4 ms·
it doesn't make sense for Uber to a) publish a list of current unpatched security vulnerabilities Hackerone could require them to publish a list of has
by michaelt 9y ago
it doesn't make sense for
Uber to a) publish a list
of current unpatched
security vulnerabilities
Hackerone could require them to publish a list of hashes of unambiguous descriptions of known bugs. That way they could prove beyond doubt which issues were already known - much like astronomers published anagrams to prove their discoveries' priority in the 1500s.
It wouldn't solve the problem of people wasting their time rediscovering bugs that don't pay out, of course.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tomxor 9y agoI was going to suggest hackerone should be responsible for both storing and arbitrating known bugs but this is even better. It's really hard to not think Uber is simply playing hackerone to get free penetration testing here by responding to everything as "already discovered" or "out of scope"... A dangerous game though if people catch on and get pissed off enough and just publish it like this, I can't really blame the author, the whole process sounds like bullshit.
- zipwitch 9y agoThis would appear to be consistent with what I've personally observed of Uber's approach to, well, pretty much everything.
- technion 9y agoI think it would go a long way just stating when they became duplicates. It would be hard to be mad at Uber if another person reported the same bug two days earlier. It would be easy to be mad at Uber if this had been sitting in an internal bug tracker for three years just getting "closed, duplicate" everytime someone made a Hacker One report.