3 ms·
While I don't doubt that Harry Reid is as corrupt a politician and as expert at funneling money to his cronies as, say, the late Robert Byrd was; there are A LO
by reaperducer 9y ago
While I don't doubt that Harry Reid is as corrupt a politician and as expert at funneling money to his cronies as, say, the late Robert Byrd was; there are A LOT easier and quieter ways of making it happen.
Especially for a sum as small as $22 million. Even county-level politicians can make that amount of money disappear without a trace and without leaving behind a warehouse and a paper trail.
To play the other side: What we have in the linked article is a couple of people who have never seen the objects in question stating categorically that they don't exist, or are ordinary. I'd believe the skeptics more if they'd at least seen the objects. But it's just a couple of guys several thousand miles away second-guessing some other guys with actual access to the objects.
Thanks, for the clickbait, SI. Next...
- titzer 9y agoI dunno, I read the article and the "guy a thousand miles away" gave pretty damn good reasoning why it'd be short work to identify and categorize "alien alloys". Or do you have an actual argument as to why these materials couldn't be readily identified and studied by competent physicists using well known technology?
- byebyetech 9y agoWould a material composed using highly advanced nanotechnology have strange properties purely due to its structure? Does it have to be an alloy?
- QAPereo 9y agoThat’s the issue, which really comes down to the word “Alloy” in this case. If you believe there’s a chance that the word alloy was used instead of a more accurate and technical term, then your points definitely stand. If they really meant alloy though? I’d tend to side it’s the article. I mean you can imagine some strange and exotic materials maintained by some kind of alien power source, but lose the power and the material should decay in some fashion. For a purely fictional example see things like degenerate matter held in some kind of sci-fi stasis.
- ridgeguy 9y agoYes, and it doesn't have to be an alloy. Structure is the basis for 'invisibility cloaks', materials with small-scale structures which confer optical properties not found in the same unstructured bulk materials. [1] Another example of where structure confers strange properties on elements (not alloys) is light emission from indirect-gap materials like silicon. Make silicon particles small enough and you can get light emission that you can't from bulk silicon. See quantum dots [2] and other similar structures. Structure can really change things. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metamaterial_cloaking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metamaterial_cloaking [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_dot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_dot
- QAPereo 9y agoOne key point is that metamaterials have unusual bulk properties, but they’re still made from the usual materials, alloys, etc.
- titzer 9y agoIf it is Earthish temperature, it going to be made of normal atoms (i.e. elements we have identified on the periodic table) and mass spectrometry and X-ray crystallography would be common tools that physicists would use to identify its molecular structures. And yes, highly advanced nanotechnology uses regular old atoms, as far as Science can see today.
- ajross 9y ago> I'd believe the skeptics more if they'd at least seen the objects. So your standard for proof is that someone said A but provided no proof, yet those who are skeptical about A's truth aren't to be trusted because they... Weren't provided proof to refute?!