4 ms·
The "for free" offer was temporary, and has expired. That is what matters. It even worked on pirated versions. You could even upgrade say your Windows XP to a
by Fnoord 9y ago
The "for free" offer was temporary, and has expired. That is what matters.
It even worked on pirated versions. You could even upgrade say your Windows XP to a later version (pirated or not) and then upgrade to Windows 10, for free. You get a valid license that way.
You paid 2-fold: one, you were an early adopter and therefore beta tester. Two, you paid with your privacy. The anti-spyware toolkits to remove the telemetry and other stuff weren't sophisticated. Plus, Microsoft went out of their way to sabotage these.
Linux also requires reboots because of kernel upgrades. Microsoft maybe does it more, but its also due to bad programmed 3rd party apps.
Windows has its own package manager these days. Apple's App Store and Microsoft's Windows Store are nothing more than a GUI for a package manager with some Web 2.0 (or 3.0) capabilities.
Your disadvantages are fair enough, but they can all be circumvented with say O&O ShutUp or one of the many other applications which remove the spyware/bloatware/adware.
What I f* ing hate about Windows is the lack of shell scripts and the need for Powershell and CMD.exe/*.bat. I don't want to use or (re)learn that shit. Microsoft could've adopted Bash but they went with Powershell instead. Windows Subsystem for Linux is decent, as was Cygwin, but it just isn't the same as native. The same's true for WINE. So I still prefer macOS; seems to be the best of both worlds. Although terrible for gaming. You want a gaming rig for that. Which could very well run on Linux, these days, given Steam's adoption plus WINE.
Good summary though. Could use some nuances (which I did mention) but we gotta start somewhere.
- userbinator 9y agoWin10 is still ridiculously easy to pirate, and the "assistive technology loophole" remains open. I don't think this is accidental, especially after all the underhanded tactics MS was using in an attempt to force everyone to upgrade. They probably figured monetising your personal data was worth far more than just selling Win10 licenses.
- mrighele 9y agoI think it is more about getting as much users as possible to use their store and the Windows 10 ecosystem, where they are probably planning to get most of the money (and use part of that to fund Windows development) (Yes, Windows 8 has the store too, but I think that there are a number of difference that makes the distinction relevant)
- Fnoord 9y ago> They probably figured monetising your personal data was worth far more than just selling Win10 licenses. That plus the people who run older versions of Windows already paid for it. If they're pirated they didn't paid for it, but its unlikely they will and they didn't pay the PII tax either.
- uhhhhhhh 9y agoThe free upgrade was to gain critical mass for the upgrade, they learned with vista, 8/8.1 that users were happy with xp/7 and wouldn't pay to change, even with LTS running out. Free upgrade was a way to convince a lot of those people to upgrade. I wouldn't compare it to Linux being free in any way. Microsoft needs to reboot to do most of its updates of its own tools, not because of badly programmed 3rd party apps but its own badly programmed apps. Out of the box with no additional software it still needs to reboot, it also takes forever, hijacks reboots without the users ability to override (sometimes for 30-60 minutes while it tries to install updates). Linux only needs to reboot for kernel upgrades, and even that isn't a full requirement (there are ways, but they aren't worth it, to load a new kernel without rebooting). Windows store is very far from anything like a linux package manager, and it ties you into their ecosystem without extensibility. Same with Apple. Linux package management is extensible and controllable (get packages from these sources, not those, blacklist this version, etc...) so I wouldn't consider them anywhere remotely equivalent. The obvious/known privacy issues in windows 10 can be disabled, but the fact the user has to know about find and run third party, reasonably advanced tools/scripts to stop the operating system from spying and advertising to you is absolutely not acceptable from my perspective. I guess sometimes nuance needs to be more nuanced For the record I use osx/linux for work, linux/windows at home. Windows only for games that don't work on linux yet.
- Fnoord 9y ago> The free upgrade was to gain critical mass for the upgrade, they learned with vista, 8/8.1 that users were happy with xp/7 and wouldn't pay to change, even with LTS running out. Free upgrade was a way to convince a lot of those people to upgrade. That is one of the reasons. > I wouldn't compare it to Linux being free in any way. Obviously not, given "Linux" is free as in speech. But free as in beer, when you also take into account things like support, doesn't exist. TANSTAAFL. And with macOS you pay via the hardware. > (sometimes for 30-60 minutes while it tries to install updates) On a SSD? Very unlikely, unless you're upgrading to a major version. True, Microsoft could make most of these updates being applied whilst OS is still online. You can schedule these reboots if you got Pro. macOS also sometimes needs to reboot btw. My Android reboots every week (LOS) for new firmware. What I said about apps requiring unnecesarily a reboot is true though. It used to be far more pervasive as well. > Windows store is very far from anything like a linux package manager, and it ties you into their ecosystem without extensibility. Same with Apple. Linux package management is extensible and controllable (get packages from these sources, not those, blacklist this version, etc...) so I wouldn't consider them anywhere remotely equivalent. Depends if you view it from the eyes of a power user or a casual user. The non-technical user just wants something which works ie. a good UI. App Store and Play Store provide that. Those non-technical users don't give a rat about features like "get packages from these sources, not those, blacklist this version". > The obvious/known privacy issues in windows 10 can be disabled, but the fact the user has to know about find and run third party, reasonably advanced tools/scripts to stop the operating system from spying and advertising to you is absolutely not acceptable from my perspective. Yeah, true, though the default settings aren't difficult to apply this is a feature most users won't use (just like "only" 33% of the browsers use an adblocker). That, together with their old model of selling licenses, is their business model. Its funny how in these last 2 points we both shift from PoV of power user to ordinary user and vice versa.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago> Microsoft could've adopted Bash but they went with Powershell instead. Because Powershell is a better designed, more powerful, saner implementation of the original Unix philosophy of having small tools that do one thing well and combine easily to do complicated tasks. Bash and coretools are primitive bullshit by comparison.