3 ms·
My GF is in med school, so I now know why it's vastly smarter to go into nursing than medicine, why so many doctors are unhappy, and why Penelope Trunk is right
by jseliger 16y ago
My GF is in med school, so I now know why it's vastly smarter to go into nursing than medicine, why so many doctors are unhappy, and why Penelope Trunk is right when she says that medical and law school force you to overinvest: http://blog.penelopetrunk.com/2009/02/03/dont-try-to-dodge-the-recession-with-grad-school/ http://blog.penelopetrunk.com/2009/02/03/dont-try-to-dodge-t... .
In addition, I know that you don't want residents making major care decisions on their own.
- megablast 16y agoMY ex was a surgeon. I am intrigued to hear your reason about why so many doctors are unhappy? More than any other overly bureaucratic profession?
- potatolicious 16y agoThe same reason why many engineers are unhappy - it's a professional that demands a lot of brain time and clock time, both leading to underdevelopment in other areas of your life. I'm fairly active in the volunteering community here in Seattle, and there are certainly many "meat market" volunteering groups here (read: ones where the implied purpose is dating, as opposed to just strictly doing good work). I've had them come through the places I normally work at, and the demographic usually breaks down to: - doctors - other medical professionals - lawyers - engineers Rarely do I see any other type. I suspect demanding professions make you a bit of a loner/shut-in/hermit, and thus unhappy.
- megablast 16y agoInteresting idea, I was concerned you were singling out one profession, when you are actually talking about all higher professions then, such as law, etc...
- zackattack 16y agoI am fascinated by this notion of 'meat market' volunteering groups. Can you provide me links to some? I don't live in Seattle, but I am very curious from a satirist's perspective.
- potatolicious 16y agoGenerally speaking, the more "gritty" a job is, the less meat market-y it is. I did a short bit serving food at a shelter - not a soul there was there to hook up. You walk into that place and the despair just hits you, I'm not sure if anyone would be in the mood for hitting on each other. I don't have a link handy - the last time one came through they invited me to join, but I never even visited their website. Generally though they present themselves as "networking for young professionals" groups, though seeing them in action it's more accurately "lonely single professionals seeking love". Not that I'm knocking it - whatever floats their boat. I've heard this from other volunteers, though I've never experienced it for myself, but religious charities are also major meat-markets. In Seattle we have the church sandwich brigades (they drive vans of sack lunches around to the local parks filled with homeless folk) - and having seen them around a few times it's definitely very meat-market-y. Ahhh, if only I would pretend to be Christian :)
- philwelch 16y agoThat's actually a big purpose of church. If you're Catholic, you go to church functions hoping to find a nice Catholic boy/girl to marry; if you're Mormon, you go to church functions hoping to find a nice Mormon boy/girl to marry; etc.
- potatolicious 16y agoSo where do atheists go to find a nice atheist boy/girl to marry? :P
- neutronicus 16y agoit's vastly smarter to go into nursing than medicine My girlfriend just graduated from nursing school, so I know a lot of recently-graduated nursing students. They do not agree with you. At all. Doctors don't have to clean feces off of people who are too obese to move.
- jseliger 16y agoI asked her about this: "Doctors don't have to clean feces off of people who are too obese to move." She said, "Yes, we do. Not only have I had to do just that, but I've had to put my finger in the rectum of an obese, eighty-year-old man, and literally pick out an impacted wedge of poop, after which, I had to insert a tube that I squirted water into and use a bucket to catch what came out. Later in the day, when I was checking on somebody, they vomited on me. And this was at the end of a thirty-hour shift, during which time I had slept like thirty minutes. Bite me. These were not isolated incidents." The other thing she's said to me (a lot) is that nurses can easily make $50K a year right out of undergrad (or more), and she's actually right about this because I didn't believe her at first: http://www.payscale.com/best-colleges/degrees.asp http://www.payscale.com/best-colleges/degrees.asp ; the median salary for beginning nurses is $52,700. If they don't like what they're doing, they can switch the kind of nursing they do (while being paid) or retrain as nurse anesthetists or nurse practitioners, who make over $100K a year. In contrast, doctors have to go to med school for four years, incur a lot of debt, and do a hellacious residency for three to nine years. Nurses can get jobs with 500 hours of clinical practice; doctors need more like 20,000K hours: http://www.aafp.org/online/en/home/media/kits/fp-np/educational-training.html http://www.aafp.org/online/en/home/media/kits/fp-np/educatio... . In any event, there are shitty parts of nursing, but it offers good pay for reasonable amounts of work.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]