3 ms·
Where I learned driving, the driver is definitely required to monitor what's coming from behind when making a turn. The mantra is "mirror, indicator, shoulder":
by FabHK 9y ago
Where I learned driving, the driver is definitely required to monitor what's coming from behind when making a turn. The mantra is "mirror, indicator, shoulder":
1. look in the mirrors
2. put on the indicator (turn signal)
3. just before turning, look over your shoulder to make sure you're not running over anyone
However, given how lazily and inconsiderately many people drive, the annoying but defensive rule you describe might be the better tradeoff: make life worse for all cyclists to safe a few lives.
- scoggs 9y agoBut at the end of the day who is wrong in a situation where a car signals to turn into the bike lane ahead of a biker (with plenty of room, it's safe) and then signals again to turn right at an intersection if the bike decides to go around the car on the right anyways and gets hit by it? I view the issue people are having with Uber's Self Driving Cars not "handling right turns in bike lanes well" in the same light as the reason you take a left hand turn at an intersection from the left-most lane. If you tried to take a left from the right most lane it puts everyone to your left at danger and definitely doesn't let people coming towards you know what you are doing. I feel the same exact thing should apply to the right lanes and bike lanes regardless if it is a car or a bike. To turn right you get as far right as you can, you check your mirrors sure, but you don't really let what anyone else is doing behind you change how you drive. I view worrying about driving in that way is possibly evidence that you are the scared, defensive-type driver. Hesitation can be a killer.
- godelski 9y agoBut there's a evolutionary problem here. You don't have eyes in the front and back of your head. Bikes are small and hard to miss. They can easily slip into your blind spot while you are looking at the road and switching to look in the mirror. You're right, a driver is definitely required to monitor what's coming from behind them when making a turn. But when we consider limits in eyesight, moving into the lane keeps everyone safer.
- tehlike 9y agoYou are assuming a fully observable environment - where everything is visible. To be honest with you, many bikers are not, or not from every angle possible. Most of the bikes I have encountered do not follow the road signs either (especially lights & stop signs - they just breeze through). With this in mind, given cyclists are the ones in danger (As opposed to the driver sitting in his car), it's safer to give the cyclist a clear sign of a right turn. I have seen way too many times where a cyclist used his judgement to pass through a car in what i call rather dangerous way, so I rather block their path to save their life than to trust them to use their best judgement. Cyclists are often invisible, and more susceptible to injuries, and I am being cautious and not leaving any doubt about when and how I will turn, by blocking the path. When I give a right turn sign, you just cannot pass through me assuming i won't be turning in the next second.