8 ms·
The Transformation of Sexual-Harassment Law Will Be Double-Faced
- rectang 9y agoI hope that as time goes on we are increasingly able to see ourselves as all in this together, rather than in a zero-sum game between genders.
- bootcampjs 9y agoIt’s stuff like this that makes me so incredibly happy to be gay.
- existencebox 9y agoWhile I share your aspiration, let me make an inflammatory question for the purpose of prompting thought. (I would hope readers take this as a neutral statement; since obviously the women entering the workforce see it as a net positive, but it may be a line of questioning to attempt to explain why it's so easy to see it as a gender battle) What if it is zero sum, or at least, approaching that? There are two phenomena going on that make me contemplate this; double income household normalization, and a somewhat sticky total # of jobs. As women further enter the workforce, the mean household income will trend towards double income, and the labor pool will be contested with more applicants, in both cases rendering a male applicant at a substantial disadvantage (comparatively to history). The way one could rebut this would be to suggest that this inflation hasn't taken place, and that the total # of jobs has scaled accordingly. A brief search hasn't turned up anything on my end, so don't take this musing as any more than posing questions. My pessimism lends me to think that the conflict I summarized above will be a rallying call for certain groups on both sides of the fold for many years to come; recent political discourse does not lend me hope for a broad view of "togetherness".
- bmay 9y agomore qualified women in the workforce => greater efficiency, increase in net jobs created, lower prices => increased benefits for everyone
- groby_b 9y agoI'm not sure where you're seeing a "somewhat sticky # of jobs": https://www.statista.com/statistics/192356/number-of-full-time-employees-in-the-usa-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/192356/number-of-full-ti... , https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/employed-persons https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/employed-persons As for "a brief search": I literally went to Google, typed "number of jobs" with the first suggestion being "number of jobs in us by year". The very first link has the answer. May I suggest that when you ask inflammatory question, you invest a tiny bit more in research? Otherwise, one could come to the conclusion that maybe you're more interested in the inflammatory than in the thought part. I'm sure that's not what you intend. But if you care about "togetherness" in political discourse, it's imperative to temper inflammatory requests with more than an absolutely cursory search for facts.
- existencebox 9y agoI was unclear with my "sticky jobs" statement; and referred primarily to the initial rate of change of women entering the workforce. I did try to look at the data for that, but while there is a spike of labor participation rate (per capita/% seems a much better metric than absolute #) during the male/female convergence in the 50's/60s as womens rights progressed, it seemed primarily externality driven. [0] That being said, I'd try and better make my main point: As a sister post states, there's the intuitive fact that remedying discrimination is by definition going to cause the previously elevated party to lose that. This is the core of what I was trying to get at; that I'm not sure "it's not a zero sum game" is going to convince people who focus on this aspect of it. Maybe there's an argument that you don't need to/can't convince someone that opposed, but that's the heart of my pessimism about the aformentioned togetherness. (Another sister post made the explanation of the lump of labor fallacy, which I had learned at one point and unfortunately forgotten as it far better responds to the hypothetical I posed) [0]https://dqydj.com/the-male-female-unemployment-gap/ https://dqydj.com/the-male-female-unemployment-gap/ (Ignoring the writing, the data is from stlousifed)
- groby_b 9y agoAh, that makes much more sense, thank you. > there's the intuitive fact that remedying discrimination is by definition going to cause the previously elevated party to lose that I think it's more than an intuitive fact. There's at least one study I can think of - "Gender Quotas and the Crisis of the Mediocre Man"[1]. And it seems to support the idea that there's a loss, at least in the short term, for the previously elevated party. I still don't think it's a zero-sum game in the long term. But that is at the core of the problem - people feel threatened now, they don't always care that in the long run, things might turn out well. Which prompted me to write my reply in the first place - anything that reinforces the notion of a zero-sum game is incredibly toxic to resolving this issue. And even if we'd all be at our most level-headed selves, it's a rather hard issue to solve. (It's worth noting that we're off on quite a tangent. None of the above really relates to sexual harassment that much. That is an abuse of power. While I'm an avowed feminist, I'm not convinced that simply having more equality in the work force will solve the issue of harassment. That likely requires a huge cultural shift to our basic mode of thinking) [1] http://perseus.iies.su.se/~tpers/papers/Draft170122AER.pdf http://perseus.iies.su.se/~tpers/papers/Draft170122AER.pdf
- mannykannot 9y ago> ...in both cases rendering a male applicant at a substantial disadvantage (comparatively to history). The reduction of inequalities tends to have this sort of effect on those who benefitted from inequality, more or less by definition. I will go along with your stated intention of wanting to provoke thought by saying that I think it is a bogus argument against equality, that ignores the unjustifiable harm done by discrimination. Furthermore, by itself, it does not establish the 'zero sum' part of 'zero sum game'. BTW, grammatically speaking, the 'it' in the question you pose appears to refer to the 'sexual harassment' of the title, but your comment seems to be about something else altogether.
