4 ms·
Most everyone will get a break. There is a weird crunch for people making between $200K and $400K in a high tax state like CA or NY who will come out behind du
by jedberg 9y ago
Most everyone will get a break. There is a weird crunch for people making between $200K and $400K in a high tax state like CA or NY who will come out behind due to the loss of deduction on their property tax and state tax, and since they live in CA or NY, are probably barely middle class at those wages.
The bigger issue is that, for example, the Walton family alone will get 5% of the 1.5 trillion dollar tax break. The Trump family will get a huge break too. It's unlikely that the Walton family or the Trump family will suddenly start making a ton of economic activity because of their windfalls, but in the meantime government revenue is down, which means they have to start cutting services.
So most of the tax breaks for the lower earners will be eaten up over the next few years in paying for things the government used to subsidize for them.
- reaperducer 9y ago> Most everyone will get a break No, that can't be right. I saw that only the five richest people in America with solid gold toilets are getting a tax break, and that everyone else is going to be fed into a wood chipper. It was on TV, so it must be true.
- betterunix2 9y agoI live in NJ, another state where the $200k-$400k will be hurt. Believe me, that is solidly middle class, even when a 1BR rents for $3k/month. The real problem with these "tax breaks" is that the most significant breaks are highly specific and selective. This tax bill basically picks winners and losers. Worse still, the winners tend to be people with the kind of investments and lifestyle that Republican lawmakers have (e.g. the Corker kickback), and the losers tend to be professionals living in Democrat-leaning states (e.g. tech workers). The relatively small breaks that the majority will receive are temporary, and represent a minefield of exceptions that can leave people with no break at all (e.g. the loss of exemptions). There is a reason Republicans are picking oddly specific examples of people the bill will benefit -- most people will not see much, which is not a very compelling story.
- smacktoward 9y ago> I live in NJ, another state where the $200k-$400k will be hurt. Believe me, that is solidly middle class The median household in New Jersey in 2016 had an income of $76,212. (Source: https://www.census.gov/data-tools/demo/saipe/saipe.html?s_appName=saipe&map_yearSelector=2016&map_geoSelector=mhi_c&s_state=34&s_measures=mhi_snc&menu=grid_proxy https://www.census.gov/data-tools/demo/saipe/saipe.html?s_ap...) In the highest-income county in New Jersey, Hunterdon County, the median household in 2016 had an income of $113,336. You may wish to adjust your definition of “solidly middle class” a bit.
- betterunix2 9y agoI was going by what sort of lifestyle you can live with that income range. You can rent a nice apartment in a nice part of town and support a family on your salary. You could also go out to the suburbs and live in a largish house. You get one or two trips abroad with your kids each year. We are not talking about country clubs, yachts, or first class airfare here. It is not the 1%. It is between working class and upper class. What else would you call it?
- llamataboot 9y agoStatistically, quite rich.
- betterunix2 9y agoI disagree. The 1% is "quite rich." The 200k-400k income band is not the 1%. Like I said, the things wealthy people can afford are still out of reach. There is a group of people who are not living paycheck to paycheck but who still need to work full time. That group is called the middle class.
- americanjetset 9y ago>So your definition of "solidly upper class" is the top 10% of earners? That's a pretty loose definition IMO. You stated that above. I'd say your definition here is quite a bit more "loose."
- Shivetya 9y agolooking at it by a $ per family is wrong and gives the wrong impression of how it affects families. If anything the bad part is that it makes the system even more progressive and the US has one of the most progressive system in existence. now why is that a problem, because it favors having politicians cater to this group by creating all sorts of carve outs so they can get back some of these taxes paid usually by supporting the same politicians.
- vkou 9y agoIf $400K is 'middle' class in CA or NY, how exactly are 'lower' class people expected to live? By roasting pigeons in a fire barrel under a highway underpass? As someone who went from earning $25K to $85K to $300K, I have near-zero empathy for the tax bills that any American family making above $200K faces... Or any of the owner class that is coming out as the big winner with the new tax bill. Here's the thing. If you're making $400K in CA or wherever, you're not middle class. You're an upper class worker. You still need to show up to the office to do your 9-5-5, or your 6-9-6, or whatever it is you get paid for. Your interests are not aligned with those of your CEO, or even the CEO of the shitty temp sourcing company down the street, who makes half as much as you do. But you are also not, by any means, middle class. You can drop out of this rat race in five years of frugal living, and retire far more comfortably then the poor sap filling orders at an Amazon warehouse will after 40 years of back-breaking work.
- jedberg 9y agoI've had this argument before, but basically, with $400K a year, you can afford two cars and a 2000 sq ft house with good schools, and maybe a nice vacation. So yeah, you're not hurting, but you're not wealthy enough to retire and maintain that lifestyle. Sure, you could "live frugally" and retire after a few years, but you'd literally have to live in a tent and then retire somewhere that isn't California. That might be ok for some, but for others it isn't. I don't know how people making less than $200K a year live here comfortably. I mean I do know, because I know people like that. They live in a house that they inherited from their parents, they don't do anything out of the house, and they live near bad schools with high crime.
- vkou 9y agoAllright, I'll bite. Let's do a simple budget for a $400K household. This puts you in the top 1.2% of incomes, nation-wide, by the way. Say, 40% of that goes towards income taxes (A bit of a high estimate, even, since taxes are progressive, there are deductions, your 401K isn't taxed, but whatever). That leaves $240,000. Two adults, so $40,000 goes to your 401K, no questions asked. It's the responsible thing to do. You're already saving as much as a median SF household takes home, but that's fine. Two cars. You can buy a working car that will probably last you seven years for $10,000, or ten years for $20,000. Let's ammortize it at $2,000/year, with another $3,000/year in gas, insurance, oil changes, tires, etc. That's $190,000 left over. Let's say you take two nice family vacations, for another $20,000 total. That's not living frugally, since you're spending more money on fun then what someone making your coffee makes in a year, but that's fine, you're definitely middle class. Let's say you save another $50,000/year. Kids need braces, your car may get dented, you might want to order tex-mex every once in a while, you want to build that retirement fund. You're left with $120,000/year in cash, to spend on food and housing. If you can't figure out how to live on that, I hate to break it, but you're mismanaging your money. The median SF household lives on $77,000/year - that is BEFORE taxes. Half of them manage to raise at least one child on that. $400,000/year is completely out of touch with what normal middle-class people can spend. You don't need two Model Ss, Junior doesn't need to go to a top 5% elementary school, and you can probably make due without a two-week trip to Spain and another to Hawaii.
- somecontext 9y ago> the Walton family alone will get 5% of the 1.5 trillion dollar tax break For some context, 5% of $1.5 trillion is $75 billion. This is ~45% of the current ~$170 billion total wealth of the Walton family. Walmart's net income was ~$14 billion/year in 2016. It pays ~$6 billion/year in taxes.