3 ms·
I think it would be better for the FCC to keep doing nothing at this point. Right now the ISPs are afraid that if they create a tiered network that there would
by nostromo 16y ago
I think it would be better for the FCC to keep doing nothing at this point.
Right now the ISPs are afraid that if they create a tiered network that there would be outrage and the government would move in and regulate their industry.
However, now Google has given them coverage by making it appear to the FCC and congress that there is a compromise that can be made into law. I'd actually prefer that there be only light regulation, but a healthy paranoia from the telcos that they would be strong armed by the government (and corporations like Google) if they start to violate net neutrality.
It reminds me of a debate in US history about the Bill of Rights. Some argued that by listing your rights, you are inherently implying that there are no rights other than those listed. The idea is that by not enumerating rights you expand them.
- wmf 16y agoI think the current state of regulatory uncertainty cannot last. Eventually Washington will get bored of the issue and — absent regulation — ISPs will go back to their old tricks.
- nostromo 16y agoPerhaps. But sometimes telling an industry not to fuck consumers or face regulation keeps them better behaved than telling them exactly how they are allowed to fuck consumers.
- djcapelis 16y agoWhich seems to exactly match up with the approach google proposed the government take with regard to wireless...
- napierzaza 16y agoWhat Google did would only be the beginning if there's not action. Telcos won't be worried anymore if Google/Verizon goes through.
- bad_user 16y ago> The idea is that by not enumerating rights you expand them. Bullshit. Only 2 things are giving you freedoms right now ... free markets where competition is real and regulations by an elected government ... the later doing good in some cases, bad in others. If you don't want government regulations (which let's be honest, aren't done for the good of the public most of the times), then you need ways to prevent monopolies. Advancements in technology are one way to do it ... and I clearly see Google's point of view. Wireless Internet is a much more competitive landscape, and IMHO the FCC would do more harm than good in the current market. I live in Europe and I'm paying ~ 20 euros per month for 3G Internet provided by Vodafone (~ 4 GB of traffic included, the bandwidth fluctuating between 2 - 4 Mbps). And it's a pre-pay card, no contract attached, and I'm paying whenever I feel like it. When a competitor approached me with an offer for a 2 year contract I almost told them to go fuck themselves. And now they are also offering a competitive pre-pay option. And 4 GB of traffic may not be enough ... but I remember the days when I was working over a 56 kbps telephone land-line. Things will improve.