3 ms·
> If the value of smart contracts is that they will execute as written with no possibility of third party interference then Ethereum is not a smart contract pla
by majormajor 9y ago
> If the value of smart contracts is that they will execute as written with no possibility of third party interference then Ethereum is not a smart contract platform.
Why would there be such value in a dumb contract platform like that? Historically, what societies have chosen to adopt such a set of values?
- kbenson 9y agoI think the perceived value comes from the assumption that contracts can be written perfectly. Apparently, some people believe that the problems encountered so far are just a matter of weeding out the problems and eventually contracts will be much less likely to have loopholes like this. I don't really agree with that worldview, but not strongly enough to bet that it won't reach some fairly safe equilibrium at some point. Even then though, a major bug could be lurking for years just waiting to be exploited later.
- samsonradu 9y agoThis is a rather perfectionist point of view, implying that our current day-to-day contracts are perfect and don’t have loopholes. Why do smart contracts have to be written perfectly to be usable by people. In the end, what’s perfect in the world around us? Big banks fail and lose people’s savings, cars break and cause deaths and it has’t stopped people from adopting these on a large scale and keep on improving them.
- kbenson 9y agoWanting all contracts and actions performed by them to be immutable is an odd point of view in my eyes, but I'm not sure I would call it perfectionist because the perfection depends on whether you think a perfect system fulfills the contracts to the letter or the spirit. In the physical world, we arbitrate contracts with authorities vested with the power to make decisions over them, such as courts, governments, mediators, etc that both parties have agreed has the final say, because the alternative is unworkable. In a consensus system such as a blockchain, that consensus is based on a majority of the participants. Wanting them to have no say on the outcome of actions is like wanting the courts to have no jurisdiction over your contracts.
- samsonradu 9y agoI see real value in smart contracts despite the mentioned flaws above. The smart contracts can automate A lot of transactions that use intermediaries, see notaries, lawyers, judges that do a ton of bulk work to validate paperwork authenticity, all sorts of agents and middle-men that charge fees etcetera. Ok, people say it’s not secure, contracts can be hacked, but why not back these smart contracts by law? And when issues/breaches happen have a judge decide. These tools should be complementary and should not eliminate each other. We can and probably will have smart contracts alongside the day-to-day bureaucracy to help us with the simple stuff at first. Like when I need to pay a couple thousand to a notary for changing ownership of an estate only because of trust issues. If that is not ripe for disruption then I don’t know what is. It’s like trying to jump from manual driving to fully automated driving and complaining it’s not safe and it won’t work.