15 ms·
How Cuts in Basic Subway Upkeep Can Make NYC Commutes Miserable
- notyourday 9y agoDude. Not moving a "sick passenger" off the train is the biggest issue of NYC subway commute.
- untog 9y agoIt really isn't. It is an issue, sure, but decrepit signals have far more of an effect every single day.
- notyourday 9y agoNo, this is the issue. A sick passenger on union sq on N Q R in a rush hour means for twenty minutes trains are stopped. A sick passenger on the L, means trains are stopped in both directions. It takes hours for the train service to get back to normal. This happens nearly daily. If we still had Gothamist, we would have still had daily articles about what caused the delay.
- untog 9y agoNo, it is an issue. In any case, a new signal system would allow the subway to recover from a sick passenger much quicker, and allow it to run many more trains per hour than it currently does, which would cover many sins. The decrepit signals are a far bigger issue, and a far more solvable one (how do you solve sick passengers?)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- notyourday 9y ago> and a far more solvable one (how do you solve sick passengers?) You move them off the train ( 2 minutes ) and let the train continue moving. Improving signal system won't fix delays. The article is about what about makes commute terrible. MTAs customer does not give a flying f!ck about why there are the delays. MTA customer wants to have no delays. MTA's solution? Contractless payments! New L cars with folding seats! Subway in NYC runs on electricity. It is not possible to run more trains on most of the lines than already run. MTA got a stupid grant from feds of several hundred million dollars to upgrade one of the L substations. It will add two or maybe three additional trains in the rush hour when trains already come every 3-4 minutes. No improvement in switching infrastructure would fix it. A train stopping for twenty minutes on Bedford St would affect the system for hours because of the idiotic 8th St design. Oh how about someone having an episode in a tunnel, followed by a dumb-ass passenger pulling emergency brake. In a tunnel. Guess what happens? The conductor has to check every car before the train moves forward even though he or she knows where the emergency brake was pulled. So you now have a sick passenger in a tunnel and entire system again stops. Fun, huh? But sure, through the magic of signal system improvement we will totally address dumb design ideas.
- gnopgnip 9y agoThe problem with that is that it means a delay. There is no easy answer for when to delay the train for everyone, or when to keep moving until it is handled with a smaller delay.
- Symbiote 9y agoLondon Underground sometimes has posters up, "If you feel unwell, seek a member of staff on the platform" and "when ill on a train, if possible, wait until the train is in a station, where help is more easily available". Also, most of the emergency communications buttons now connect you to speak with the driver. They presumably have a procedure, depending on the problem, but for someone sick they will call ahead "passenger in front of carriage 3".
- concerned_user 9y agoI suspect they are talking about homeless and/or people under influence of alcohol or other substances, not people with health issues that is why "sick passenger" is in quotes. Police probably given up on throwing them out.
- notyourday 9y agoThey are treated the same. "Sick passenger" = train stops, vacate the car, wait for EMT to diagnose.
- frandroid 9y agoAndy Byford has his work cut out for him.
- free652 9y agoFor MTA: labor expenses are higher than revenue, there is no easy way out.
- Fej 9y agoHow are they paying for everything?
- mc32 9y agoFarebox rev is ~40% the rest of funding comes from a variety of taxes (RE, payroll, etc) and a few state and local subsidies.
- TuringNYC 9y agoSounds like they take the prevailing wage and multiply it by two! https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/18/nyregion/new-york-subway-system-failure-delays.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/18/nyregion/new-york-subway-... "...average total compensation for subway managers has grown to nearly $300,000 a year."
- djsumdog 9y agoIt's important to note that no train system in the world is covered by fairs. They are always subsidized by the state. In most cities, fairs make up 20% ~ 30% of costs (tolls are about the same for toll roads). Cities with expensive transit typically have mandates that x% of costs must be paid by fairs. In Wellington, NZ and Chicago, US, this is 50%, leading to some pretty high fares or low service. Just having transit makes revenue though, in taxes from the increased commerce. Access to transport is also the single largest factor in escaping poverty. It's difficult to measure those numbers in revenue though. But transport always must be subsidized by the State, going back to the roads of Rome.
