2 ms·
I think even calling it an "echo chamber" is a bit harsh. I have a home in the real world. When I am in it, I do not particularly want a nudist hippie drum circ
by jerf 9y ago
I think even calling it an "echo chamber" is a bit harsh. I have a home in the real world. When I am in it, I do not particularly want a nudist hippie drum circle in it. I do not want a Republican senator organizing his campaign in it. I don't need ten philosophy professors to come in and start debating the finer points of logical positivism. I don't want some guy to be there ranting and raving about how the lizard people are poisoning us all with chemtrails to prevent us from realizing how the world is going to end next Tuesday. There's nothing necessarily wrong with any of those things (though the last guy there might be mentally ill, but that's another complicated issue). But I don't want them in my space, all the time, without invitation (and even then, a solid exit plan).
This is not because I need my home to be an "echo chamber". It is because I need it to be a home. There's nothing wrong with having a "home" on the Internet either. It's just a lot harder to have one when you don't have width, height, and depth helping you delineate a space in the 3D universe, vs. the Internet, which easily degenerates into a zero-dimensional space where no distinctions can exist. Having a home doesn't prevent HN or Twitter from existing; nobody can stay in their homes all the time in either space. But the Internet is definitely getting less and less inviting for lacking the ability to have a "home" in it.
Thanksgiving just went by with HN denizens complaining a bit in some of the comment threads about how they are going to have to spend time with people they don't really want to, and the other holidays are coming up fast for a repeat performance. The homeless-Internet makes every day the day you have to spend like that, makes every minute the minute you have to spend like that. I fully believe people of a free society have some sort of obligation to engage with viewpoints they find uncomfortable (even if really nailing down what that means would be a challenge), but that doesn't mean everyone needs to be doing it all the time, without rest. I wouldn't expect that to produce understanding; I'd expect it to produce conflict and bitterness, not even necessarily because of the views themselves, but just from the sheer tiredness of never being able to rest anywhere for even a moment.