3 ms·
This says I will save a few thousand dollars. I am a single young person with no dependents and no debt and I make a six figure income that likely puts me in t
by slg 9y ago
This says I will save a few thousand dollars. I am a single young person with no dependents and no debt and I make a six figure income that likely puts me in the top 10% of earners in this county. If anyone deserves a tax cut, it isn't me.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- coolso 9y agoCool so will you be writing a check for the difference to the IRS as a “donation”? You can actually do that you know.
- burkaman 9y agoI don't think you can donate to the IRS. You can do similar things, but none are quite the same as paying taxes. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2011/04/uncle_sam_wants_you_or_at_least_your_spare_change.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20... Also, the problem is that the government now has to plan its budget based on the new tax plan. Even if I donate a few thousand extra, that won't stop a lot of important programs from getting cut, and it won't stop general inequality from increasing.
- ncallaway 9y agoYou're correct that you don't donate to the IRS, specifically. You can write a check to the "United States Treasury", however. They will gladly cash your check.
- ncallaway 9y agoI have written checks to the United States Treasury in the past to better cover what I think my tax obligations _should_ be. I have absolutely no faith in the current governance of the federal government, so I'll probably put my savings into a high yield savings account or a low-risk investment vehicle. When I again agree with the direction of the federal government, I'll pay this insane tax break back United States Treasury.
- slg 9y agoNo, not the IRS. A few thousand dollars has zero marginal impact on the US government. I would rather donate my money to an organization that can better use a donation on the scale that I can afford to give.
- coolso 9y agoAnd yet, it makes much more than a zero marginal impact for most Americans, including you. So why don’t you deserve it, if even only just to use to donate it to charity?
- slg 9y agoBecause certain projects are only possible when we pool our money together in an organized fashion. That is the whole point of collecting taxes.
- coolso 9y agoIsn't that what charity is? You could donate 100% of your tax savings to one or more charities next year. If there's a specific government project you want to support, aren't there ways of donating money directly government organizations instead of just the IRS or the Treasury Department? The government doesn't have to do everything; it's better when citizens take a more direct approach in my opinion.
- slg 9y agoThere are certain things charities don't or can't do. I can't donate to a charity and have them repair a local bridge for example. And my donation wouldn't move the needle on nearly any government project. There are hundreds of thousands if not millions of people in my situation. You can take a penny from each of them and it would beat my donation. That is the whole point of taxes, to pool our money together for the greater good. You can't run a country on just the charitable generosity of its people. Things like infrastructure would never get built in that world.
- bertjk 9y agoIt seems weird to use the word "deserves" here, as if tax cuts were doled out depending on who has been naughty and who has been nice. I would prefer tax policy thought up more in terms of budget needs and setting the right economic incentives, but I guess us all being humans makes this unavoidable.
- slg 9y agoI agree. I gave the word "deserves" a second thought when I initially wrote the comment. The proper word is somewhere between "needs" and "deserves", but I don't know what it is. I think most people reading this on HN, probably don't "need" a tax cut but I am betting a decent percentage feel they "deserve" a tax cut if the government has already decided that a tax cut is going to be given out.
- derekp7 9y agoHow about "usefully benefits"? where "usefully" is defined as improved quality of life, and/or most able to apply that to improving the economy.