3 ms·
> Frequentist: yes. I don't follow.
by nerdponx 9y ago
> Frequentist: yes.
I don't follow.
- RA_Fisher 9y agoI ought to directly show this, but Frequentist hypothesis tests will produce different p-values depending on which model is chosen.
- RA_Fisher 9y agoSee this document with the calculation: https://www2.isye.gatech.edu/~brani/isyebayes/bank/handout2.pdf https://www2.isye.gatech.edu/~brani/isyebayes/bank/handout2....
- gerdesj 9y agoI read that pdf and it is not exactly rigorous. Eg page 4: "Should depend only on the outcome observed and not on any other outcome we might have observed and thus sharply contrasts with the method of likelihood inference from the Neyman-Pearson, or more generally from a frequentist, approach. In particular, questions of unbiasedness, minimum variance and risk, consistency, the whole apparatus of confidence intervals, significance levels, and power of tests, etc., violate the conditionality principle." and "Here is yet another scenario that will not impress a conditionalist:" You don't write a paper to trash a POV. You put your own thesis across. That thing is bollocks.
- tel 9y agoFrequentist analyses will depend upon assumptions of the sampling process which often include specific stopping conditions. This means that the _reason_ an experiment ends is an important part of data. That exactly defies the likelihood principle since it means that our outcome is dependent on information not observed.
- RA_Fisher 9y agoYes! I feel like I'm finally getting to this crux in the difference between the Bayesian / information theoretic methods and Frequentism.