7 ms·
Mattermark (YC S12) to shut down after selling to FullContact
- draw_down 9y ago> In other words, Mattermark employee shares are worthless. Happy holidays everyone!!!
- nickfrost 9y agoBrutal result after years of work - "a less than $500,000 cash consideration from FullContact, which will be used to facilitate shutdown."
- gnicholas 9y agoIt wasn’t an all-cash deal: > The deal additionally included a stock transaction
- mooreds 9y agoYes, 500k of stock (at present value). So $1M. Tough outcome.
- gnicholas 9y agoSounds like you've got inside info. In situations like these does that go 100% to investors, or do founders/early employees take even a small piece?
- jpeg_hero 9y agoThe “inside info” of actually reading the article. Hahah.
- gnicholas 9y agoAh, I see the article has been updated. The details on the stock side of the transaction were not in there when I read the article yesterday.
- jasondrowley 9y agoThe article said that "common" shareholders walk out with nothing. Typically, founders and early employees are issued only common stock, while investors are issued "preferred" shares. Unless the founding team invested their own capital alongside the angels and professional VCs involved in their rounds, it's not likely that they were preferred shareholders. Preferred shareholders are first in line to get cash payouts after liquidation. Common shareholders are able to access cash only after all of the preferred shareholders have been paid. I wrote a series on the subject I could share if you're interested.
- highace 9y agoGreat news everyone! Ps. Not you.
- gk1 9y agoI signed up for a trial of Mattermark a month ago. Within several minutes I learned that: 1. Their database is terribly outdated. A company that was funded by X two years ago did not show up in a search for companies funded by X. 2. Their "show contact info" feature wasn't working. That's not an easter-egg feature; that's the feature they're selling! After several frustrating minutes I thought, "People pay for this?!" Evidently not. To be clear, I don't wish this on anyone. I have friends who've had to sell their company for peanuts, and I had a pleasant chat with the Mattermark CEO just recently, but what do you expect when you enter a crowded market with a product that isn't delivering on its basic promise?
- rmason 9y agoI'm left wondering what sort of due diligence their B round investors did if Mattermark's app was really all that bad?
- jacquesm 9y agoAt a guess, not a whole lot. And that is far more common than you would think.
- minimaxir 9y agoIt’s worth nothing that employees have been leaving Mattermark gradually over the past year, which could explain an out-of-date database/features if there isn’t anyone to update it.
- confiscate 9y agoYes, exactly. I see a lot of these comments on HN made by folks from-the-outside-looking-in. "I tried out this product. It had this bug I noticed that affected me a lot. By extension, this entire company will fail." That's like saying, I went to a restaurant. I noticed the silverware is a bit dirty, thus the shop will close down. Usually the commenter is someone who works in a specialized day job. Like an engineer :) Or silverware washer at a restaurant. Someone who sees and handles a narrow part of the picture. There are many possible reasons why Mattermark closed down. I am sad to see it. But it is probably not due to a specific feature or bug. There are probably reasons beyond the description in the article that led to the disappointing outcome. I hope Techcrunch will be able to find the reasons behind this so other startups can learn and avoid future tragedies :(
- einarvollset 9y agoHoping they will honor my year subscription somehow...
- toomuchtodo 9y agoDepending on when you charged it, you should probably contact your credit card company to charge it back if they’re unable to provide the service going forward.
- einarvollset 9y agoOhh. News you can use. Thank you!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- godzillabrennus 9y agoSorry to hear it didn’t pan out well for Danielle. I was rooting for them to try and find a business model that worked for them.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y ago> "I’m reaching out to share some great news" This is disgusting. Remember that this letter is: 1. for common shareholders who will get absolutely nothing out of this deal. 2. yet it's asking them to sign so that they can go ahead with the deal. 3. And to top it off, "I'm reaching out to share some great news"? Are you kidding me? To be clear, I support all entrepreneurs regardless of what ridiculous business model they're trying to pull off. I even think Magic Leap should be given a benefit of the doubt and they may be able to pull it off. Also I think it's great that silicon valley celebrates failure. Without this type of environment it's hard for founders to shoot for the stars. That said, people have taken this too far, and it's become ridiculous. It's no longer about it being ok to fail, but it's about "I failed, so what? I'm the genius and I totally deserve it and you just paid to tag along." I totally despise bullshit like this. If you lost, just say you lost. And say sorry. Don't bullshit people about how "it's a great news that I'm asking you to sign this letter so that other people--not you--will get the money you actually deserve".
