9 ms·
Why Anti-Corruption Strategies May Backfire
- vemv 9y agoI think the article's point would be more convincing if they related that study to real-world examples. Personally I cannot imagine how corruption makes the world any better?
- petre 9y agoIt doesn't. I fell like this article is a summary to a game theory study.
- digi_owl 9y agoLike i needed another reason for considering game theory a potentially dangerous distraction at best.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI'm glad you say that because I had the same thought.
- meshr 9y agoLet me disagree. Corruption is corruption but not cooperation. The same as cancer is a decease but not your new living form. The “bribery game” is bad corruption model because corruption often occurs when you don’t have a choice and you have to accept the corruption risk (which can cost you infinite money). “The public pool is multiplied and divided equally among the players” – they modeled Denmark but not Kenya to learn corruption, didn’t they? “Corruption is largely inevitable” – they should learn about blockchain. Lastly, I grown up in corrupt country (Russia) and I do not only think that bribes are acceptable but also think that anyone who does this should donate the same money to anticorruption agencies to treat this disease.
- petre 9y agoAnticorruption agencies can essentialy be neutered by corrupt leadership. They're subject to public funding. This is what happens as we speak in Eastern Europe (notably Poland and Romania). Bad economic conditions, lack of infrastructure and education only make it worse. This is why the Marshall Plan did wonders to post-war GDR. And this is why halting EU funds to corrupt Eastern Europe states will only make matters worse and reutrn these countries 90s cleptocracies.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- belorn 9y agoThe conclusion/title seems a bit obvious but also wrong at the same time. In society when corruption is not punished and you combine that with full transparency, what you get is open crime. Prohibition comes to mind, and I am pretty sure no one has thought since then that prohibition would have worked if we just shone enough sunlight on the lawbreakers. That said, more transparency on the bribery and political corruption could have led to further reduced trust in the police and political system until the breaking point where civil war breaks out and the system gets replaced. The researchers' experiment did not allow for total replacement of the system and leaders. It can show the obvious that transparency can reduce trust when it demonstrates corruption and a failure to punish it, but what happens next is left unanswered.
- throwaway122517 9y agoThis is such bullshit. Corruption is not cooperation, it's more like a leech on public resources. I work with one of the big consultancy corps which got hired by one of the indian state governments to help put in place the eGovernance initiative. Well it turns out a lot of the civil servants involved have made it their goal to make sure that the system is as incompetent as possible so that people are forced to fall-back to the old systems where it'll be easier for them take bribes. It infuriates me to no end that progress (which is supported by the elected government) in a country is being blocked by corrupt numbskulls who just wish to make sure they can fill their pockets.
- smallnamespace 9y agoI think you missed the entire point of the article > What we call “corruption” is a smaller scale of cooperation undermining a larger-scale. The vast majority of people don't work for some abstract social good. They work for specific concrete goods: helping themselves, helping their loved ones, helping their friends first and foremost. People also believe in reciprocity and fairness. Sometimes that means that if someone 'helps you out', you do the same back... even if that interaction wasn't completely 100% sanctioned by the rest of society. Corruption is not people ignoring their moral instincts and choosing to be evil. It is them weighing one set of moral instincts more strongly than another set of moral instincts (egalitarianism, not breaking rules). The struggle is to align the incentives properly so that 'helping yourself' also means to help society. Unlike what many libertarians and pure free-marketeers seem to believe, this doesn't just happen magically, but requires careful thought and planning.
- smallnamespace 9y agoOne of my US high school history teachers once taught us that bureaucracy and endless mounds of red tape were the natural consequence of Americans valuing fairness over efficiency, and in the end getting neither. We want a system that is: 1. fair, and Americans immediately suspect that humans tend to favor their friends 2. based on clear, written rules, so everyone can compete on an even playing field 3. good enough to handle any edge case, so that 'exceptions' to rules via human override (and potential corruption) can be avoided Implementing 1-3 means building a giant, inflexible bureaucracy, where responsibility is widely distributed (so nobody can be corrupt) and an immense book of rules and red tape (so it can handle every edge case). Unfortunately Americans don't even really get fairness in practice. The cost of following all the rules to the letter is so incredibly expensive and inefficient that obviously government agencies and their favored contract bidders have back channels with one another so that they know exactly how to structure their bids to win. This is why conservatives sometimes have a point - many regulations not only do not do anything for the public good, but they actually help entrenched interests.
- js8 9y agoI suspect if you think that U.S. is too bureaucratic or unfair, you have never been to other countries, really. There is only a handful of countries that can be said to do better in one of those respects. It seems to me that you claim that there is a trade-off between bureaucracy and corruption. I disagree, to me it seems (although I cannot readily prove it) that these are more often correlated than not.
