4 ms·
That's an interesting question, with an interesting premise. Will realism (graphics + physics simulation) take less compute than AI for sure? If we look at th
by dahart 9y ago
That's an interesting question, with an interesting premise.
Will realism (graphics + physics simulation) take less compute than AI for sure?
If we look at the limit case, the reality I can see out my window has more atoms than are in my brain. So, in theory perhaps, human-equivalent AI will similarly require less compute than realistic graphics & physics simulation/animation.
OTOH, evolution took billions of years and presumably depends on all the animals and all the physics that has ever happened, so maybe inference will always be cheaper than graphics, and maybe AI training and evolution will always be more expensive?
I have no idea, but it's a fun thought experiment.
FWIW, I also worked for a Pixar competitor, and the renderfarm we had was indeed more compute than I had been exposed to before. That said, we didn't make a huge amount of effort to optimize the system, we only made sure really stupid things didn't cause overnight renders to take longer than required for dailies the next day. I'm absolutely certain that at least 1 order of magnitude is available to software render farms, if the primary focus shifts from production to optimization. I'm halfway sure that using today's and tomorrow's GPUs could get you at least another order of magnitude, but that comes with a second level of expensive engineering effort. In short, I think if you really really wanted it, and had the money & time to commit, you could probably have your three orders of magnitude right now.
- cr0sh 9y ago> In short, I think if you really really wanted it, and had the money & time to commit, you could probably have your three orders of magnitude right now. I'd imagine something along the lines of a datacenter, filled with racks stuffed full of these: https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/data-center/dgx-1/ https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/data-center/dgx-1/ ...but repurposed for graphics rendering instead of deep learning. In fact, it wouldn't surprise me to find out something like this actually exists (though whether for graphics or deep learning, I don't know). Also - I wouldn't be surprised to learn that a datacenter full of D-Wave machines exists somewhere (perhaps next door to the datacenter filled with DGX-1 systems - I mean, something has to make sense of the data output). Pure speculation, of course; I'd suspect we'd know about it though if it were the case, unless it was done as a government black project...