- Pyxl101 9y agoIndeed. What is the incentive for any common stockholder to sign what they will be asked to sign? I could imagine someone holding back purely out of spite. Though I suppose, perhaps, if those common stockholders are employees who want to keep their jobs rather than be laid off, that might be one reason, though an individual wouldn't learn whether they'll be retained until a later stage of the acquisition.
- confiscate 9y agoAgree. If the goal of the letter is to get signatures, starting off with "great news" and then leading to "you get $0" does not seem to be the most convincing nor effective way to phrase a signature request. Well, if the reader is an employee holding Common stock, and the employee signs just to keep her job, then she would have signed regardless of what the letter said anyways. Basically, it's hard for me to see a Common stock holder reading the letter, and then going "Ya that makes sense, I'd buy this. Let me sign it now."
- colbyh 9y ago
- kayhi 9y agoI started getting worried when their pricing was no longer public and their blog posts didn’t make it on here any more. Enjoyed their insights on fundraising and the progress of their company. I imagine it’s harder to be open when things are not going as expected.
- mooreds 9y ago> I imagine it’s harder to be open when things are not going as expected. For a number of reasons, I believe this. * You don't get the rush of external validation * You are heads down trying to make things better at the company and blog posts don't help (enough) * It's hard enough to share bad newest with employees and investors, who wants to share it with the world * You may fear scaring off customers ("I was going to mattermark but then they seemed like they were going out of business so I used competing project")
- jasondrowley 9y agoI wrote a few of those articles! Say what you want about the company, product, and executive leadership, but for a time Mattermark was a fairly influential organization in the Valley and elsewhere. Mattermark can probably serve as a case study of how good written content can really bolster a company's credibility and positioning in a market.
- hai2ashwin 9y agoDanielle (if you read this), I was rooting for you to succeed (as a fellow entrepreneur in the same space). I hope you would write soon on what worked and what didn't. Data business is hard for a few reasons: 1. Data is a commodity until it is not. People's contact information is a 'done to death' problem but not solved yet (and probably not solvable completely) 2. Data is capital intensive 3. Data businesses (and the modern ones at that) are more annuity businesses and less like SaaS. Monthly recurring patterns take time to emerge and you need investors that understand this dynamic. They will if you prove that your core hypothesis works and customers are buying more (if not following a strict monthly pattern). 4. You need to have enough money and execution speed to prove your hypothesis. Unlike software where customer development and execution discipline can help you launch a good product, in the data business you need to stitch partnerships early on with data sources. That's not easy. You tried. Again, I'd love to read your reflections on what you could've done differently.
- confiscate 9y ago+1 I too was also rooting for you, Danielle, since the early days when you started Referly before pivoting to Mattermark. Back then there was not a lot of YC companies, and even fewer female YC founders to root for. +1 to a reflections blog post! Hope you succeed in the future--the best is yet to come.
- droopybuns 9y ago+1. You had an impact.
- randfish 9y ago+1 Also rooting for you Danielle - and always will be. Can't wait to see what you do next, and if I can ever be helpful, don't hesitate to ask.
- matco11 9y ago+ same here Also, I’ll miss the newsletter
- unclebucknasty 9y agoI just read through their website and I can see why it was tough. There's something especially difficult about a business like this. It doesn't feel like a finished product on offer, but more of a raw material for making of it what you will. Because when you look at their home page as a potential end customer, there isn't much in the way of real benefits on display. In fact, the main "features" are: -Automatically enrich leads in Salesforce -Customize your experience with API -Export Mattermark data to spreadsheets -Right Data. Right Format. Right now. 3 of those 4 are purely meta-features around accessing the data (which is presumably the core feature), but there's virtually nothing about why you'd want to or how to make it easily actionable. They're saying "here's a bunch of data and a bunch of ways to access it. Go make it do something for you." That's a tough sell because it doesn't answer an immediate need wherein you simply sign up and a problem is solved. Even if you are able to connect the dots WRT how you might make use of the data, you're now left with the task of building something on top of it. I'm not sure how many customers can do that. Seems the only way to make it work is to pull in very tight partnerships to build finished apps in specific verticals, through which you license the data/API.
- kapauldo 9y agoIs full contact viable?
