3 ms·
> * Package managers are a much more efficient way to download and install software than any way I have seen on Windows. Package managers are probably my secon
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago
> * Package managers are a much more efficient way to download and install software than any way I have seen on Windows.
Package managers are probably my second least favorite thing about using Linux as a desktop (the Linux Desktop community would be the first by a wide margin). Package managers, as implemented, are a horrible mechanism for software installation. They have all the problems of walled garden app stores, shared namespaces, and the registry. Ever see a package manager database get corrupted? Good luck ever fixing that. Want to install two different versions of the same application? Too bad, unless they're different enough that the repo maintainers decided they were separate software (only python 2/3 comes to mind). How about installing software to a different path? Nope, sorry. Good luck with make install.
There are even Linux developers sane enough to realize that this is silly, which is why you have things like AppImage. Not that more than a handful of applications are distributed that way, because Linux people quite often mistake tradition for wisdom. Oh, and the little problem of Linux not having a defined base system you can rely on.
Installers/uninstallers aren't any better, but they're only worse in different ways. That's why there's Portable Apps.
- adrianN 9y agoThey also have the benefit of walled-garden appstores: Users don't have to care about all of the things you mentioned. If I want to use Thunderbird I just apt-get install it. Normal users almost never want two versions of the same program, and they don't make install either. I've never seen a corrupted package database. I have seen lots of software on Windows that couldn't be properly deinstalled for some reason or other though.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoTypical Linux community response: "Normal users don't need that." "I've never seen it, therefore it isn't a problem." You want to talk up a system for being stable, malleable, and under the user's control, then you pull out lame excuses like that. It's no wonder Windows still kicks the Linux Desktop's ass in the market even with all its crap and having to pay for it.
- adrianN 9y agoI'm just thinking about the needs of my friends and family. I still recommend Windows to them, but the lack of a package manager is definitely an argument against Windows.