There is a huge difference between being a crank and being incorrect. The death of subtly is depressing. This line by Lipton is a response to the questions th

There is a huge difference between being a crank and being incorrect. The death of subtly is depressing. This line by Lipton is a response to the questions that were raised when the preprint was removed Deolalikar’s personal HP page on Monday. Many were wondering if it was a retraction, and this is denying that. But as so far as I have seen in Toa's wiki or Lipton's forums, there has not yet been a specific object to any lemma or claim in the paper. The author has no more reason to believe there is a flaw in his argument than he did on August 6.