4 ms·
>> is a product of their being in suburban America. Close, but imho is has more to do with liability, a fear common at all american companies. Car drivers are
by sandworm101 9y ago
>> is a product of their being in suburban America.
Close, but imho is has more to do with liability, a fear common at all american companies. Car drivers are licensed. They can be expected to obey traffic laws. So when google sends them down the wrong way on a one-way road, nobody blames google. They blame the adult who listened to their phone rather than the signs. But bicyclists are not licensed. If google says that a road is open to cyclists when it isn't, and something bad happens, few will blame the 12yo unlicensed cyclist just following their phone's directions. This is why google, imho, seems to be limiting bicycle routes to those areas with the most clearly defined paths, preferably separate from roads.
And the one-way thing for bike routes is likely based on the widespread understanding that bicycles on roads must obey all the rules that cars do. Going the wrong way on a one-way road is illegal in many areas no matter what vehicle you use. This may never be enforced, but google's legal team probably isn't willing to depart from the letter of the law.
- maxerickson 9y agoOn my phone, Google's bike routing happily sends me down a 35 MPH, 4 lane highway, crossing under a rail bridge where there is no shoulder. It also presents an alternate route, but the traffic environment here isn't such that the route under the viaduct makes any sense. (this is in small town usa)
- panglott 9y agoI cycle in a mid-cized American city that has had a "Bicycle Friendly America" Silver ranking for several years now, and the Google Maps bicycle directions have been extremely iffy since they were introduced. I just checked how Google Maps routes my normal cycle route home, and it's very close to good, but in fact is quite bad. It routes me onto a dangerous arterial road rather than the pleasant multiuse park path that is directly adjacent to the arterial road (and which is my normal cycling route). The Google Maps recommendation here is quite bad and possibly dangerous. The alternate route goes on another heavily-trafficked road rather than the quiet surburban street a block away that is a designated cycle route marked with bicycle signs and sharrows (which was my previous cycling route).
- tintor 9y ago"And the one-way thing for bike routes is likely based on the widespread understanding ..." There are many examples of one-way roads with two-way bike lanes, ie San Francisco: https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Francisco+City+Hall/@37.7780535,-122.4182049,83m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x808580997aeae663:0xb2706dff83574f4a!8m2!3d37.7792597!4d-122.4192646 https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Francisco+City+Hall/@3...
- sandworm101 9y agoAnd the presence of those only adds to my point. Where bike lanes are not specifically states as being 2-way, the default for someone like google is to treat them according to the rules of the road they run alongside.
- Scarblac 9y agoThe point is that in the Netherlands there is a huge number of streets that are specifically signed as "one way, except for bicycles", it's a core feature of our urban infrastructure. Google treats them all as one way for everybody, in a country where over a quarter of all journeys is made by bicycle.