8 ms·
I vividly remember being in an airport when this announcement hit the news, waiting to catch a plane to go home for the holidays. And thinking "huh, bad move, t
by smacktoward 9y ago
I vividly remember being in an airport when this announcement hit the news, waiting to catch a plane to go home for the holidays. And thinking "huh, bad move, they should have bought Be instead."
What can I say, nobody's perfect :-D
- mikeash 9y agoI’d love to get a peek at the alternate universe where they bought Be instead and see how it worked out. Obviously NeXT worked out really well for them and Be would have a tough time matching that success, but who can say for sure?
- grzm 9y agoIt would have been interesting. One of the driving factors for me with Apple's acquisition of NeXT has been the underlying Unix support. I've been using Mac OS since System 5, primarily in desktop publishing. Having that Unix subsystem opened up a whole new range of opportunities for the Mac in ways that I think would have been hard for BeOS to compete with. I agree a peek would be interesting, particularly the multi-tasking, but I think more for curiosity's sake than anything else.
- itomato 9y agoJean-Louis Gassée is on the record saying Apple made the right choice. Gil Amelio thought the 20th Anniversary Macintosh was really awesome and clones were a good idea. With (seriously cash strapped) Apple doubling down on Multimedia on rebranded BeOS as a licensed OS for Clones, they would have gone head-to-head with the entirety of the PC market that already had a taste of BeOS. BeOS was quick and fun, but barely had a TCP/IP stack. See BONE. Apple probably would have switched to Intel earlier.
- qubex 9y agoMy BeBox running BeOS5 has been happily participating in TCP/IP (v4) communications on my home Ethernet network for twenty years. (Admittedly it’s off most of the time these days because I’m concerned about the health of the hard-drive, but still.) It even ran a web-server for a decade with uptimes measured in years. (I had an amateur radiotelescope wired up to the GeekPort and exposed the controls over HTTP. I’ve long since retired that setup in favour of a modern SDR linked to a Raspberry Pi 3.)
- protomyth 9y agoI get the feeling Jean-Louis Gassée would have probably pushed out the existing management the same way Steve Jobs did, but I just don't think he would have been successful at reviving the company. I had both BeOS and NeXTSTEP and pretty much left BeOS to sit while NeXTSTEP was my daily driver (along with a Windows NT machine because IBM was problematic with OS/2).
- yuhong 9y agoI am more interested in the post-NeXT acquisition Apple with Gil Amelio and later Ellen Hancock as CEO. Thinking about it, the path without Steve Jobs of "CHRP" and maybe eventually open-sourcing OS X completely would probably work better in a world where PC manufacturing was not outsourced to China.
- gwbas1c 9y agoWhy they chose Next over Be is an interesting lesson itself. I still can't remember the technical merits of the Be operating system. Someone tried to get me to use it back in 1999, but there were no applications worth using.
- jhugg 9y agoBe was designed to be lightweight and parallel. It was optimized for many threads and the API pushed you to embrace threading. It also had pretty decent scheduling for media stuff. Not quite real-time OS, but closer. It was screaming fast and responsive. The catch is that it was much less mature. It was single user and had very little real security. It had basic Posix support, but NeXT has much more rich BSD-ishness.
- gwbas1c 9y agoAbout 9-10 months later I installed Windows 2000 and I got all that... And a rich ecosystem of applications!
- jghn 9y agoBy 1999 it was too late. They'd already transitioned to x86 and that was their death knell. At the time most hardware would provide drivers only for Windows which meant that other OSs needed to create their own. This sorta-kinda worked for things like Linux where the masses would crowdsource them, but for a commercial OS like BeOS they had to spend a ton of time working on this instead of the actual OS. My recollection at the time was as soon as they entered into this phase the forward progress on BeOS itself ground to a halt, and within a few years the mainstream OSs had started to at least pay lip service to its key features. Any momentum they had was completely lost.
- walrus01 9y agoBy late 1999 it was also too late because Microsoft had taken NT4.0 Workstation, put a much better GUI on it and made it even more stable and reliable, and released it as Windows 2000. It was pretty regular to see Windows 2000 workstation machines with uptimes of 25+ days, which was unheard of in the consumer Win95/Win98/Win98SE era. You could actually kill a misbehaving application and not risk crashing the whole OS.