3 ms·
This inverts the sequence of events. What is written in the article: This past Sunday HP researcher Vinay Deolalikar became the second person at HP to fall vic
by scott_s 16y ago
This inverts the sequence of events. What is written in the article:
This past Sunday HP researcher Vinay Deolalikar became the second person at HP to fall victim to the Internet fameball machine, as he posted his attempt to prove P ≠ NP on his personal website, and sent out an announcement email, which got picked up by the original formulator of the problem, Stephen Cook. Cook forwarded Deolalikar’s email to select mathematician colleagues with the now infamous statement “This appears to be a relatively serious claim to have solved P vs NP.”
Those who have been following this on HN know the real sequence of events:
1. Deolalikar emailed his paper to a select few theorists so that they could review it. In other words, he was soliciting peer-review.
2. Someone leaked the paper. It made it up to scribd first, as far as I know. Eventually pdfs were in the wild.
3. HN and others caught on to the developing story.
4. Presumably since the cat was out of the bag, Deolalikar posted the announcement on his webpage along with a pdf of the paper.
With these facts in mind, the lede is, well, misleading. As written:
What happens when Twitter and online communities filter scientific discovery ahead of professionals?
That's clearly not what happened, since the paper was first sent to the people who are most qualified to evaluate it. Further, the next sentence,
As we saw this week, a lot of fuss over a result that will ultimately be discarded into the dustbin of flawed mathematical proofs.
That remains to be seen.
(This is a long way of saying what RiderOfGiraffes said.)