3 ms·
So would it also be illegal to advertise your job positions in teen Vogue but NOT in AARP magazine? It doesn't seem much different in this case. Bit methods ta
by jjeaff 9y ago
So would it also be illegal to advertise your job positions in teen Vogue but NOT in AARP magazine?
It doesn't seem much different in this case. Bit methods target young people.
- mulmen 9y agoNo of course not. Anyone can buy either magazine. Those two examples are completely different. In the magazine case you are taking out an advertisement with no ability to discriminate. In the Facebook case there is a specific setting based on age to show job ads. Job seekers over the age of 40 are protected so this is discrimination against a protected class. The problem is not that young people were targeted, the problem is that those over 40 were not.
- cutcss 9y agoYou say it like it is that simple to fix; they could ask for photo in the curriculum and just discard the few that looks old, -after targeting job ads on pages that are disproportionaly "liked" by the age range they want- The only true way to solve this is to force by law to hire older people (e.g. 30% of your workforce must be over 40); otherwise all this proxies like trying to regulate third-party ads and else its just an endless cat-and-mouse game.
- mattmanser 9y agoIt is an easy fix. Job ads have no age options allowed. Fixed.
- wils1245 9y agoAnd the next day, those age-based ads will be replaced by other user attributes closely correlated with age. A US Supreme Court case comes to mind, Batson v Kentucky: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batson_v._Kentucky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Batson_v._Kentucky In which it became illegal to dismiss a juror based on race. A simple, sensible fix, which most agree did very little to stop race based discrimination from juries. Doing so just became a bit more complicated.
- cutcss 9y agoNope; you can target pages that are liked only by young people (e.g. Snapchat) and then just discard the few old people manually.