10 ms·
Accusers getting more money isn't good for the public. Incentive to settle without a fair trial in something as serious as sexual assault is not only not good f
by gpm 9y ago
Accusers getting more money isn't good for the public. Incentive to settle without a fair trial in something as serious as sexual assault is not only not good for the public, it's bad for the public. Due process exists for a damn good reason.
Preventing sexual assaults is good for the public, publicizing cases of sexual assaults may well have a tendency to do that.
Based on your arguments above, I would come to the conclusion that NDAs on this should be banned. But I haven't thought enough about the topic to conclude that there aren't successful counter arguments.
- marcoperaza 9y agoIt's a mutually beneficial trade. The accuser gets paid, without having to go through the rigors of a trial, where the defense counsel will impeach their character and try to convince the world that they are scheming liars or worse. The accused gets silence, instead of having their name run through the press and assumed guilty by the angry mob. Also, where did sexual assault come into this? Sexual assault is a crime. Sexual harassment isn't a crime at all; it's a civil wrong that exists only in the context of the workplace.
- vvanders 9y agoIt may be beneficial to each party but it sure as hell isn't what I want from my society. A large portion of these events have come from men with money and power. Letting them pay their way out of this just means they get to go on perpetrating the same crime on other people. That's not an acceptable outcome for sexual harassment.
- greglindahl 9y ago"Blood money" (a family forgiving a murderer in exchange for money) is a mutually beneficial trade, but is illegal in almost all countries.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dominotw 9y agoTelling some one a sex joke is a not a crime, killing someone is a crime. Edit: Sexual harassment, as such, is not a crime under state or federal law in the U.S. Murder is a Crime. Makes no sense to compare it to murder. apples oranges.
- greglindahl 9y agoThis discussion is about more than just "telling some one a sex joke".
- dominotw 9y agoyea but you are comparing something thats considered crime by federal law to something that isn't. Commiting a crime is illegal, sure. I don't understand what you were implying then.
- greglindahl 9y agoThis discussion is about allegations which range from rape down to "acting creepy." Some of these are crimes. Even if we aren't initially talking about a crime, I would find it unjust if a billionaire quietly paid off 100 victims of sexual harassment, and then committed an assault. "Who could have predicted this?!?!"
- PastaMonster 9y agoHere's a thought, define these, be specific, don't be vague: Sexual harassment, creepy, weird, offensive, hostile, racist, rape, consensual, troll, etc. All this nonsense is subjective. I mean to some people, being hostile and offensive is to have a differing opinion. For how long is this nonsense to continue? People are too afraid and walking on egg shells to have a normal human conversation. Now that IS a hostile work environment! For how long are we going to allow people to run around causing havoc and social disorder? Just the other day some people talked about a person getting accused of sexual harassment because he wore a t-shirt with a big X on it. The bandwagon effect caused yet another person to claim the t-shirt were insinuating racism because of the t-shirts colors. For crying out loud! Think the victim got reprimanded, perhaps fired. Can't remember, I was quite drunk at the time. Do remember it didn't end well though. This sort of bullshit is getting worse and more common. Companies don't want to deal with the drama so they just fires the victim of these accusations and publish a press release of which they pat themselves on the back for what they did. You dislike someone? Accuse them of rape or sexual harassment, let the bandwagon effect do the rest. The drama queens, attentions whores, liars, trolls and such make the same accusation or similar and for some reason when several people claim the same or similar means the person is guilty. Argumentum ad populum. This just pisses me off. What happened to "whoever makes a claim carries the burden of proof regardless of positive or negative content in the claim." Where's the justice? This is like the witch accusations a few decades ago. "Aww. She didn't float, she drowned, guess she wasn't a witch. Oh well, mistakes happen". "She swore revenge and cursed us while she burned to death. It can only mean one thing: she was a witch!".
- s73ver_ 9y agoAt the same time, having the victim's name plastered all over everywhere can't be good for them. Despite all the progress that's been made, we still live in a time where most victims would be blacklisted from the industry, despite nothing being their fault.
- maroonblazer 9y agoI think the reticence of victims of sexual assault being identified has more to do with the taboos around sex that still exist, at least in this country. The cult-of-virginity and inequitable attitudes toward sex that come largely from the Abrahamic religions. I think we'll eventually outgrow that.
- QAPereo 9y agoYou would be just shocked at the “cult of virginity” in places as far from Abrahamic traditions as Japan.
