2 ms·
But realism was achievable and was achieved not that long later; Lord of the Rings is still a very good movie, you can start to see the CGI is a bit dated but f
by Cthulhu_ 9y ago
But realism was achievable and was achieved not that long later; Lord of the Rings is still a very good movie, you can start to see the CGI is a bit dated but for a long time, e.g. Gollum's character was the benchmark - worse, the Hobbit movies couldn't even top it, despite being made over ten years later.
- ekianjo 9y agoGollum, while very good, was never good enough to be said to be photorealistic or something. Your eye would not be fooled that easily.
- neonhomer 9y agoGollum was definitely a benchmark, maybe even still. Then there's Avatar and Cesar from the Apes movies. But we've yet to get close with actual humans. What started with Final Fantasy we still have that "uncanny valley" in things like Tron and Star Wars: The Force Awakens. Side note: I can't find an article but I believe Gollum was one of the first times deaf movie-goers could actually read a digital actor's lips.
- lobster_johnson 9y agoI find it weird how producers still insist on shoe-horning CGI humans into movies even when the technology clearly isn't there yet. In Star Wars: The Last Jedi, Snoke is entirely CGI for no discernible purpose, and it's uncanny valley hell every second he's on screen. It's all in the animation, of course; the rendering itself is great, but there's something really off about his movements and facial expressions. What's odd is that they could easily have produced this character using a real actor in prosthetics, with some subtle CGI augmentations. Tarkin in Star Wars: The Force Awakens is even worse, like something out of a video-game cutscene. I don't understand why they couldn't just have used an actor.