15 ms·
Taking a break from Adblock Plus development
- kleptako 9y agoWhat is even the point of Adblock Plus now? uBlock Origin seems so much better
- hood_syntax 9y agoIt's better than nothing for the non-expert users who don't know it's worse than other options available right now. Pretty much the only worthy use case for it
- squeaky-clean 9y agoYep, it just has a much better name than uBlock Origin.
- Jonnax 9y agoYou're asking what the point in developing alternatives are? Microsoft said the web was done at Internet Explorer 6. It looks like it was also rewritten for webextensions from that blog post.
- Spivak 9y agoBut AB isn't an alternative with pros and cons so much as it's a worse version of uBO.
- squeaky-clean 9y ago> Microsoft said the web was done at Internet Explorer 6. Yeah? And this is like OP asking "Now that Edge exists, what's the point of IE 6?"
- Moru 9y agoThe point is (as with so many things) money. If I remember right, ABP makes money by allowing "friendly" ads if they get payed for it.
- paxy 9y agoAdblock Plus sold out a long time ago by taking money from big players to let their ads through. I've been using uBlock Origin for a while and haven't looked back. Plus it's way faster and less buggy.
- jameskegel 9y agoThis is also why I switched to uBO
- def_true_false 9y agoThe ads still have to satisfy the Acceptable Ads criteria and they only have to pay when they exceed a certain volume (as in everyone besides the big players doesn't have to pay a cent). There is an opt-out checkbox in the settings.
- Nadya 9y ago>There is an opt-out checkbox in the settings. Which should be opt-in. And if nobody wants to opt-in there is the problem; it's going against what the users want. Most people never change default settings of software they install so "opt-in" may as well not have a way to "opt-out" except as a scapegoat to say you can.
- def_true_false 9y ago> Most people never change default settings of software they install so "opt-in" may as well not have a way to "opt-out" except as a scapegoat to say you can. You might as well just blame the browser vendor for not having a built-in ad blocker, URL rewriter (Google search results), not disabling 3rd party cookies or whatever else the flavour of the month in abusing-features-for-tracking is. The people who never look into the settings probably didn't install the ad blocker themselves in the first place...
- Nadya 9y ago>The people who never look into the settings probably didn't install the ad blocker themselves in the first place. Not true. Even most people who install an AdBlocker will not change their settings. If you change your settings, you're part of a very small minority. Businesses often use this to increase tips. Imagine two settings: 1) Enter your own amount (default of $0.00) 2) Four options: 15%, 20%, 25%, Other If you use #1 you'll receive fewer tips. Many people will leave it to $0.00. If you use #2, most people will tip and of those tips most will be 15-20%. [0] https://www.uie.com/brainsparks/2011/09/14/do-users-change-their-settings/ https://www.uie.com/brainsparks/2011/09/14/do-users-change-t... [1] https://www.fastcodesign.com/3022182/how-square-registers-ui-guilts-you-into-leaving-tips https://www.fastcodesign.com/3022182/how-square-registers-ui...
- TekMol 9y agoMost tech people now seem to use uBlock Origin. But I use uMatrix (from the same developer) and I am super happy with it. It took me a minute or so to understand the interface. But then it is super intuitive and exactly the way I would have designed it myself. Since I only allow the hosts that I need, I almost never see advertising. And the web is blazingly fast.
- interfixus 9y agoNot a thing! It's all you need.
- gourou 9y agoHas it got an easy way to unblock elements? Going through the every request in the logger using uBlock is pretty tedious.
- nerdponx 9y agoIt's rare to enter a filter in rule by hand in uMatrix in the first place, so you just go to the matrix and switch the box from red to green. I actually just switched from uMatrix back to uBlock Origin, because uBlock makes it easier to block individual JavaScript files, rather than blocking JS wholesale.
- bmn__ 9y agoThe matrix functionality is available in uBlock Origin, no need to install both. Simply enable advanced mode.
- ilikepi 9y agoThe matrix (and its corresponding rules syntax) in uBlock Origin is not as powerful as in uMatrix. In uBO, you can specify how to handle traffic between two origins. You can also choose which type(s) of content can be loaded from a particular origin. However, you cannot specify both at once. For example, you can't create a rule in uBO to allow only image requests from google.com to googleusercontent.com. The uMatrix rule syntax can do this, and the matrix UI does provide this capability. EDIT: formatting, typo
- romanovcode 9y agoWho is even using this anymore? ABP lost all its cred when it took money from ad business. Just use uBlock Origin.
- andrepd 9y agoUnfortunately more people are using ABP than uB. The common person googles "adblock", and ABP is usually the first result.
- toyg 9y agoTo be fair, that's because "adblock" basically defined the space. They are entitled to the name recognition, since they built it themselves. It's a bit like WinZip vs 7-Zip.
- jameskegel 9y agoGood hypothesis, but I suspect it is because of the search algorithm matching words
- toyg 9y agoYes, but "adblock" wasn't a word before AdBlock appeared, that's my point.
