was actually used by practitioners in the field.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoSure, fine, I agree that back then the definition of OS was more fluid. Though in reality I don't think that in those early days they even called what was running on the Mac an operating system at all. The term "Mac OS" didn't arrive til much later, and it wasn't until there were later revisions that they used the phraseology "System" for it. But to the original point, my understanding is that the Lisa had a more classic OS architecture when compared to the Mac: multiple processes, dynamic memory allocation, etc. But until I can actually read the source for it (soon!) I'm just repeating hearsay. I've run the OS on emulators, but that doesn't tell you much about its inner workings.
- eesmith 9y ago"in reality I don't think that in those early days they even called what was running on the Mac an operating system at all" I must live in a different reality. The first Apple operating system, with the phrase "operating system" in the name, was Apple DOS, starting in 1978. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_DOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_DOS . It did not have the features you require in your definition of an operating system. Here's the summary from the bibliographic entry for an article from "Popular Computing", Aug 1984, quoting from http://www.worldcat.org/title/whenever-you-use-a-computer-you-are-using-a-program-called-an-operating-system/oclc/425467573&referer=brief_results http://www.worldcat.org/title/whenever-you-use-a-computer-yo... : > Examines design, features, and shortcomings of eight disk-based operating systems designed for general use that are popular or most likely to affect the future of microcomputing. Included are the CP/M family, MS-DOS, Apple DOS/ProDOS, Unix, Pick, the p-System, TRSDOS, and Macintosh/Lisa. (MBR) Several of those have the term "operating system" in the name, and as you can see "Macintosh" is described as an operating system. Here are internal development notes from the Macintosh project, dated 1983, which shows that Apple had a "Macintosh Operating System Manual" already by that time: https://archive.org/stream/MacintoshDevelopmentNotes/Macintosh%20Development%20Notes#page/n27/mode/2up/search/operating+system https://archive.org/stream/MacintoshDevelopmentNotes/Macinto... . Chapter 1 of those notes is titled "Overview of the Operating System". https://archive.org/stream/MacintoshDevelopmentNotes/Macintosh%20Development%20Notes#page/n299/mode/2up/search/operating+system https://archive.org/stream/MacintoshDevelopmentNotes/Macinto... The introduction is "There are two main groups of routines that may be called by an application program -- the MacIntosh Operating System and the MacIntosh User Interface Toolkit." (The capitalization in "MacIntosh" is theirs.) I know what your intent is, and I think you are correct. What I disagree is your use of phrases like "True sense of the word" and "in reality" in expressing what seems much more like a personal opinion based on a shallow understanding of the topic.
- hota_mazi 9y ago> Geh, in reality the Mac didn't get an operating system in the true sense of the word Indeed. Apple's operating systems were completely outclassed by Windows 95, AmigaOS and BeOS (and by that I mean both at the OS level and also the GUI). Even the "merger" of NeXt and Apple didn't give Apple a credible OS for many years after that. This is why I can't help chuckle when I read comments such as "Lisa was programmed with planned obsolescence because it couldn't support years past 1995". This is not planned obsolescence, it's just incompetence from Apple's software engineers. Back then, Apple was a lot better at product and hardware than software. And when I see iTunes, I still think it's still kind of true today.
- TimTheTinker 9y agoNeXtStep was an excellent BSD-based OS, and Mac OS X, released (I believe) first in 2000 (3 years after Apple bought NeXT) was basically NeXTStep with a new UI, new graphical apps, and new APIs to bridge the gap to OS 9.
- ghostcluster 9y ago> Geh, in reality the Mac didn't get an operating system in the true sense of the word (proper process separation, memory protection etc.) What? No. So DOS wasn't an operating system either then? Lots of higher level OS features just weren't really possible with the extremely limited RAM, ROM, and complete lack of hard drive of the original Mac. That doesn't mean it wasn't an "operating system"