6 ms·
“Silently”? macOS will pop a prompt for new root CA, and from what I’m reading in the thread, Windows will, too. Did I miss the part where a software vendor can
by mikestew 9y ago
“Silently”? macOS will pop a prompt for new root CA, and from what I’m reading in the thread, Windows will, too. Did I miss the part where a software vendor can slip in a new root CA without me knowing about it?
- noncoml 9y agoIs the word "silently" your only concern here? Not the fact that Blizzard installs a root CA, silently or not? Or are you trying to derail the conversation on purpose?
- enzanki_ars 9y agoIt wasn't silently added: > I got a strange prompt that Agent wanted to make changes on my computer and needed my admin password An admin/mod should change the title here, but the concern is still the same.
- taneq 9y agoAt this point, admin escalations are common and random enough that I'd imagine most users just click OK. You're installing a patch, that's changing software on your computer, right? So I guess it needs admin, right? I'm not sure how a normal user is meant to know what's legit and what's not.
- bagacrap 9y agoMost users have no idea what a root ca even is, so they have no ability to judge whether to accept or decline. Even with a prompt, they are not aware of what is happening.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoSo? This strawman user you've constructed has no idea what any of the blinkenlights in front of them are for. How much are you willing to make the desktop experience suck to cater to them? That was rhetorical. It's obvious from the state of modern desktop OSs what the answer is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ng12 9y agoYeah, why did we ever get away from the glory days of bare-metal programming. Computers are only for people who understand them. Sarcasm aside, I'm a software engineer with a very superficial understanding of the certificate system. I'm not even convinced of my own ability to notice when something's wrong.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoWhat I'm saying is: why do you people always assume the average user of a desktop computer is a drooling moron? Because that's what you're doing when you say shit like this. Thinking like that is what gave us forced automatic updates.
- ng12 9y agoI don't agree with your characterization as somebody who doesn't understand the significance of a root CA as a drooling idiot. The text of one of your post's siblings is: > A root lets you make a valid cert for any domain. It can be used to create a man-in-the-middle attack if paired with a proxy. If you were to walk down the street tomorrow and ask 10 people to define "cert", "domain", "MITM", and "proxy" I'd wager you'd get 0 correct responses. I'd also wager those 10 people use computers every day -- and I don't think that's a problem. You shouldn't have to study and understand byzantine systems just to use a computer.
- ntumlin 9y agoEven if it does prompt, 99% of users will read it as: Attention: You must click OK to play this game.
- mikestew 9y agoI understand this, but that wasn’t my question. And the only comment in all this typing under my original comment that even made an attempt to answer my question of whether or not a piece of software can install a root CA without my knowledge, well, that got downvoted, too.
- user5994461 9y agoTo reply to your question. It's possible to install a CA without one's knowledge. The battle update this week requested to run with admin rights, like a million of setup software. It didn't ask specifically "Allow setup.exe to install a system CA? Yes/No".
- mikestew 9y agoAh, thank you. And it’s the answer I suspected (use the admin rights of the installer), but apparently need to burn some points to get a confirmation.