3 ms·
I haven't tested it properly, and n=1, but I recently cleaned a MBP 2010: dedust, replaced battery (was at 85% with approx 900 cycles), replaced both fans, and
by Fnoord 9y ago
I haven't tested it properly, and n=1, but I recently cleaned a MBP 2010: dedust, replaced battery (was at 85% with approx 900 cycles), replaced both fans, and reapplied thermal paste (I'd already replaced the RAM and HDD with SSD earlier, and dedusted numerous times already). If you follow iFixit guides and have the right tools (mentioned in the guides) its fairly easy to do. I'm not good with this stuff at all, and I managed. The problem was that the machine got very hot very easily. It still gets hot very easily (seems to even spike quicker now) but the fans need to work less hard.
The Nvidia GPU is also on life support on this machine due to a bug which isn't covered under warranty. For that I use Gfxcardstatus and keep the machine's GPU in Integrated mode (the slower Intel CPU). Its a widely known problem with the 2010 series. All apps which use Electron or Chrome put the machine's GPU at boot in Dedicated mode. Which is annoying. Firefox doesn't do this, and since 57 yields good performance. Although I'm not sold on watching videos in Firefox; Chrome/Safari might yield better performance on Mac according to certain anecdotal evidence I found (including my own).
Now, there's a few reasons why newer macOS versions are slower than older. One reason being APFS [1] [2] (Reddit thread [3] [4]). Especially when using FileVault. Keep in mind thats a state of the art MBP; its from 2017.
Regardless, we need benchmarks.
[1] https://malcont.net/2017/09/apfs-vs-hfs-benchmarks-on-2017-macbook-pro-with-macos-high-sierra/ https://malcont.net/2017/09/apfs-vs-hfs-benchmarks-on-2017-m...
[2] https://malcont.net/2017/07/apfs-and-hfsplus-benchmarks-on-2017-macbook-pro-with-macos-high-sierra/ https://malcont.net/2017/07/apfs-and-hfsplus-benchmarks-on-2...
[3] https://www.reddit.com/r/osx/comments/72z2v5/apfs_vs_hfs_benchmarks_on_2017_macbook_pro_with/ https://www.reddit.com/r/osx/comments/72z2v5/apfs_vs_hfs_ben...
[4] https://www.reddit.com/r/mac/comments/6nnaex/i_made_some_benchmarks_on_apfs_to_hfs_comparison/ https://www.reddit.com/r/mac/comments/6nnaex/i_made_some_ben...
- boundlessdreamz 9y agoWhich battery did you get for it?
- Fnoord 9y agoThis one (new) [1]. Note I'm from EU, so I bought it from the iFixit EU store located in Germany. Delivery took a few days during Black Friday peak. Little bit more than half a week IIRC. When I first checked earlier this year they weren't in stock, so I asked when they'd be in stock which was soon. Once they were in stock I lacked time IRL so had to postpone order. Hence I only replaced it a good month ago. Had to order some kit and accessoires to open up the machine (was on sale during Black Friday) including the magnetic project mat which you can use to group the screws (you can add notes as well on it). 10/10 recommend that! (I'm not affiliated btw.) I recommend to just check the guides. They're good, and if you need help you can ask questions over there. The people there are much more knowledgable on this subject than I will ever be. Only bad thing is that the guide told me to not worry about disconnecting the iSight camera. I managed to break that cable. That was during thermal paste application guide though; not battery replacement. The other disconnections of cables all went very well or flawless. Nothing broken in these departments. In a way, no iSight is a plus anyway. [1] https://eustore.ifixit.com/en/Parts/MacBook-Parts/Macbook-Pro/15/Unibody/Mid-2009/MacBook-Pro-15-Unibody-Mid-2009-Mid-2010-Replacement-Battery.html https://eustore.ifixit.com/en/Parts/MacBook-Parts/Macbook-Pr...
- boundlessdreamz 9y agoThank you. Unfortunately I'm not in EU and package forwarders don't accept lithium batteries anymore.
- Fnoord 9y agoIf you're in US, there's also iFixit US. Just check the main site [1] and see if its possible. You can select language on top right. [1] https://www.ifixit.com https://www.ifixit.com
- heywire 9y agoIf you’re comfortable with a soldering iron, there is a pretty easy fix for the GPU. I fixed mine earlier this year and it has been rock solid since. https://youtu.be/DzcgT_fiVTA https://youtu.be/DzcgT_fiVTA
- tedmiston 9y agoIt looks like the first link is current and concerning. Why would APFS encrypted be so much slower than HFS+ encrypted?