4 ms·
Yeah the only time it makes sense to have a 401k is if your company matches your contributions.
by nunez 9y ago
Yeah the only time it makes sense to have a 401k is if your company matches your contributions.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoDon't they all have a match? It would be nice if people could keep the match and have more control over their portfolios. Buy & sell stocks, bonds, commodities, etc. whenever instead of a very small basket of mutual funds that can only be juggled a few times a year.
- user5994461 9y agoWe had that when I was working in a top investment bank, in the UK office. The employment contract was accompanied by a 50 page document explaining the pension system, a long tutorial on risks/asset-types/location/diversification and everything you ever wish to know about pension, and last but not least the 20 funds they make available to us.
- hkmurakami 9y agoyes the limitation of 401k plan fund choices seems very arbitrary to me. Perhaps a result of lobbying, or a remnant of the past when such limitations were a good call?
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> Don't they all have a match? No, some employers just pay in whether you do or not, and your contribution doesn't in any way change theirs.
- exclusiv 9y agoWe don't do a match but offer a safe harbor automatic 3% contribution which everyone gets. This is nice because some younger employees don't contribute anything but we're still helping out their 401k.
- pinewurst 9y agoStartups (and even quite a few more mature companies) seldom match. I'm noticing this in a job search now.
- brewdad 9y agoMy wife's doesn't have a match per se. Instead the company contributes a lump sum annually that amounts to about 5% of her income. She wouldn't have to contribute anything to get this money and it doesn't count against her annual cap. It is accounted for separately from her contributions, so might technically not be a part of her 401k.
- exclusiv 9y agoOr if your 401k has decent funds available and you also want to lower your taxable income for the year.
- ericd 9y agoNot really, it also makes sense to have one if you're already maxing out your IRA (as long as it's a low fee 401k, many aren't).
- Joky 9y agoI'm using it to save taxes, because I'm not sure what are the alternatives. You're comment makes me feel I should be less ignorant: any good online reading to suggest?
- wils1245 9y agoSaving on taxes is a good reason to contribute to a 401K. Just be mindful of the fees.
- avemg 9y agoThere isn’t a good tax-advantaged alternative if you’re an employee with access to a 401k. If you’re under the income limit, you can make deductible contributions to an traditional IRA but that’s capped at $5500 per year vs $18,000 for the 401k. Plus there’s no company match there. The best practice is to contribute to your 401k up to the employer match and then contribute the rest to an IRA. Once you’re at the IRA limit you comtribute the rest to the 401k.
- marcoperaza 9y agoAnd when you leave your current job, you can transfer your 401k into a Rollover IRA, which you can invest however you want.
- cmurf 9y agoIt's worth doing the "what if" on a Roth 401(k). The money goes in after tax, so you lose the deduction, but the money grows tax free, and you can pull it out tax free. Usually you come out ahead paying tax on less money now, and no tax on the grown investment later. You can also open an IRA on your own and stuff that to the limit every year. Again there is a Roth version, which you can dip into for certain things before retirement age without penalty, and never pay tax on the withdrawal because tax was paid already going in. Another thing to look into is if your employer can offer an HSA qualifying health care plan. You get a tax deduction on the front end when funding the HSA, and it can grow tax free, with tax free withdrawals for qualifying medical expenses - the trick is to never use it while you're working. Just pay co-pays, and deductible amount from pocket, instead of from the HSA. Use the HSA later to pay the things Medicare doesn't (which is a lot). The best way to avoid taxes is to make the maximum possible contribution every year now while you can.
- cmurf 9y agoWhy are you saying this? The employee can make up to $18,000 in contributions to a 401k, and still max out their IRA (Roth or conventional). You're not maxing out your retirement savings options if you're refusing to participate in a 401k. For those who are self employed should look into SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, in addition to making the max contribution to a Roth IRA and HSA. For those over 50, many offer additional catch up contribution limits, which raise the max contribution you can make each year.
- nunez 9y agoBecause not all 401k’s offer low-fee funds, whereas IRAs are more flexible
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoI think you are wrong, because of saving on taxes, and company match, and the fact that many people won't save otherwise, 401ks often make sense. Just chose sensible investments that don't have high fees. I know that's actually nontrivial, but otherwise many people don't have savings.