3 ms·
To the degree formal verification adds economic value to smart contracts, it will get attention. The attention is a side effect of the primary uses. To put it a
by brudgers 9y ago
To the degree formal verification adds economic value to smart contracts, it will get attention. The attention is a side effect of the primary uses. To put it another way, many contracts are agreed without having been reviewed by both parties' lawyers and negotiated back and forth. Largely this is because the economics including calculated risks, the amounts exchanged, previously established trust, etc. don't meet a party's threshold for paying for legal services because the purpose of the contract is not "to hire a lawyer."
Perhaps analogously, the business uses of encrypted communications over the web has not led banks to invest in cryptographic testing. Banks tend to buy and rely on off the shelf products and when smart contracts are adopted, they are likely to behave similarly.
[Edit: where the opportunity may lie is at the nexus of the computer science and the legal profession: Paying legal council to formally verify a smart contract.]
- nuclx 9y agoAcknowledged, that it really depends on how many people are willing to pay for verification services. Product developers may be encouraged economically or legally though. For example cryptocurrency exchanges may decide to list only Quantstamp-verified tokens. Quantstamp's CEO Richard Ma likes to compare his project to Verisign - being kind of a certificate authority for the blockchain.
- brudgers 9y agocaveat: My basis of experience is in the US. I think it is possible that the primary forces which will shape the general use/non-use of formal verification methods for smart contracts will be legal not technical. The distance from widespread adoption of formal use of smart contracts and the current state of the world is approximated by the distance between the widespread availability of legal council and the scarcity of people skilled in formal verification. It is easy for an ordinary individual to enter into an ordinary contractual agreement because lawyers are ubiquitous. It is difficult/impossible for an ordinary individual to enter into a smart contract because qualified practitioners are rare. The growth of qualified smart contract practitioners may be rapid until the point where is is deemed legal practice and becomes regulated as such. And if I were to bet, I would bet that it will be deemed legal practice once it comes on the radar of the legal system.