- icegreentea2 9y agoI think his point that you don't actually get fairness in practice answers to your point about the trade-off between efficiency and corruption. I think the point was that adding rules and diffusing responsibility appear to be a way to reduce corruption and making things fair for everyone, but that in practice that relationship may not be so simple.
- smallnamespace 9y ago> U.S. is too bureaucratic or unfair Not so much at the local level where a citizen deals with the bureaucracy, but certainly at the level where lots of money gets allocated and spent, such as military procurement. Just look at what SpaceX has managed to achieve largely outside the world of government cost-plus contracting at a small fraction of the budget of its competitors. Large parts of the military-industrial complex are jobs programs for underserved portions of the country disguised as 'defense'. The inefficiency is purposeful. It keeps mounds of people employed in states where there otherwise wouldn't be much investment. It requires an army of federal bureaucrats who spend years writing detailed waterfall-style calls for bids, then an army of engineers at the large firms that craft bids that are happen to be perfectly suited to the government's needs. A clique of politicians from those states that will provide unwavering support to make sure the jobs remain in their states A small town worth of lawyers, accountants, inspectors, to make sure that the entire process is 'fair' and 'transparent', and to produce thousands of pages of documentation to a public that will never read (but is always available to defend against charges of corruption). This is still 'corruption', but legally, done at a massive, industrial scale and with more steps. But note that much of this is simply make-work, the equivalent of digging holes and filling them again. The country would probably be safer and have a better military if we were just honest with ourselves, made those industries efficient, and then pay off the existing beneficiaries with direct transfers and massive investments in health care and education.
- scotty79 9y agoCorruption is not only present with relation to government officials. It's not uncommon that small companies bribe employees of large companies so they award them contracts for services. Bribes are whenever person has decision power larger then income from making correct decissions. Then he can be bribed to make incorrect ones but beneficial to the one who bribes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- baxtr 9y agoI wonder for a long time now: what are underlying factors for societies to be less corrupt than others? How come that many western states fare better than other countries? It’s gotta be related to what’s mentioned in the article: people valuing a larger-scale cooperation higher than a smaller-scale/immediate one. By why? Ideas/hints anyone?
- smallnamespace 9y agoSocial trust and cohesion, a unified set of values that every member of society agrees with. > How come that many western states fare better than other countries Because Western societies are by and large the product of 19th-century nationalism. The ideal has always been: one nation, one people, one language, one state. If you steal from the public, you are also stealing from members of your own 'group'. If you don't view other members of your country to be part if your own social group, then of course it's much easier to be corrupt. You can see this happening in India in particular -- everything is drawn along lines of religion, ethnicity, and caste. The same thing is happening to the US.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alexryan 9y agoI dispute that corruption is inevitable and propose that its origins lie the violation of a foundational moral at the heart of most religions: In Christianity, this is the commandment: Thou shall not steal. In Buddhism, the precept is more explicit: Do not take that which has not been freely given. If we live in a society where the majority of people are willing to violate this rule by directing the state to steal from those who have more and redistribute to those who have less, those who are being robbed will naturally seek to find a means to defend themselves and their families from the predation of the majority. Being outnumbered, they do not have the votes to defend themselves at the polls. Naturally, they will use the resources they do have. They can bribe those who are tasked with committing the theft. This is entirely rational. No matter how many prohibitions against corruption are erected, those who are being preyed upon will seek to defend themselves and there will always be people willing to help them, especially in exchange for cash. The origin of corruption lies in the decision to violate the prohibition against theft. The violation of the prohibition against theft creates a need for bribery which would not otherwise exist. When a need is created, market forces will move to ensure the need is met. One way to create a society free of corruption is for the majority to voluntarily commit to the prohibition against theft and to enforce the prohibition against those who choose to violate it. I would further propose that this could lead to a more general replacement of zero sum games with positive sum games. This, in turn, would serve to further accelerate the rate of innovation and thus speed the rate at which all,human needs are met. When trust is strengthened, instead of seeking to meet our needs at the expense of each other, we are naturally more willing to work together to solve the larger problems which afflict us all.
- yuliyp 9y agoThis theory would make sense if bribery were a practice only practiced by the rich. It is not. Even civil servants who are not being taxed disproportionately would accept bribes, and even the poor would give them (as the benefit of the bribe outweighs the cost). Unless your argument that it's the perception of being stolen from that would cause someone to be willing to engage in corruption. This feels nearly like a tautology. Everyone can find some way in which they feel victimized/punished by society (or rationalize their way into feeling such).