2 ms·
It sounds like you may be overgeneralizing your experiences in a particular city. At least here in London, the people you see on trains are a broad crossection
by foldr 9y ago
It sounds like you may be overgeneralizing your experiences in a particular city. At least here in London, the people you see on trains are a broad crossection of the general public, and are no smellier or less attractive (not sure why this matters?) than anyone you're likely to run into on the street.
So, no, it is not the case that "no-one" likes public transport. I like it fine, and experience none of the issues with it that you seem to. I would generally prefer to get the tube as compared to e.g. an Uber, even if there were no price difference.
- lazerpants 9y ago>I would generally prefer to get the tube as compared to e.g. an Uber, even if there were no price difference. The rest of the discussion aside, I agree with you regarding my experiences on the NYC subway. However, that is because I organized my entire living situation around the locations of subway stations and lines near my office. If that constraint didn't exist (there were a reasonable alternative to the subway), I may well choose to live elsewhere, and therefore, prefer to use Ubers or other methods of transportation. For many of us who use public transportation, we have built our lives around a constraint that may no longer be present in the future and may allow for people to live in currently less desirable parts of cities.
- foldr 9y agoPeople have been building their lives around available transport since the stone age. Nothing Musk is proposing is set to change that.
- ghaff 9y agoI'm sure there are, on average, demographic differences between who takes the subway, who takes a taxi/Uber, and who has a reserved black car. That said, I don't disagree with you in general. In cities with good public transit systems where transit is a genuinely easier way to get around much of the time, many people take the subway even if they could afford something else. I know that's true for me in Boston, New York, and London to name 3 cities. I do take BART in SF but pretty much only to get in from the airport.
- foldr 9y agoIf some options are more expensive than others then there are bound to be demographic differences, even if the more expensive options aren't better. But so what? What's so terrible about traveling with people outside your demographic?
- ghaff 9y agoAbsolutely nothing. Not sure what I said to imply that.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoHere in DC, there actually is a demographic difference between people who take the subway and the overall population: the subway riders have a median household income of about 50% more than the overall population of the metro area.