5 ms·
Come on, as if ABP innovated so much? ABP wasn't the first. I remember using an adblocker native in Firefox back around 2004 (and IIRC I even used on on Mozilla
by Fnoord 9y ago
Come on, as if ABP innovated so much? ABP wasn't the first. I remember using an adblocker native in Firefox back around 2004 (and IIRC I even used on on Mozilla milestones). Back then, there were already /etc/hosts based alternatives (which also have always worked in Windows btw) as well, and a so-called personal firewall could also block ads. These existed for Windows 9x. We're talking end of '90s here.
As for the current direct comparison: uBlock yields better performance and doesn't have a shady track record [1]. Other than "I've always used this" or "I benefit if other people use this" (ie. am affiliated which you're not) I just do not see your point. So could you explain us why you pick ABP over uBlock?
[1] https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-vs.-ABP:-efficiency-compared https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-vs.-ABP:-effic...
- def_true_false 9y ago> doesn't have a shady track record Care to expand on that?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Macha 9y agoThe eventual setup of their acceptable ads policy ended up being seen as pay-to-whitelist by users and advertisers. It felt that way to advertisers especially when the fee was 30% of ad revenue rather than say, a processing fee for time spent verifying it met the criteria. A lot of them were more ok to ignore ad blocking before they were held to ransom. Users were unhappy at an adblocker's default config allowing ads.
- def_true_false 9y agoI can see why people would be upset, but it doesn't seem especially shady to me - they were upfront about what they are doing and why. I do remember that multiple forks appeared immediately, but I don't see how trusting someone else in addition to the ABP developers is an improvement... until UBO there was nothing to switch to, and UBO had other advantages.
- epicide 9y agoSo as long as I tell you I'm screwing you over, it's okay?
- DarronWyke 9y agoAnd it can be turned off. It's not a big deal at all. People are making mountains out of molehills.
- Fnoord 9y agoAh, so opt-out is suddenly totally OK. A feature being able to be turned off is a plus, but default features not in the interest of the user are a minus. Especially not when users don't have an easy way to opt-out. If users reasonably want to only opt-in such a feature, you as developer should implement it as such.
- UncleEntity 9y ago> Especially not when users don't have an easy way to opt-out. When I first heard about it took me like 35 seconds to opt-out -- open options and unclick the little clicky box, easy peasy.
- Fnoord 9y agoGood for you. If I need to be happy every time I opt-out "when I hear about it" which is often "when I already used the software" and get USDs for every hour I didn't opt-out even though I'd have loved to opt-out right away, then I'd be one hell of a happy Richie Rich. Having to go through settings in software when you install it, to get the software to work the way the average user wants it to, is annoying. An example could be removing a bitcoin miner from the software, or disabling ads in uTorrent, or disabling telemetry in Windows 10. Firefox as well, but at least they tell you about it right away, and they started doing it later. Not good, but less bad. Why do software developers get away treating their customers like stupid sheep either wasting their time or getting their data? Ah well, at least in Europe we're getting GDPR.
- UncleEntity 9y ago> Good for you. If I need to be happy every time I opt-out "when I hear about it" which is often "when I already used the software" and get USDs for every hour I didn't opt-out even though I'd have loved to opt-out right away, then I'd be one hell of a happy Richie Rich. It's not like they owe me anything, I downloaded their software for free and use it for free with absolutely no expectation other than "I'll use it as long as it works for me." If it gets annoying I'll replace it with something that isn't just in this particular case it was a lot easier to click a box than search out a new adblocker. > Why do software developers get away treating their customers like stupid sheep either wasting their time or getting their data? Because they want to use Windows 10 or uTorrent or something with a bitcoin miner instead of searching out alternatives. Personally, other than ABP, I can think of no other cases of this happening on my stock (other than the chrome repo) Fedora box.