- avz 9y ago> [...] sticky total # of jobs. As women further enter the workforce, the mean household income will trend towards double income, and the labor pool will be contested with more applicants, in both cases rendering a male applicant at a substantial disadvantage (comparatively to history). Isn't this the lump of labor fallacy [1]? I think the economic theory leads to a different description: As more women enter the workforce, the aggregate income goes up. Some of it is spent and becomes someone else's income. Some of it is saved in a bank which loans it out or invests it. The receiving business then spends it and once again the money becomes someone else's income. IOW, as more people work, both aggregate demand and aggregate income rise. The economy shifts into a higher gear. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy
- Spooky23 9y agoIt seems a little sketchy to me that apparently labor is exempt from the basic laws of supply and demand. Fundamentally, enlarging the supply of workers, through the entry of women, ending systemic discrimination against minorities, elimination of early retirement while reducing demand should have an effect on the price of labor. I’ve worked for large institutions that have been performing the same work for decades and I’m familiar with their employment statistics. By any measure, they are using fewer person-hours of labor annually. About 40% less since 1997, about 60% less than 1987. One subdivision in particular replaced about 3,000 workers with 50 IT guys and about $10M in annual IT spend circa 1995. Those labor costs are held in check by a constant stream of cheap contractors.
- mannykannot 9y agoThe basic laws of supply and demand have two sides, but you are just looking at supply. The post you are replying to contains a suggestion as to why the demand side may, at least in some circumstances, mask or compensate for supply-side effects. Large institutions that have been performing the same work for decades do not fully represent the economy as a whole.
- Spooky23 9y ago
- pessimizer 9y agoI think it's better to realize that we're not all in this together, and instead to sacrifice unearned personal power in order to help the less powerful simply because we think it's just, not because we think that it'll ultimately benefit us in an indirect way. There's no way to allow power to women without giving up power over women, so control of women's agency and options has to be zero-sum.
- sheepmullet 9y ago> I think it's better to realize that we're not all in this together That doesn't make any sense at all. Men and women are, in western society, naturally aligned and both genders as a whole want what is best for everyone.
- forgottenpass 9y ago>I think it's better to realize that we're not all in this together Without an idea of "we're all in this together" from what would I derive motivation towards the just? Or even a definition of justice? (Just in case we're having some miscommunication around different readings of the phrase, where one describes an "is" and different "ought": I see the phrase "all in this together" to refer to our shared inescapable subjection to the consequences of society. Although I can envision a reading that takes it as some assertion we're all equivalently culpable for steering. Unless you really want to get into the semantics, I'll stop typing and leave it at the point I see the former definition used in the parent post.)
- readams 9y agoAs a society we need to have a much more sober response to this sort of allegation. Immediate career-ending consequences based on a mere accusation are ultimately bad for both accuser and accused, because it raises the cost of making an accusation.
- rectang 9y agoWe've reached this place in part because formal avenues of responding to harassment are so terrible. A lot of harassment cases involve sexual assault or other crimes, but the police and the courts are often so indifferent or hostile that they cannot even come close to fulfilling the role they should. Improving how the criminal justice system handles such crimes would be a big help, but it's a monumental task.
- sheepmullet 9y ago> A lot of harassment cases involve sexual assault or other crimes, but the police and the courts are often so indifferent Are they? Or are most sexual assault cases incredibly messy and unclear?
- late2part 9y agoMy impression from reading these comments is that we should bifurcate sexual assault from sexual harassment. Both are bad, one is worse. It may be that the former is civil while the latter is criminal.
- Avshalom 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15953907 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15953907
- sheepmullet 9y agoA bankrupt and highly corrupt county does not represent the country as a whole. I do mean it as an honest question - is there evidence of widespread police indifference to rape? I'd like to know how often getting a rape kit done leads to a criminal conviction. Does it double the likelihood?
- jeffdavis 9y agoPutting employers and schools at the center seems like the wrong approach. If there is a victim and a perpetrator, why can't it be handled in court between them? Asking the employer/school to handle it is a recipe for injustice. Their interest is to limit their liability and favor their most useful employees, in that order. Justice is a distant concern.
- AnimalMuppet 9y ago> ... why can't it be handled in court between them? If you're falsely accused, do you want to have to spend $10,000 to defend yourself? If you're harassed, do you want to have to spend $10,000 to accuse the perpetrator? That's why it should be handled in court only as the last resort.
- chroem- 9y agoIt's much harder to make false accusations in a court of law.
