5 ms·
Not everyone can be in the top 1% of paid professionals in their field. That extends to acting or consulting. And there simply aren't enough clients that can pa
by ineedasername 9y ago
Not everyone can be in the top 1% of paid professionals in their field. That extends to acting or consulting. And there simply aren't enough clients that can pay that much to support a significant increase in the # of folks pulling down those fees, regardless of the quality of the service offered. If 100 Michael Jordans showed up tomorrow, that would just increase competition for the same scarce resource of NBA player slots, not the number of slots. Professional sports or acting make these dynamics more transparant, but they're at play in all professions.
- Retric 9y agoI would argue that increasing the number and quality of great actors increases the profitably of movie studios, and thus the number of movies made. Similarly with sports, there is a huge range of player incomes and assuming the sport becomes more interesting to watch and thus profitable their would be room for more highly compensated players.
- s73ver_ 9y agoFor that to happen, they would have to increase the number of teams. This requires new stadiums/arenas to be built, and expansion teams to be created. This requires rebalancing of conferences and divisions within the league.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt also requires a fanbase.
- kemitche 9y agoAnd, over several decades of the NFL, all of that has happened several times.
- walshemj 9y agoYour assuming that every where else follows the socialist model that American sports do i.e. a pre entry closed shop for franchises with no consequences for failure - a premier league footballer has far more incentive to play well to stop his team getting demoted and facing a massive drop in his salary.
- emodendroket 9y agoYou should be required to pass a test on what the word "socialist" means before you're allowed to start throwing it around like this.
- walshemj 9y agoI think I have a better idea than you do and your seelioning here BTW the way the NFL etc are set up is very similar state controlled enterprises where run under more socialist regimes British Leyland ICL and so on.
- emodendroket 9y agoI don't think you do because the NFL is a system where surplus value is captured by the owners of the teams
- ineedasername 9y agoMost leagues in the U.S. have fairly open methods of getting on the team with the athletic talent required. For the NFL, anyone can pay a tryout fee and walk on to one of (usually) 8 spots. The other 45 are normally used by the veteran players good enough to have a multi-year contract or the new draft picks from college ball. And the consequence for failure are huge: 90 players start the pre-season, and after training & a few pre-season games, teams have to drop that to 53. 10 extra can be part of a training squad, which represents a 75% pay cut compared to the league minimum for the 53.
- walshemj 9y agoI was taking about the teams compare this where the bottom 2 teams from the top flight football get relegated each season - this is like the bottom 2 teams in the nfl get dropped and replaced each year
- Retric 9y agoI don't think athletic ability directly translates to higher revenue. But, their is also showmanship which more closely relates to revenue. Some players make 50x+ what other players are making. Having linemen make 10 million per year does not involve adding linemen it involves linemen that are worth being paid 10 million / year. At the same time football has added new teams over time and increased both the number of players and minimum salary significantly from inception.
- emodendroket 9y agoToday's pro sports players are, as a rule, far better than pro sports players in the past. Why isn't this happening already? People only have so much time and attention. Also, many leagues operate with salary caps. You also mentioned movies, but a lack of competent actors is far from the biggest reason there aren't more movies being produced.
- njarboe 9y agoAre you saying there is not an upward trend in sports salaries? They have been skyrocketing for decades and decades.
- emodendroket 9y agoNo, the discussion is about whether if you had a thousand Tom Bradys they could all play quarterback in the NFL.
- Retric 9y agoPlenty of great movies had a ~20 million dollar budget, but few moves with that kind of a budget had high returns. In terms of movies, studios look a lot like a VC firm with a term sheet from hell. However, plenty of studios died over time and would be making moves today if their past movies where more profitable. Sure, you needs a direct / script / special effects etc, but low budget movies with simple scripts and great actors also work without X00 million dollar budgets. So, their is clearly some wiggle room in terms of number of movies produced per year.
- emodendroket 9y agoThere are also countless starving aspiring actors so I doubt actor supply is your problem
- Retric 9y agoRaw supply may not be the problem, it could be training etc. Plenty of people are in a move, it takes something else to have the kind of run of a Robert De Niro or Anthony Hopkins. And generally people that have those kind of long runs are significantly more talented that many others. They also often have family in the business, who presumably pass on more than just a foot in the door.
- kamaal 9y ago>>Not everyone can be in the top 1% of paid professionals in their field. The whole point of the 1% is the remaining 99%. The axiom of this game is there are filters enough to filter out the 99%.
- chrishacken 9y agoNot everyone can; but anyone can.
- yequalsx 9y agoAs an extreme counter example can a person with an IQ or 50 do it? Clearly not. So not everyone can. There’s a range of abilities and personality types. I suspect the number of people with the ability/personality type necessary for $10,000 a week gig is much less than you imply.
- chrishacken 9y agoPersonalities are built; you're not born an introvert. Anyone can be built into a leader; go join the Marine Corps if you don't believe me.
- perl4ever 9y agoYou can't teach any arbitrary thing (nor temperament) to any arbitrary person. For a specific example, consider: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teichm%C3%BCller_space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teichm%C3%BCller_space I can say that not only would I never get anywhere with math at that level, but some of the related mathematical pages on Wikipedia surpass my ability to even tell if they are real or the work of cranks. For any random person, there are things they can't do or learn because of the way they're made, any more than a cow can do calculus. What's deceptive is that people constantly tell you that you must believe in yourself. But the reason isn't that believing in yourself is sufficient for success - the reason is believing in yourself is necessary to succeed so everyone who is successful attributes their success to that.
- chrishacken 9y agoGiven enough time and training, anyone who puts their all into learning it, is capable of understanding that. It may take them 20 years to learn math from the ground up, but they can do it. Saying someone can't do something is bullshit. That's sheep mentality.