2 ms·
Signals are expensive because of their safety guarantees (and because of lack of competition). That LED light you can buy for a few bucks doesn't guarantee eigh
by adrianN 9y ago
Signals are expensive because of their safety guarantees (and because of lack of competition). That LED light you can buy for a few bucks doesn't guarantee eight nines of uptime if you keep to the maintenance schedule. You also can sue the manufacturer if a train runs a red because the LED broke. Signals and other trackside equipment make up a large part of the costs of building rail.
- exabrial 9y agoExactly what I was thinking: certification and insurance
- concerned_user 9y agoNot really, it is all because you have this crazy idea that mass transit systems should be profitable and/or self-sustaining so with the intent of getting profit they cut corners. Most other countries have subsidized or even free mass transit systems and they realistically don't expect them to be profitable, but helping people/goods to be moved is considered more important. It is one of those natural monopolies where privatizing stuff doesn't really work.
- aninhumer 9y agoGenerally I'd agree that it's better to just let the government subsidise it (or just run it) and accept the cost in exchange for the economic benefits. However, there is one way to make it work privately, and that's to capture some of those economic benefits by buying the land around stations. If someone buys some relatively cheap land near a city and then builds a train line from there to the centre, the value of that land increases and so they can charge higher rents on any housing, offices or shop units built there.
- StudentStuff 9y agoThis is illegal nearly everywhere but China, as the rail company becomes the 500 pound, rent seeking gorilla that has dominion over large chunks of a city, or state.
- crocal 9y agoNo, it is not. Plenty of examples around the world, and it generally works better. Copenhagen and Hong-Kong come to mind.
- themaninthedark 9y agoJapan as well, If you go outside major train stations in the large city there are big department stores run by the train company. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kintetsu_Department_Store https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kintetsu_Department_Store https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isetan#Subsidiaries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isetan#Subsidiaries
- dsr_ 9y agoThe US subsidizes mass transit systems. The biggest subsidies go to the highway system.
- ams6110 9y agoNot sure who "you" is here but nowhere in the USA is public transit expected to be profitable (excluding private coach and shuttle services, airlines, etc. as those are not "public") or even self-sustaining. The general problem is like most government services they are money pits with incompetent, corrupt management.
- rayiner 9y ago> Most other countries have subsidized or even free mass transit systems and they realistically don't expect them to be profitable, but helping people/goods to be moved is considered more important. Here is a good map of "farebox recovery ratio" (the percentage of operating costs funded by fares): https://people.hofstra.edu/geotrans/eng/gallery/Map_World%20Farebox%20Ratio.pdf https://people.hofstra.edu/geotrans/eng/gallery/Map_World%20.... Quite a few asian systems recover more than 100% of operating costs, and a couple of European systems do, but no American ones. London's public transit system, for example, gets 25% of its funding from the government. The NYC MTA is at 45%.
- usrusr 9y agoThat and actually not killing a great many people, as that dj light signal would inevitably do sooner or later. Rail signaling isn't just a convenience and throughput optimization like road traffic lights are, with little consequence in the case of failure. Failing rail signals are more deadly than falling air traffic controls.
- jessriedel 9y agoThe legacy parts manufactured half a century ago have eight nines of uptime?
- AlgorithmicTime 9y agoOf course not, but you can't sue the manufacturer because they were made before that law was in place. Also the manufacturer is probably out of business by now.
- adrianN 9y agoRelays are pretty reliable if you exchange them regularly enough. Just because the stuff is old it doesn't mean that you can't build machines with enough redundancy to make them very dependable. It's not so clear that complex software solutions as in modern interlockings are more dependable than the comparably simple electromechanical solutions of yore. Cheaper, yes, more capable, sure, but more reliable?
- NikolaeVarius 9y agoNot just dependable in terms of systems engineering, these things were also massively "overdesigned" to be extremely reliable no matter what.
- jessriedel 9y ago> Just because the stuff is old it doesn't mean that you can't build machines with enough redundancy to make them very dependable. I can do the same with 1-dollar modern parts.
- adrianN 9y agoThat's exactly what the companies building these things do. It's not the material that's expensive, it's all the paperwork necessary to prove that it actually provides the guarantees that it does.
- jessriedel 9y ago
- betterunix2 9y ago"You also can sue the manufacturer if a train runs a red because the LED broke" FYI, MTA operating procedures require trains to stop when a signal is not lighted, then coordinate by radio before proceeding. There is also a defense-in-depth strategy: the interlocking maintains 4 red signals between trains, so a collision in theory would require 4 failing signals, 4 failing stop arms (which automatically stop trains that ignore red signals) and a train operator ignoring the rules.