6 ms·
Of even greater concern to me than the loss of the tactile experience that books give to readers is that, to my knowledge, there's nothing equivalent to the pub
by theBobMcCormick 16y ago
Of even greater concern to me than the loss of the tactile experience that books give to readers is that, to my knowledge, there's nothing equivalent to the public library system for e-readers. Libraries are important for any youth, but particularly for poor and disadvantaged youth. They're a huge democratizing force, providing mountains of information and education for free to even the poorest members of society. Thanks to the prevalence of DRM on ebooks, I think the odds are against us seeing anything as universal and far reaching for ebooks.
Ebooks are great for the privileged middle and upper class. But thanks to DRM they lack the lend-ability and share-ability of real books, and they require a relatively expensive ebook reader. Even if libraries have the ability to lend every ebook ever published, it'll still require kids using the library to have a relatively expensive and fragile e-book reader. With real books, all they have to bring is an inquisitive mind.
With real books, even poor and disadvantaged children have access to books, not just through libraries, but also through borrowing, and sharing books from friends, relatives, neighbors, etc. And because most books are cheap to the point of damn near disposable in our society, most kids can count on getting gifts of books, hand-me-down used books, etc. Heck, it's pretty easy to scrape up an enough for a paperback on an allowance, lawn jobs, etc.
This worries me a lot. While I know that the circumstances I grew up in are very privileged compared to most of the world, we were poor by US standards. My family was often on some form of public assistance, and there's no way in hell I could have afforded a Kindle, Nook, etc. if such a thing had existed in those days. Growing up, the local public library was my teacher, my escape, my best friend. I'm saddens me to think kids in the near future may not have access to that same wonderful resource.
- kiba 16y agoWhat about the internet and hand-me down computers? It's about 40 bucks a month for a decent internet connection right? Maybe the computer is worth three furniture pieces.
- theBobMcCormick 16y agoGeesh! How out of touch with reality are you?!? Do you have any idea how many families in the US can't afford $40 bucks a month? That's assuming that the parents are supportive of buying a computer and an internet connection. If not, the kid on his own is fucked if he's gonna need a computer and 40 dollar a month internet connection to get access to the library.
- billswift 16y agoBasicISP dialup is $6.95 per month. You can't listen to music, watch videos, or play games over it, but it is plenty adequate for reading text. And you can access it anywhere there's a phone.
- sp332 16y agoWhat if the Kindle is the library? Instead of checking out a book, you borrow a Kindle locked to the library's Amazon account. Instead of paying for a Kindle, you just put up a damage deposit.
- theBobMcCormick 16y agoVery different costs involved for the library. Instead of loaning some 7 year old kid a 5 dollar paperback, you gotta lend him a much more fragile 200 dollar Kindle. Not to mention you need to stock enough Kindle for every patron who might want one in addition to purchasing licenses for the books. Right now, every book can be lent out individually. A library might have lent out all it's copies of a specific title, but as long as there's a single book left in the building, they've still got something to lend. It seems like that simplifies capacity planning quite a bit as opposed to the model of having to provider readers as well as ebooks.
- v21 16y agoLet's hope ebook piracy takes off, then.