- DonHopkins 9y agoHowever, "adblock" was a word before "AdBlock Plus" appeared.
- votepaunchy 9y ago> Just use uBlock Origin. Has there always been a uBlock extension for Safari? That was my last holdout for using ABP. I've now manually installed the downloadable extension but ABP is prominently displayed in Apple's Safari extension app store.
- mgbmtl 9y agoMany comments are bitterly unfair against ABP. Wladimir/Eyeo changed how we use the web, gave us means to fight back against abusive advertising. They built a business model to make the extension sustainable and find a strategy to legitimate themselves, fight in the courts, etc. Not to mention that ABP never tried to close the market. Alternatives were easy to build thanks to EasyList. Today there are many alternatives to ABP. I am extremely grateful for his work. He's going on a well deserved vacation. I wish him success in his future projects. (In case anyone wonders, I am not affiliated. Just a happy user of ABP.)
- ycombobreaker 9y agoAs is frequently the case, I would give credit to Opera. They didn't have a central list but the browser had an easy-to-use element blocker that was suitable for blocking many obnoxious ads of the era. The central list ideas I've seen come out of projects built on squid proxies with known-advertiser black holes. ABP may have packaged things up nicely, I dont remember that evolution of history. And they may have other good will now to balance out the "acceptable ads" monetization. But the tools to "fight back against abusive advertising" should be credited elsewhere, IMHO.
- Fnoord 9y agoInterestingly, Opera was proprietary with its own rendering engine (Presto) and you could buy a license or you could run it for free with an ad showing (back then, ads were more profitable as well). Bummer they never open sourced Presto. Maybe that inspired Brave. Though you can't "buy" Brave.
- digi_owl 9y agoThere is also Vivaldi, funded by the same guy that formed co-founded Opera back in the day. https://vivaldi.com/ https://vivaldi.com/ Sadly it is not much more than a reskinned Chrome, same with current Opera and Brave. BTW, Opera offered "tabs" before it was a thing by making use of MDI. And it carried forward until they scrapped Presto. Similarly Vivaldi right now offers to split the viewport into multiple areas to show tabs side by side.
- merlish 9y agoAnd so, XUL is returned to the TLA pool. Anyone got any claims for what XUL should mean now?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hartator 9y ago> I also want to spend more time doing security research again, which should help pay the bills as a side effect. I would have thought he would have savings from Adblock Plus deals.
- Larrikin 9y agoI find it odd that I never see AdNauseum recommended. I switched from ABP a few months ago. Screws over trackers by making me appear interested in everything. https://adnauseam.io/ https://adnauseam.io/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aphextron 9y agoI'm confused as to what ABP does that is more useful than just adding a blocked list to your /etc/hosts file. Moreso, as to how someone could work on it for 12 years. Exactly what am I missing here?
- praneshp 9y agoEasy. A quick google and couple of clicks led me to https://github.com/adblockplus/ https://github.com/adblockplus/.
- mistercow 9y agoI don't know much about the specifics of ABP's history, but there's an obvious arms race component to ad blocking that could keep a developer busy indefinitely.
- djur 9y ago1) There's a lot of cases where blocking an entire domain is either excessive or insufficient -- important assets can be located on the same domain as ads. Adblockers can target specific files and specific elements on the page. They also provide much better ease of use for the average user than updating a hosts file. 2) The list of ad domains, URLs, and elements has to be constantly updated. The plugin has to be kept up to date with changes in browsers. Advertisers occasionally come up with new techniques to bypass or detect adblockers, so those need to be worked around.
- ivanfon 9y agoA bit unrelated, but does anyone else think the new NoScript has an absolutely awful interface?
- jhiska 9y agouMatrix is better than the new NoScript.
- calcifer 9y agoHere [1] is a post by the NoScript developer explaining how the new UI works and which buttons map to which legacy functions. After reading it and letting myself adjust for a few days, I'm perfectly comfortable with the new version. [1] https://hackademix.net/2017/12/04/noscript-quantum-vs-legacy-in-a-nutshell-2/ https://hackademix.net/2017/12/04/noscript-quantum-vs-legacy...
- thg 9y agoIt made me switch to uMatrix, which incidentally also gave me the cookie controls back that I had with the Cookie Monster extension pre-Quantum.
- INTPenis 9y agoI've always been a control freak. Long before ABP I used ipfw to block ads at home. I remember having to use Opera on my poor laptop because Firefox was becoming too bloated to run. And Opera at that time had ads in the INTERFACE of the browser. So blocking those at the router level left big blank spaces in the interfaces that were more satisfying to me than ads. So I'll give this guy credit because I used his plugin, but not too much credit when you sell out to the people you've basically made a business model out of blocking. Like many others I've switched to ublock and I'm a control freak so I also use noscript extensively. For many years now the browser has been the number one threat to the average internet user so I firmly believe in noscript. You should in fact take it even further and use qubes os.