4 ms·
No. It's about building a chip that isnt going to crash when the voltage drops for a picosecond, allowing throttling to happen only as needed without fear of c
by sandworm101 9y ago
No. It's about building a chip that isnt going to crash when the voltage drops for a picosecond, allowing throttling to happen only as needed without fear of crash.
- ghshephard 9y agoAre there processors out there that can handle voltage drops without crashing?
- ComputerGuru 9y agoPretty much all processors start off that way. The clock speed needs to drop to compensate, though. Unless you actually put some thought into your hardware designs because you're making phones that have a life expectancy of greater than a mere 12 months that will be used around the world for years to come... in which case you can easily reference an electrical engineering textbook and design a circuit that can buffer enough power and supply sufficient voltage/current to meet your expected max sustained power draw with some very simple and cheap components. But simple frequency scaling based off of _dynamically detected_ available power. There's no need to slow down a CPU based off the age of the battery so you can "guess" what the max speed you can safely run at without inducing a brownout is (and even less of a reason to do so in discrete steps instead of linearly scaling the performance, except if you're trying to do it discreetly) - all you have to do is monitor available power and scale the CPU clock rate accordingly in realtime. But if your circuit is poorly designed with no forethought as to what you'd do if the maximum rated power of the battery wasn't available, I suppose that's not so easy to retrofit.
- sliverstorm 9y agoModern x86 chips have built in support for voltage drops, as part of margin recovery. As the chip changes activity profile increasing current draw (e.g. turning on all cores for multithreaded code) the voltage will drop until the regulators catch up. "Back in the day" you used margin to accommodate this. Today, circuitry detects these events on the fly and slows down the chip for a few microseconds waiting for the voltage to recover. This allows you to remove margin and operate closer to the limit.
- tmd83 9y agoEssentially they designed a processor that cannot handle the normal variance of real life usage and so did a software fix that's very expensive to the user but very cheap for them. I am wondering is there a reason they can't be sued to oblivion for this?
- QAPereo 9y agoSued? Yes. To oblivion? No... not enough harm done, and Apple has good lawyers and deep pockets.
- alkonaut 9y agoIt's a tradeoff. Building a chip with more margin costs perf and/or power too. So it's a game you can't win.
- sandworm101 9y agoNo. You can build circuit to accommodate small voltage fluctuations without crashing things, defeating the need to drop the clock speed 24/7. Lots of other chips do this. Apple dropping clock speed as phones age is a very convenient excuse for an anti-feature to sell new phones.