5 ms·
Signals are expensive? That kind of blows my mind. A chaveut dj LED light that responds to dmx commands can be had for a few bucks
by exabrial 9y ago
Signals are expensive? That kind of blows my mind. A chaveut dj LED light that responds to dmx commands can be had for a few bucks
- gozur88 9y agoIt must be one of those things that's harder than it looks - China had a train crash because they decided to roll their own signals.
- exabrial 9y agoAgree, it's obviously much different than a lighting effect in practice. What I'm trying reconcile is the hardware and software. Are there truly that many differences physically? The cost of signals probably comes from certifications I'm guessing
- Symbiote 9y agoDid you take any computer science courses on software verification? That is, proving your program does what you intend. It's complicated, difficult, and the people who can do this are expensive. Railway signaling systems, alongside air and spacecraft, and sometimes consumer devices that would be expensive to firmware update during the warranty, are the few places software verification is used. The specification we are verifying the software against must also be proven to be correct, including failing safe. The hardware also has to perform, at all reasonable temperatures, humidities, with vibration, poor power, and for an expected life of at least 50 years. The people installing the hardware must be checked, to ensure the work is done correctly. A crossed wire is a critical fault, I imagine there's a long and detailed procedure for connecting every wire. [1] is an interesting read, a retrospective on a bad crash in 1988 in Britain which led to many improvements in signaling safety. https://www.railengineer.uk/2014/01/06/25-years-after-clapham-a-review-of-signalling-procedures/ https://www.railengineer.uk/2014/01/06/25-years-after-clapha...
- icebraining 9y agoBut most of that work can be reused, you're not building the whole software from scratch each time, so those fixed costs get diluted. According to Wikipedia[1], there are about half-dozen commercial systems that get heavily reused. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications-based_train_control#Architecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications-based_train_con...
- concerned_user 9y agoUnfortunately its not, yes framework is reused but business logic part is written from scratch most of the time and it is that part where most errors usually occur. That is why you can't just install SAP or Dynamics you need to program your logic and workflows into if first, the fact that framework itself is reused saves some time sure, but error probability increases with the amount of customization framework provides.
- icebraining 9y agoI'm talking about software designed for railway signaling, like SelTrac, not generic business platforms like SAP.
- crocal 9y agoSeltrac will not be accepted by MTA. They have their own CBTC specifications and Thales (seltrac supplier) is engaged in a large program to create a compliant product.
- Symbiote 9y agoI don't know, but presumably there's still a lot of work - planning and then (re)locating points/switches - planning and then (re)locating signals or balises - updating trains - configuring the software to reflect the track and signals - verifying the final configuration
- pjc50 9y agoThe signalling system probably has an extremely small amount of software in it, and if it's old the logic will be electromechanical; if a train is in the block, the entry signal will be red, because a particular relay is closed. The signal lamp itself is probably a small part of the cost compared to all the wiring and the time spent installing it. Edit: googling for "cost of railway signals" produces this very comprehensive PDF on the subject: www.credo-group.com/downloads/tco_of_rail_signalling_systems.pdf
- jon-wood 9y agoIf you just look at the signals as "a little red light that tells the driver to stop", then its not that complex. However in the rail world signals encompasses much more than that red light. There's sensors on the track which detect when a train enters a section of the line and when it leaves, and on modern systems there's communication with the train itself to force the brakes on if the driver runs a red light, making it near impossible to enter a section with a train already in it. All those parts need to communicate with each other, and they need to be ridiculously reliable, and capable of self-reporting when they fail, because in the worst case a failure in any one of those components results in a few hundred people dying in a dark underground tunnel.
- adrianN 9y agoSignals are expensive because of their safety guarantees (and because of lack of competition). That LED light you can buy for a few bucks doesn't guarantee eight nines of uptime if you keep to the maintenance schedule. You also can sue the manufacturer if a train runs a red because the LED broke. Signals and other trackside equipment make up a large part of the costs of building rail.
- exabrial 9y agoExactly what I was thinking: certification and insurance
- concerned_user 9y agoNot really, it is all because you have this crazy idea that mass transit systems should be profitable and/or self-sustaining so with the intent of getting profit they cut corners. Most other countries have subsidized or even free mass transit systems and they realistically don't expect them to be profitable, but helping people/goods to be moved is considered more important. It is one of those natural monopolies where privatizing stuff doesn't really work.
- aninhumer 9y agoGenerally I'd agree that it's better to just let the government subsidise it (or just run it) and accept the cost in exchange for the economic benefits. However, there is one way to make it work privately, and that's to capture some of those economic benefits by buying the land around stations. If someone buys some relatively cheap land near a city and then builds a train line from there to the centre, the value of that land increases and so they can charge higher rents on any housing, offices or shop units built there.
- StudentStuff 9y agoThis is illegal nearly everywhere but China, as the rail company becomes the 500 pound, rent seeking gorilla that has dominion over large chunks of a city, or state.
- tallanvor 9y agoYou are thinking of signals as just the lights telling the driver what to do, but the signals used in the subway are much more complex and include the hardware to know, for example, whether another train is on an upcoming stretch of track, or how a switch is set up ahead, which affects what tracks the train is routed onto. These aren't just electronic systems, they include mechanical hardware to detect the necessary information. The design of some of the signals still in use basically hasn't changed in 100 years!
- gambiting 9y agoHave you ever looked at industrial-grade hardware? You know, stuff that is actually certified to work for years on end in the worst conditions imaginable? If someone asked you, how much do you think a 12V power supply costs, would you say $5-10, because that's how much they go for on ebay? Try a National Instruments 12V supply - it's about ~$1200 for a power supply slightly larger than your phone charger. Why? Because it's certified to work in -80C and +120C without failure, in environments where explosive gases are present and in very high humidity environments. You can't use consumer hardware in industrial/commercial environments, and for a good reason.
- notyourday 9y agoThat was the story told by SGI execs. It was also a story told by Sun execs. And it was a story told by Unisys execs. But I'm sure it is different this time around.
- gambiting 9y agoI mean sure, in a lot of cases, yes, a normal iPad is a lot better than this super custom commercial terminal for $10k/each. But if you work in an oil refinery where you can't risk an explosion of millions of gallons of petrol, or if you run a metro system that carries hundreds of thousands of people a day, you can't be using consumer grade electronics.