- bjterry 9y agoThat sucks. I used to work in investment banking where we used a tool called Capital IQ for our research, despite the fact that our focus was on venture-backed startups and Capital IQ's coverage of startup companies was really crappy. When I left banking one of my top 2 or 3 ideas was to start a company that would essentially be Capital IQ for startups. The idea being that I would sell the overall platform to VC firms and investment banks, gain access to their data, and use it to build predictive models of non-venture-backed startups based on publicly-available information. I didn't end up pursuing that idea, but I was aware of Mattermark and thought that it was a service that should exist, would be a no-brainer for people targeting that market. To be honest, I think they did a lot better of a job of it than I would have. Back in April when I was looking for jobs I did get the chance to interview at Mattermark, though. Kevin Morrill and the rest of the engineers that I met all seemed very friendly and bright (they ultimately rejected me, which is good because [1] I would have accepted their offer, and [2] I ended up joining Flexport, which I love). Even at the time I got the impression that they may have a tough road ahead, but I'm sorry to see that things turned out this way.
- noomerikal 9y agoI don't understand why they pivoted to this contacts thing. I thought they had a solid idea previously. I guess CB Insights came along and took the ball the last 20 yards.
- reeteshv 9y agoI agree! I receive newsletters from both the services and I prefer reading the CB Insights for its casual style and lots of graphics.
- eps 9y agoYou can't make this up: Dear Mattermark Common Shareholders, I’m reaching out to share some great news: Mattermark is being acquired by FullContact! ... lorem ipsum ... Common stockholders will not be receiving anything in this deal (cash or stock). It's a letter to common stockholders saying they get zilch and calling this a great news. I sure hope it's just a quirky inner joke of some kind, because otherwise it reads like a spit in the face of aforementioned stockholders.
- BigMan555 9y agoThe CEO of Mattermark spent a lot of time and energy in the early days of the company establishing a public presence as a brash, highly opinionated thought leader in the “how to run a start-up” intellectual space, which makes the failure of the company a little ironic and is almost certainly contributing to the Schadenfreud I’ve read on Twitter. Take, for instance, this post, in which she seemingly boasts of the company’s massive burn rate: https://medium.com/@DanielleMorrill/is-my-startup-burn-rate-normal-882b2bd20f02 https://medium.com/@DanielleMorrill/is-my-startup-burn-rate-... Or this post, in which she shames a number of “Zombie Unicorns” (including WeWork): http://www.businessinsider.com/mattermark-names-troubled-unicorns-2015-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/mattermark-names-troubled-uni... Why be so publicly hostile and truculent? Also, it appears that the CEO lacked focus: according to her Twitter profile, she’s a VC and a very prolific angel investor. I’d be upset as an employee of the company receiving $0 for my common stock that the CEO was effectively hedging her Mattermark bet with a number of side gigs. The CEO’s job is to be singularly focused on the success of the company.
- minimaxir 9y agoNotably, there's been complaints that the TechCrunch article is too negative (https://twitter.com/sm/status/944087102982995969 https://twitter.com/sm/status/944087102982995969), which has the inverse problem.
- jpeg_hero 9y agoYeah, unreal. Hey @sm give me $17m and I’ll give you $1m back and we’ll gauge your positivity/negativity. This is the stuff that gives SV a bad reputation- the sense of entitlement. That of course we deserve “others people’s money” to do with what we please and should be praised for it. This is real money @sm !!
- lenley 9y agoThat aggressiveness gets noticed and picked up by lots of different outlets -- from tech aggregators to mainstream business publications looking for "punchy" topics. E.g. look at who appears on CNBC programs. Unfortunately, people have made that into a marketing strategy -- I'm not sure it is something to really hold against Mattermark in particular.
- motdiem 9y agoI wasn't using their product (found the data wasn't that great), but I really like their daily newsletter - I hope it'll find a new home.
- paulbjensen 9y agoLooks like FullContact got data/systems/source code, a customer list and 6 employees for $1m. Bargain!
- confiscate 9y agoyes. Would have cost Full Contact way more to do it themselves from scratch (collect all the company data, get the customer list, the source code, and recruit 6 trained engineers who are ramped up on the source code)
- xrd 9y agoAnyone reading this thread that said "disgusting!" reveals to everyone else that you've never raised money. It is brutal and you have to be 100% prepared to tell your investors you lost everything. Even if you are one of the few who doesn't actually lose everything, you'll have multiple moments in your entrepreneurial path where you go over that conversation in your head, like an anti-Oscar speech, as you face the death of your company (and more importantly, your identity as one of the brilliant).
- skipd 9y agoYes, we should respect founders who try and fail but the amount of praise for a company with such little value doesn’t make sense. This praise for the failing founder would make a lot more sense if the company was chartering new and interesting ground.