3 ms·

> [SS] has massive assets Those "massive assets" are T-bills. If push comes to shove, who do you think will get shafted - SS or China? More to the point - ho

by anamax 16y ago

> [SS] has massive assets Those "massive assets" are T-bills. If push comes to shove, who do you think will get shafted - SS or China? More to the point - how much are you personally willing to pay to maintain the SS benefits for folks 10-20 years older than you? How much do you think that folks who are 10-20 years younger than you are willing to pay to maintain your SS benefits?

jbooth 16y ago
What happens if we put it all into the stock market and the baby boomers retire? I really don't want to see a stock market that has 3x the money coming out as is coming in.
- anamax 16y ago
  The stock market is ownership of various kinds of assets. The demand for those assets will change. However, it is world-wide. And, there are income producing assets. Folks are saying "I'd rather have an iPad than $400 even though I know that that ipad costs only $35 to make". T bills are a claim on future US tax revenue. That's very different.
  - jbooth 16y ago
    You didn't even begin to address my question, you just threw out a bunch of hand-wavey silliness about how "ownership" and "assets" makes everything ok. What happens to the prices of those assets when the baby boomers retire and are pulling out more money than there are young workers putting in? You have the same problems as SS. What if we had all of that SS money in the market? It'd be a disaster.
    - anamax 16y ago
      The whole world didn't have a baby boom at the same time. WRT companies that produce stuff, the critical time is not when boomers retire, it's when they stop spending money. Fortunately, many will stop when they die, which reduces demand and the "load" on both the stock market and SS. Again, the whole world thing is relevant. And, since boomer spending is income for later generations.... Do you really think that money invested in the stock market is like SS obligations? (Here's another difference - Congress can repeal SS whenever it feels like it.)

by anamax 16y ago

jbooth 16y ago

What happens if we put it all into the stock market and the baby boomers retire? I really don't want to see a stock market that has 3x the money coming out as is coming in.

anamax 16y ago
The stock market is ownership of various kinds of assets. The demand for those assets will change. However, it is world-wide. And, there are income producing assets. Folks are saying "I'd rather have an iPad than $400 even though I know that that ipad costs only $35 to make". T bills are a claim on future US tax revenue. That's very different.
- jbooth 16y ago
  You didn't even begin to address my question, you just threw out a bunch of hand-wavey silliness about how "ownership" and "assets" makes everything ok. What happens to the prices of those assets when the baby boomers retire and are pulling out more money than there are young workers putting in? You have the same problems as SS. What if we had all of that SS money in the market? It'd be a disaster.
  - anamax 16y ago
    The whole world didn't have a baby boom at the same time. WRT companies that produce stuff, the critical time is not when boomers retire, it's when they stop spending money. Fortunately, many will stop when they die, which reduces demand and the "load" on both the stock market and SS. Again, the whole world thing is relevant. And, since boomer spending is income for later generations.... Do you really think that money invested in the stock market is like SS obligations? (Here's another difference - Congress can repeal SS whenever it feels like it.)