- munchbunny 9y agoA couple years ago, on top of their acceptable ads program that was more or less pay-to-bypass, Eeyo announced that it was going to start an ad exchange to let people buy placements on spots that ABP blocked. In effect ABP was forcing itself in as a middle man and taking a fee from both the site owner and the advertiser. As an example, if I, your local newspaper, sell a placement to your local car dealership, ABP comes in and says "people won't see the car ads, but if you split the revenue you were going to get with me, I'll sell those placements to someone else for you." So let's say 10% of my visitors use ABP. I can now either lose it or get back some smaller percentage of it by paying ABP. That's one DDoS short of a digital protection racket. In addition, when Eeyo made that announcement, they also announced that they were working with AppNexus and Google on the new exchange, which just wasn't true. Though I believe Google does pay to get some ads into the acceptable ads program. If you're going to be in the business of blocking ads, stay out of the business of selling ads.
- mindslight 9y ago> That's one DDoS short of a digital protection racket. Your specific condemnation rests on this tired narrative that "ad spots" are something belonging to the site owner. In the reality of the web, it's all the user's display area - the user agent decides what and how to render. The real critique is that the software is working against the user's interest for its own gain. This is par for the course of proprietary software, but generally seen as unsustainable poor taste in the Free world. Fortunately, having achieved the activation energy of installing extensions for one's self, switching is not hard.
- munchbunny 9y ago> In the reality of the web I'm willing to concede that I assume a specific view of the nature of ad spots, but you're going to have to reeeeeeaaaaally stretch your argument to claim that this is the reality of the web. For the vast majority of people the browser is the renderer that happens to be customizable, not the arbiter of what is rendered, regardless of the browser's capability to decide. Regardless, you don't have to accept the online advertising business model, even at a moral level, to acknowledge the shadiness of the other aspects of the practice that I pointed out.
- cuckcuckspruce 9y agoI remember using the Internet Junkbuster[1] and Privoxy[2] to block ads in the browser long before ABP. The novelty was embedding the functionality directly in the browser through the extensions. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/19980210082938/http://internet.junkbuster.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/19980210082938/http://internet.j... [2] http://www.privoxy.org/ http://www.privoxy.org/
- shpx 9y agoNetscape had an ad blocking plugin called Internet Fast Forward in the mid 90s. https://youtu.be/pvzR_bON9qM?t=3m46s https://youtu.be/pvzR_bON9qM?t=3m46s
- m12k 9y ago> ABP wasn't the first Sure, and the iPhone wasn't the first smartphone either, but it did bring the concept to mainstream attention. Same goes for ABP
- brianwawok 9y agoNo I think the Palm Pilot did that.
- saagarjha 9y agoMaybe into your attention, but the majority of people probably have no idea what a Palm Pilot even is…
- brianwawok 9y agoSure they did. They were on TV for years. It was a sign of being important to carry some form of palm / blackberry device around. Just like when car phones first came out..
- Fnoord 9y agoBlackberry and Nokia also deserve mention wrt smartphone. This is the smartphone I've ever used: Nokia Communicator [1]. Though I didn't own one smile Need to see products in their zeitgeist. Not easy for everyone. Nostalgia comes into play, some people just weren't there or were too young (or have passed away). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_Communicator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_Communicator
- saagarjha 9y agoI'd agree about Blackberry, or even the Motorola RAZR–those were phones that people knew about. Palm? Not so much.
- Fnoord 9y agoWe're discussing innovation versus invention. You're sure that wasn't adblock? ABP is from 2006, and installing it wasn't easier or harder than adblock. As for iPhone, that innovated the touchscreen, specifically it was the first (US-)mainstream application of a mobile device using a capacitive touchscreen. I wonder if we should also claim it innovated the removal of the user replaceable battery or the 3.5 mm jacket. Furthermore, popularity isn't a good measurement of quality but that goes without saying.
- wnevets 9y agoIt was the first meaningful adblocker for me.