- gozur88 9y agoPrivate railway operators in Tokyo aren't subsidized by the state, though I think they get a not-insignificant portion of their income from property rents around stations.
- adrianN 9y agoThe technology on the NYC subway is so old that they have to pay through the nose for replacement parts. I also assume that you have a hard time finding people willing to work at a place where they learn few transferable skills, because nobody else uses century old stuff. Especially if the pay is so-so and you don't guarantee a job for life. Yet upgrading the system to modern signals and interlockings is even more expensive, especially since maintenance is extremely hard when the system has to run 24/7.
- exabrial 9y agoSignals are expensive? That kind of blows my mind. A chaveut dj LED light that responds to dmx commands can be had for a few bucks
- gozur88 9y agoIt must be one of those things that's harder than it looks - China had a train crash because they decided to roll their own signals.
- exabrial 9y agoAgree, it's obviously much different than a lighting effect in practice. What I'm trying reconcile is the hardware and software. Are there truly that many differences physically? The cost of signals probably comes from certifications I'm guessing
- Symbiote 9y agoDid you take any computer science courses on software verification? That is, proving your program does what you intend. It's complicated, difficult, and the people who can do this are expensive. Railway signaling systems, alongside air and spacecraft, and sometimes consumer devices that would be expensive to firmware update during the warranty, are the few places software verification is used. The specification we are verifying the software against must also be proven to be correct, including failing safe. The hardware also has to perform, at all reasonable temperatures, humidities, with vibration, poor power, and for an expected life of at least 50 years. The people installing the hardware must be checked, to ensure the work is done correctly. A crossed wire is a critical fault, I imagine there's a long and detailed procedure for connecting every wire. [1] is an interesting read, a retrospective on a bad crash in 1988 in Britain which led to many improvements in signaling safety. https://www.railengineer.uk/2014/01/06/25-years-after-clapham-a-review-of-signalling-procedures/ https://www.railengineer.uk/2014/01/06/25-years-after-clapha...
- djsumdog 9y agoOther major cities around the world are moving to automated light rail. Singapore and Kula Lumpar both have fully automated trains, London has several of their lines automated with plans on slowly replacing rolling stock to eventually go driver-less on more of its above ground lines. American cities are so far behind. D.C. is probably one of the best metros, but NYC and Chicago, while having quite extensive systems for very large cities, have no budget to expand or move them into the future. For cities that large, these systems have to be maintained. They cannot afford to cut train lines, unless they want to end up with grueling traffic like you have in LA.
- hkmurakami 9y agoiirc Yurikamome in the gulf area of Tokyo is automated monorail. It's really nice -- well run, clean, peaceful.
- delackner 9y agoWhile automation sounds elegant, it has nothing to do with the problems or solutions here. The core problem with the NYC subway system is a management culture that does not value long term problem solving, instead preferring quick fixes and short term band aids. Many modern subway systems have similarly huge networks with far higher traffic than NYC but manage to maintain low failure rates and CLEAN tracks simply because they value and prioritize maintenance and quality of service. Some are private, some are public. It truly baffles me why NYC and actually the SF BART both fail so utterly to even attempt to provide quality service.
- concerned_user 9y agoI live in Europe and to me it seems that its a general American mentality of everybody having a car, dislike of mass transit in any form (except planes) and as a result mass transit is meh and makes people even more miserable.
- CaptainZapp 9y agoI live in Europe and to me it seems that its a general American mentality of everybody having a car New York is different. Car ownership is extremely low and the subway is a vital part of the city's transportation infrastructure. The problem seems more attitude wise. We want great infrastrure while paying low taxes. This contradiction, of course, isn't really solvable as can be seen in the generally pretty rotten state of infrastructure in the US.
