3 ms·
A signal failure can lead to dead passengers, so maybe you want to reconsider that statement.
by adrianN 9y ago
A signal failure can lead to dead passengers, so maybe you want to reconsider that statement.
- lmm 9y agoSignalling is always fail-safe - as far as I can tell this is the case even when there are e.g. multiple redundant ways of detecting train presence, a failure of any one is treated as a reason to stop trains. Something like a cheap LED that burns out more frequently is not unsafe, it just means there would be more cases of trains having to stop because the signal light was out.
- notyourday 9y agoIf you are thinking about "verified" systems spent way too much in academia. Fundamentally, verification system is a traffic light problem. In case you do not know, the blinking yellow is "i crashed". That condition is not checked via code verification of Red/Yellow/Green state machine. It is checked via crossed green detector: a circuit that checks for a condition "green energized" on both and should that condition occur it crashes the Red/Yellow/Green state machine. That state machine will never recover until Bob shows up at a traffic box, looks to see if a sensor is dead, looks to see if box is OK and resets it by hand.