- mgbmtl 9y ago> "So could you explain us why you pick ABP over uBlock?" On a philosophical level: I support the ABP strategy of "acceptable ads". I think it's a good way to legitimize the development of adblocking extensions. They also make it easy to disable those ads. Technically: For a long time, ABP blocked more ads than uBlock. Maybe this is not as true today. For example: some adblockers didn't block ads in videos. I also appreciated the "Element Hiding Helper" extension (which has not been ported to webextensions). ABP was usually one step ahead of everyone else. On performance: Firefox had ups and downs with regards to performance, and ABP was part of the problem. I remember reading a few blog posts from Firefox about the work they did to improve that. These days, I don't notice any difference, especially with Quantum/webextensions.
- shakna 9y agoEvery major ad network has been caught distributing malware at one time or another. How do you weigh the risk of exposing yourself through acceptable ads?
- mgbmtl 9y agoI wonder if that has happened from ABP's approved networks. From what I recall, their criteria are rather strict, and I would expect a network to get banned if that happens. To be honest, pretty much the only ads I notice are sponsored results from Google (static text). I also use uMatrix for untrusted sites.
- shakna 9y ago> I notice are sponsored results from Google (static text). Google's AdSense has delivered malware in the past. And nobody is about to ban them. It doesn't matter if it's just a "text ad" either. They allow a script, which means a malware payload can get delivered. Google do a fair effort stopping malware, something like 400,000 malware ads try and host themselves through their network every day. But some do get through.
- madmax108 9y agoComments like this is why us developers can't have good things. Just like we hated dropbox because it's oh so trivial to replicate the functionality [1]. ABP took ab blocking mainstream to the level where many non-technical friends started adding ABP as the first addon when they installed Firefox/Chrome, and that's saying a lot. Is uBlock better? Yes, but uBlock probably wouldn't exist if ABP had not established the market and highlighted the need for ad blocking extensions. Happy uBlock user (and happy former ABP user). [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863
- Fnoord 9y agoNot sure what you're on about. Dropbox innovated online storage, sure (my ISP already provided telent & SSH access in 90s and I could mount my homedir with SSHFS and WebDAV but sure, relatively small ISP in small country who didn't popularize it just like tons of other efforts did not). Dropbox caught the momentum. Who's to applaud for that? Plus, first of all in order for the masses to use it securely it needs some kind of encryption for its storage. Other than that it was just a good UI for tools already in existence. WebDAV, SSHFS, rsync, or Coda (which you can see mentioned and ignored multiple times throughout the thread). For the encrypted content part, one could use GPG, but many other solutions exist as well. Now, if I was the NSA back in 2006, I'd invest in Dropbox via a proxy. Gives me free data to plow through which people otherwise store locally. And its data they want to save. Hah, I'll save it too! I knew about those risks before, so I wasn't raving about "the cloud" back in the days. Heck, I'm still skeptical. What a lot of innovation has in common is that it succeeded to market itself. No, that's not something I have a lot of respect for indeed because I don't have a whole lot with things like marketing, sales, and popularity. Sue me. I'd like to look at the technical side of things and peek at the less popular gems (though on say Kickstarter I'm wary as well). Parallel to that, it is often some kind of GUI which gets popular while it uses techniques from more abstract developments: libraries, smaller software research projects which got bought, CLI. Which important features did ABP innovate? Seeing what it added to original adblock is lackluster. And even that original adblock isn't the first browser-based adblocker. We're also talking about a time where the browser was the way to read the WWW and there wasn't a way to embed the browser in "an app" (an app? what?). Well, thinking a bit more about it, it was there (MSHTML for example). But it wasn't high quality. And you could block those ads via /etc/hosts > Yes, but uBlock probably wouldn't exist if ABP had not established the market and highlighted the need for ad blocking extensions. You mistakenly neglect to take into account that if ABP didn't exist, adblock wouldn't have been continued (ie. forked) by someone else. Parallel to that, if Linux didn't exist, the BSD lawsuit would've set that source code free, and it would've caught on from there. Its easy to say, in hindsight, "well that worked out well" but its equally easy to say "well if that didn't work out alternatively something else could've worked out". Without an in depth analysis on why that was so unique (we are talking about inventions then and patents more likely I am not going to buy your argument, sorry.