- Tohan 9y agoVICTORIA FINANCIER HELP MY FAMILY WITH LOAN @ 2% INTEREST RATE with victoriafinancier@outlook.com VICTORIA FINANCIER COMPANY, offers all kind of loan, ranging from $5,000 USD to $100,000,000.00USD Max. if you need a loan amount quickly write to her Email now with ( victoriafinancier@outlook.com) . She helped me when i was so much in need of money. I lost my job. i and my kids were almost evicted from our house. I seeks assistance from all the people that i know but i could not even get drugs for my child. I also develop brain tumor as a result of stress and excess thinking. In my messed life, i look online for assistance there i found Mrs Victoria Financier Loan Lending company. I read how she always help different people from different countries. I urgently contact her, explain my situations to her same day and then i ask for any assistance that can give because i don't want my kids trow out to street; She advised me to get a loan amount with long term of 10years. The funds was sent into my bank account 4 days of contacting her and she also send the transfer confirmation slip to me and my bank gave me the money in full when i went to withdraw. Victoria Financier service is so amazing. I recommend Victoria Financier Lending Company to you, contact her today and be patient with to assist you because lot's of person contact her daily for assistance. She will help you urgently. Her Email is: victoriafinancier@outlook.com Full Name:_________ Address:_________ Tell:_________ loan amount:_________ Loan duration:_________ Country:_________ Purpose of loan:_________ Monthly Income:__________ Occupation__________ Next of kin:_________ *Email :_________
- Endy 9y agoNow they're also talking about stopping the L train for a year or more. And my major issue is, these people who have the time to go out and protest - and the city literally is not allowed to say, "You want this to get fixed? Either convince the rich folks to actually pay their taxes, or be willing to volunteer and do the work we need done down there."
- ancientworldnow 9y agoThe L shutdown has nothing to do with funds - it's mostly covered by federal Sandy money. The issue is the tunnel needs to be essentially gutted and replaced after being submerged in salt water for days post Sandy. There's no reroutes available so the only option is a shutdown. It can either be done all at once in less than 18 months (and MTA actually has a good track record coming in under time for repair work) or done one direction at a time over three years with a fraction of the current brooklyn-manhattan service level. A full shutdown is absolutely the best option as much as it sucks for people dependent on the line (like me and my neighbors).
- jopsen 9y ago> and the city literally is not allowed to say, "You want this to get fixed? Either convince the rich folks to actually pay their taxes, or be willing to volunteer..." That sounds like an excellent campaign poster. The city is a public institution it shouldn't have opinions. But the politicians who govern it are very much encouraged to do so. I suggest you try to run on a political platform of taxes and better services. Then you'll see of Americans want that.
- notyourday 9y agoNo need. The current tax bill exposed the positions of American limo liberals quite well - no one wants their "but i already pay taxes in New York so of course I deduct them from my federal tax liability" to go away.
- 1ba9115454 9y agoI always wondered what would happen if you just remove the trains and the track and just let people cycle through the tunnels.
- Shivetya 9y agoDo not that this is a problem nationwide with rail transit. Both heavy and light rail variants suffer the same issue, deferred upkeep. Throw in the elevated expense in deploying such solutions and the money just vanishes. While NYC has issues specific to it many cities slight their bus travelers to support rail lines to the point of changing bus routes to be less advantageous. LA lost nearly four bus riders for every new rail rider because they cut routes to pay for the train. when it comes to deferred maintenance, if you were to look into the 2015 DOT reports there is nearly a hundred billion dollar backlog on rail maintenance. This is on top of the tens of billions spent building it and building new rail. the estimates to bring just DC's Metro system back up to maintenance date is over twenty billion. Just remember in the US most transit rail lines are for the purpose of politicians to cut ribbons.
- heisenbit 9y agoBut roads are faring so much better? Or water infrastructure (Flint)? Or electricity infrastructure (PR)? Our western society seems to find ways of fund investments but when it comes to maintenance there is a void. Why the US is particularly bad at this and what needs to change across the board is the question. The current course is not sustainable.