- tptacek 9y agoIt's much harder to make any accusations in a court of law.
- ams6110 9y agoRight, because as an individual you can't make an accusation in criminal court. That is done by a prosecutor, who will have to be reasonably confident that he has sufficient evidence to get a conviction.
- tptacek 9y agoYou've confused "court of law" with "criminal court". Most sexual harassment claims are civil, not criminal.
- prepend 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ScottBurson 9y agoHere's a thought: maybe it should become standard practice for companies to issue a hidden body camera to any employee who requests one. I'm sure there would be lots of issues around this that I haven't thought through yet, but it would certainly solve the evidence problem. Indeed, I would expect the mere existence of the policy to put a major damper on misbehavior.
- AlexandrB 9y agoI really hate that the answer offered to many modern social problem seems to be "more surveillance". I'm not saying it wouldn't help or that we shouldn't do it but like police body cams this is only as effective as the people charged with following through on the consequences. If a company retains control of the camera and wants to bury the evidence they'll still do it.
- ScottBurson 9y agoYes, I think the recordings should be under the control of the employee who requested the camera. It should be their choice what parts, if any, to show the company — and they should have the ability to show them to a lawyer if they choose. Your concern is very reasonable, but that's why I didn't suggest just blanketing the office with surveillance cameras.
- eduren 9y agoI like that better than making it company only, but that way gives avenues of abuse to the employee rather than the company. The ideal situation is that both parties get immediate copies of the recordings. That way neither gets the ability to cherry pick of censor.
- Spooky23 9y agoYou can already do that. In the age of smartphones, it’s trivial to record audio for a whole day. It’s not necessary either. The downside of capturing everything is that you capture everything. The employee ends up getting canned for claiming a 30 minute lunch when she was gone for 40. A good, factual journal is the best weapon in most cases.
- drtillberg 9y agoThe article's link to the Chinese cultural revolution is a hidden gem.[1][2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Struggle_session https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Struggle_session [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2013/10/03/you-have-to-be-careful-about-using-the-word-struggle-in-china https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2013/10/03...
- explainplease 9y agoThanks for pointing that out. The stories in the Wikipedia article are sobering. I hope we are not seeing a modern equivalent of struggle sessions in our media now, but...
- nerdponx 9y agowhat strikes a reasonable person as “severe or pervasive” has been evolving This is an important point, and I think it represents a tremendous victory.
- jancsika 9y ago> Among the imperatives of #MeToo is that employers, and, indeed, all institutions, must take care to implement orderly processes in which reports of harassment are fairly and impartially investigated, and yield results that inspire confidence—to the benefit of victims as well as the accused. That's the author's imperative. #metoo has three imperatives: 1. A smoke signal to communicate across long distances and allege abuse against powerful serial abusers more quickly than those alleged serial abusers can use their power to divide and conquer the allegations. 2. It is a shared statement by victims of sexual abuse (including male victims) that investigations of people who hold power inside institutions have been anything but fair and impartial. 3. It is a day of reckoning for the people who have enabled the serial abusers, in a desperate attempt to create a minimally workable environment where people can try to have careers without having their genitals grabbed, their spirit broken, and their faith in institutions shaken. The imperative the author erroneously attributes to #metoo is certainly important, and related. But it's different, and it seems like #metoo is merely shoe-horned to make the article more relevant. (Does anyone think the definition of sexual harassment wasn't already being broadened before #metoo?) It's unfortunate, too, because I'd love to know how both Title IX and Title VII are impacted by students' growing ability and proclivity to accumulate allegations over social media against serial abusers. What does a college's "honor court" or whatever do when it's not victim vs. accused but instead multiple victims across different classes and campus locations vs. one accused?
- AstralStorm 9y agoThe problem with those initiatives it's lack of validation. It sometimes happens that other people follow the crowd on accusations. These effects should be tested and measured before implementing what is essentially public shaming.
- AlexCoventry 9y ago> For more than three decades, we have understood sexual harassment to be a form of sex discrimination A minor derail: In fact checking this, I learned that because sexual harassment is federally treated as a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which forbids discrimination on the basis of sex, it is a defense if you bisexually harass people. https://www.natlawreview.com/article/trouble-so-called-equal-opportunity-harasser-another-cautionary-case-out-minnesota https://www.natlawreview.com/article/trouble-so-called-equal... It's good that the legal system has found a way to shoehorn a fairly effective discouragement of a vile and destructive societal tendency out of a law which was not intended for the purpose. (I also learned that the CRA amendment prohibiting discrimination against sex was added at the last moment, as a poison pill, in the hope that doing so would make the bill untenable.) I think the country would probably benefit from dedicated sexual harassment laws, though. The current situation is pretty ethically incoherent.