- sverige 9y agoI would argue that the recent wave of "guilty until proven innocent" and "guilty when accused, and more guilty if accused by more people" is even worse for public policy. Due process does indeed exist for a good reason, one of which is to prevent a situation where mere accusations have the power to destroy lives. Does this mean I think any or all of the recent high-profile cases are innocent? Oh shit, wait, it doesn't matter what I think unless I'm on a jury or in a position to hire or fire the person who is accused. It's easy to feel smugly righteous about a lot of these cases, but the reality is that it does matter if innocent people are caught up in the hysteria. I'm not quite sure when the media collectively decided that it was a good idea to promote abandoning the principle of "innocent until proven guilty," but the long-term consequences of this are likely to play out in very unexpected and ugly ways that will affect most or all of us in areas that have nothing to do with sexual harassment.
- greglindahl 9y agoSociety has not abandoned innocent until proven guilty in court cases. That's where that standard applies.
- jeffdavis 9y agoCourts do have stricter standards for admission of evidence and verdicts. But the basic innocent-by-default is a general principle that should apply pretty much everywhere. And there should be consistency and standards in media reporting of allegations, and for HR decisions.
- geofft 9y agoThe thing about innocent-by-default is that false accusations are also a serious crime with serious penalties (for good reason), and if you believe that the accused is affirmatively innocent, you have to believe that the accused is guilty. The reason that courts, specifically, do not have this paradox is that "innocent" simply means "we do not have the evidence to justify using the extraordinary punishment powers reserved to the government alone against this person". Yes, there's such a thing as getting a court to declare you affirmatively innocent, but usually they say "not guilty," which is an important philosophical distinction. So a court can very well decide that a person has not been proven guilty of their crime, and that their accuser has not been proven guilty of malice, either. But humans don't work like that. When we think "innocent," we don't think "I have insufficient data," we think "they didn't do it". It is arguably a flaw in human thinking, but it's a flaw we have to live with and work with. And a world in which all who accuse people of sexual harassment are effectively guilty-until-proven-innocent in the court of public opinion isn't a great world, either.
- anon12345690 9y agoI bet youll change your mind if/when you get accused, especially if its false. Guess you should hope that never happens then right?
- rectang 9y agoThis knife cuts both ways: you might change your mind if you were subject to sexual abuse. "If a conservative is a liberal who's been mugged, a liberal is a conservative who's been arrested." -- Tom Wolfe
- geofft 9y agoThis makes no sense to me. Especially if it's false? If I'm correctly accused, I hope I get what I deserve! This feels like saying, "I bet you'll change your mind about manslaughter laws when if/when you accidentally run someone over with your car." No, I'm pretty sure I'll be preoccupied by feeling terrible for killing someone. And I understand that false accusations happen occasionally, and I am willing to take that risk because a world that insists on zero false positives has a ton of false negatives. It would be hypocritical for me to not accept the consequences if it happens to affect me - I am not advocating for others anything I could not accept for myself. But I can absolutely accept that if I am a visible leader of an organization, or a manager of people, or in some other role of trust, and I am accused of something I believe I didn't do, the best thing for me to do for the organization is to step aside. (It is not like I can guarantee that I will even live to see tomorrow, so anything that I care about, I should arrange so that my personal involvement is not critical.) But more than that, it's entirely possible (though I have zero reason to expect it to happen) that some behavior I thought was reasonable will be seen by the world as unreasonable. And if that happens, I am happy to accept the consequences. My goal is making the world a better place, not making myself powerful/comfortable at the expense of other people. If removing myself from positions of trust to prevent my behavior from hurting the world is the right thing for me to do, why should I shrink away from it?
- anon12345690 9y agoexcept we designed the justice system so that it's better to let 10 guilty people go than let 1 innocent person suffer the rest of your comment just sounds ridiculous, hurting the world? im sure you realize not everyone else has the same attitude and arent going to throw away their livelihood because of a false accusation. that's not moral high ground, its just pathetic
- dominotw 9y ago> something as serious as sexual assault This article is about "sexual harassment" which isn't illegal according to federal law. You are conflating it with "sexual assault" which is a crime.
- gpm 9y agoYou're right, I wrote the wrong thing, they are substantially different things and shouldn't be confused. It changes absolutely nothing about what I intended to say, sexual harassment is serious, it still goes through the court system, due process still applies, preventing it is good for the public.
- astura 9y agohttps://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/sexual_harassment.cfm https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/sexual_harassment.cfm >It is unlawful to harass a person (an applicant or employee) because of that person’s sex. Harassment can include “sexual harassment” or unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical harassment of a sexual nature... Although the law doesn’t prohibit simple teasing, offhand comments, or isolated incidents that are not very serious, harassment is illegal when it is so frequent or severe that it creates a hostile or offensive work environment or when it results in an adverse employment decision (such as the victim being fired or demoted).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- walshemj 9y agoAh so you'd force some one to go to court - what happens when they kill themselves feel good about that would you ?