- loup-vaillant 9y agoOne thing that shocked me when going to the US, that still shocks me now, are those adds: "Injured? Cellino & Barnes". Apparently, when you're injured in the US, the first thing to do is not go to the hospital, but call your lawyer. I'm not sure what to think of it, but it does make me feel uneasy.
- sonthonax 9y agoAmerica's courts unlike the UK routinely award punitive damages. Suing someone for causing you injury in the UK may only net you the cost of your medical bills (which might be negligible) and the cost of missed work.
- loup-vaillant 9y agoGiven the US health care system, I understand why someone might need punitive damages.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoNeeding punitive damages is a contradiction by definition. If you could show injury then they would be normal damages The point of punitive damages is that they're not necessary to compensate the injured party but to send a message that a certain behavior is not acceptable. For example: "$person was burned by your hot coffee so we're awarding them $smallnumber for medical expenses, lost wages, suffering, etc. and $bignumber in punitive damages because you shouldn't be serving coffee that hot in that manner in the first place"
- loup-vaillant 9y agoI know what "punitive damages" mean. I was just pointing out that in the US, one might lose one's ability to get health insurance at all because of an injury (many conditions will cause most insurance company to refuse your application). The possible prejudice for that can range in the millions. Even if those aren't punitive, they sure feel like it.
- pcr0 9y agoWhy does such a troubled metro still run 24/7? Most of the best-performing metros in the world (HK, SG, Tokyo) close at midnight.
- futurix 9y agoBecause the city itself is 24/7?
- lagadu 9y agoYeah but at night there's significantly less traffic, so it's ok to stop the trains and rely solely on the bus network because it has enough capacity to handle night traffic. Where I live is an example of that: during weekdays the light rail closes IIRC between midnight and 6, they only keep it running on weekends because of all the people going out at night (the metro always runs but that's fully automated). Just because the bus system isn't enough to handle a city's peak load, it's usually fine for handling the load on periods where the load is the smallest.
- betterunix2 9y agoThere are a lot of people who ride at night -- not just party goers, but also people with late night jobs. The MTA does change the service pattern at night and there are often closures/reroutes for maintenance. Also note that the MTA's troubles have nothing to do with running the system 24/7. The subway has run 24/7 for a century, and for most of that century maintenance was not a problem. What happened recently was that the state started cutting the MTA's subsidy, so maintenance started to slip and the system fell apart -- something which happened in the 1980s, but people have no ability to learn from past mistakes.
- futurix 9y agoRing-fenced yearly upkeep budget + years of sustained funding for improvements = great subway system. London Underground in the 1980s was like NYC Subway now - but after sustained 15-20 years of funding it improved immensely (while passenger levels more than doubled, if not tripled). Of course this could not last - with the current Conservative government Underground is getting less and less money, so starting to defer upgrades... Politicians are incapable of learning.
- xvf22 9y agoThe social infrastructure is a bank account paid into by previous governments. They are pilfering it because it's easy and the fallout will probably land on someone else.
- rayiner 9y agoThat doesn’t help. The MTA’s problem is decidedly not money. The MTA’s spending on subway is about double per passenger as Transport for London spends on the underground.[1] Having a ring fenced budget wouldn’t do any good as it gets eaten away by inefficiency and waste. What the MTA needs to do is: 1) Disband the union 2) Cut service overnight to increase maintenance times 3) Double fares (Tube fares are 15-100% higher depending on distance; using exchange rates from a few years ago, minimum Tube fare was like $5 versus $2.75 for the NY subway) [1] http://content.tfl.gov.uk/tfl-mayors-budget-2017-18.pdf http://content.tfl.gov.uk/tfl-mayors-budget-2017-18.pdf (page 10) versus http://web.mta.info/mta/budget/pdf/MTA%202017%20Adopted%20Bu.. http://web.mta.info/mta/budget/pdf/MTA%202017%20Adopted%20Bu.... (page II-A). Just look at the Underground versus the subway + the Staten Island Railroad.
- 1jojojo 9y agoIf MTA's problem is decidedly not money, then why does the MTA need to double its fares?
- jjoonathan 9y agoTo keep the poors out, duh.