5 ms·
If you’re imagining getting work done, I don’t think you understand what transit crowding is like. In cities with busy transit systems, getting a seat is out of
by closeparen 9y ago
If you’re imagining getting work done, I don’t think you understand what transit crowding is like. In cities with busy transit systems, getting a seat is out of the question - the variable is how tightly you’ll be squished against your fellow standees, and whether it will even be possible to squeeze onto the train.
The problem is absolutely being too close to strangers. Still, going to individual cabins is an over-reaction, what we need is longer and more frequent trains so that people can at least have seats and/or room to breathe.
- kevmo314 9y ago> what we need is longer and more frequent trains so that people can at least have seats and/or room to breathe. I think autonomously networked trains would be a huge leap towards accomplishing this. The headway between trains could be cut down dramatically and could allow for some magical improvements, eg express trains passing using the opposing direction's rail, that aren't feasible with human drivers.
- lev99 9y agoDC has autonomous trains (in metro) until an accident happened and they switched to human conductors. Autonomous networked trains aren't new technology.
- munk-a 9y agoVancouver has them and (while the SkyTrain has had loads of issues) the autonomous part isn't one of them, this may be due to the fact that the rails are not at ground level which prevents stupid humans from doing stupid stuff along with a higher emphasis on avoiding collisions over getting places (when it snows sometimes sensors will get tripped and prevent the system from allowing any trains to run over a section because the system believes that section is occupied)
- lurr 9y agoLiving in Seattle I miss the skytrain.
- peatmoss 9y agoBut you have the monorail from Seattle Center to Westlake :-) Skytrain is a big bet transit system. Enormously expensive from a capital perspective, but offers a qualitatively great experience, and with pretty fixed operating costs. Busses done well can offer great performance characteristics at lower costs (with the added benefits of resiliency though rerouting and service refinement). But there seems to be something psychological about a choo-choo that gets people fired up for transit in a way that busses typically don’t. I think it’s because we have North American examples like Seattle’s Rapid Ride line that in the end didn’t deliver a train-like experience that we were sold on. We watered the BRT concept down so far as to make it meaningless. Meanwhile, Link light rail is being delivered at high cost, but they aren’t cutting corners. Thus Link feels so much better than Rapid Ride.
- closeparen 9y agoIf you have been on both buses and trains it should be obvious. Trains: smooth ride where the tracks are good, smooth power delivery/acceleration, satisfying whooshing sound, forward facing seats, spacious aisle, feels solid and efficient. Makes one acceleration and deceleration per stop, which are at least a few blocks apart. A BMW sailing down a wide-open left lane. Buses: rattles 10x worse than the cheapest car you’ve ever been in. Violent, jerking, loud, desperate-sounding acceleration and braking action. Cramped aisle, mostly inward facing seats, hostile, harsh, and dirty fluorescent interior. Everything about it gets right up to your face and screams in your ear at the top of its lungs, “CHEAP!” A rolling welfare office waiting room. Stops every block, even with a dedicated lane. Usually averages walking speed, or worse when you factor in the wait. (No, these are not symptoms of being old - I have been on some perfectly pleasant 80s New Flyers. I am talking about San Francisco’s newest fleet here). Somehow it still baffles transit planners that people might care about the subjective experience of being in transit rather than the throughput or cost. How the auto industry hasn’t made that blidndingly obvious is beyond me.
- Fricken 9y agoNobody uses transit anymore, it's too crowded.
- closeparen 9y agoWhen your choices are “put up with transit” or “live somewhere else,” plenty of people choose transit, grudgingly, for a while. But we can and should do better.
- Fricken 9y agoI was recently in Vancouver for a month and used transit daily. It's a well oiled machine and not unpleasant to use. This is in stark contrast to my home city, a more typically north American city: sprawling, car-centric and any transport mode that isn't a motor vehicle is compromised, and transit system exists to punish people for being poor. Even using a car is compromised because of all the other cars, there's a geometry problem there. Nobody is actually saving time, they're just spending lots of money, running people over and generally making a mess. But you do have a nice, protective shell to segregate you from strangers. My primary experience living in different cities is 'put up with cars or live somewhere else', and I don't even know where this mythical land unsullied by the tyranny of the automobile might be, but I fantasize about it regularly.
- alicorn 9y agoThe Netherlands, Danmark and, to a lesser extent, Sweden are seriously rethinking the automobile tyranny. I live in Sweden, and have no real need to own a car, since public transportation and a bicycle solve pretty much all my transportation needs.
- ahartmetz 9y agoThis sounds like another instance of Silicon Valley trying to fix something that doesn't need fixing, certainly not the way Silicon Valley considers "fixed". Public transit does not need to be awful. In many places it's great!
- 9y ago